70 of 73 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best study of the "Treasure Fleet" voyages by a wide margin, May 25, 2006
This review is from: Zheng He: China and the Oceans in the Early Ming Dynasty, 1405-1433 (Library of World Biography Series) (Paperback)
The table of contents, which I've reproduced at the end of this, gives a good idea of the book's coverage and organization. Dreyer is a professor of history at the University of Miami, where he teaches Asian history, Chinese history, and military history. His previous publications include studies of early Ming political history (based on his 1971 Harvard dissertation) and China's experience of war in the first half of the 20th century.
The author surveys the secondary literature and draws upon some earlier reconstructions which he finds credible and consistent, particularly in the matter of the voyages' itineraries. However, he relies on the primary sources (and a smattering of archeological evidence) in every respect. Indeed, at the end of the book he provides his own critical translations of the key primary sources.
He works through the background and issues in a methodical manner, carefully evaluating the evidence in light of his extensive knowledge of early Ming history. Naturally this does not make exciting beach reading, but Dreyer does a good job of making the exposition clear and straightforward. The glossary provides brief entries for all of the places and people mentioned, in the event one loses track.
The only lapses I could see seem to be in his knowledge of European history, where he repeats a few obsolete views: "[W]hat drew the Western powers into the Indian Ocean and Southeast Asia in the first place was the wealth they could gain by controlling the seaborne trade of the region." (p. 8) "[B]roadside firing and line ahead tactics ... only began in European waters almost two centuries after Zheng He." (p. 56) These are minor issues of degree that do not materially affect the value of the book.
One very welcome surprise is Dreyer's judicious and well-informed evaluation of the design of the ships of the Treasure Fleets.
Dreyer does not address the speculations and assertions of Gavin Menzies regarding far-flung voyaging, except to remark dryly on pages 29-30 that they rest on an assumption that exploration was a major purpose of the voyages (an assumption Dreyer demolishes quite thoroughly) and on pages 182-3 that it is very unlikely that the ships could have gotten far along Menzies' track before coming to grief. Surely the Chinese, with their nautical knowledge and skills, would have gone about exploration in a very different manner, had they had the intent.
Throughout, the author is skeptical in the best sense, carefully examining and weighing the evidence on each point, unswayed by preconceptions. This leads him to many conclusions that diverge from those of previous authors, always convincingly. Unless and until new evidence appears (possibly from marine archeology) this is likely to remain the definitive treatment of this interesting and revealing facet of Chinese history.
One of the best services Dreyer performs is to cut through the layers of projection and romance that have been overlaid on these voyages in respect of their purpose, conduct, and consequences. He insists, with strong documentary support, that the purpose was "to enforce outward compliance with the forms of the Chinese tributary system by the show of an overwhelming armed force" [p. 163, and passim] as a means of bolstering the Yongle emperor's political position and perhaps self-esteem. Dreyer scotches the notion that these were voyages of discovery or exploration in the European sense, adventurous though they were in their own terms. He makes clear their astronomical expense and how they contributed to economic pressures on the empire, and stresses that there were very real practical reasons (in addition to the undoubted cultural and political ones) for the opposition to them expressed by many senior scholar-bureaucrats. And he shows that far from being peaceful and amicable diplomatic missions they involved heavy measures of coercive force. It certainly lay within China's power to have constructed an Asian maritime empire much as the Europeans later did, but not within China's powers of conception. It equally was open to the Chinese to have gone exploring at least as widely was the Europeans were to, but that also was unthinkable in Beijing. And no one in China could do such things without imperial command.
The book is modestly but well produced, with good binding and stock. There is one overall map, a diagram showing Dreyer's concept of the design of a "treasure ship," and a few relevant illustrations. Oddly the house style seems to eschew source notes, but it is usually possible to identify sources in the general notes at the back of the book. Overall, the publishers deserve thanks for a valuable and high-quality monograph issued at a reasonable price.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. The Enigma of Zheng He.
The Chinese Tributary System and the Purpose of Zheng He's Voyages.
Traditional Chinese Interpretations of Zheng He's Career.
Zheng He's Voyages and Western Imperial Expansion.
Zheng He's Voyages and the Course of Chinese History.
Historical Problems in the Interpretation of Zheng He's Career.
II. Zheng He's Early Life and His Patron Emperor Yongle.
The Fall of the Yuan and the Rise of Zhu Yuanzhang to 1368.
The Reign of Emperor Hongwu, 1368-1398.
Civil War, 1398-1402.
Yongle's Reign as Emperor, 1402-1424.
III. China and the Asian Maritime World in the Time of Zheng He.
The Purpose of Zheng He's Voyages.
Patterns of Trade in the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea.
The Malay-Indonesian World in the Hongwu Era.
Southern India and Ceylon in the Time of Zheng He.
IV. Sailing to India: Zheng He's First, Second and Third Voyages.
The First Voyage, 1405-1407.
The Second Voyage, 1407-1409.
The Third Voyage, 1409-1411.
V. Sailing to Africa: Zheng He's Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Voyages.
The Fourth Voyage, 1412/14-1415.
The Fifth Voyage, 1417-1419.
The Sixth Voyage, 1421-1422.
The Last Years of the Yongle Reign, 1422-1424.
VI. The Ships and Men of Zheng He's Fleets.
Dimensions and Displacements of the Treasure Ships.
Masts and Sails.
Shipbuilding Notices in the Taizong Shilu.
Shipbuilding Costs.
Numbers of Ships in Each of the Voyages.
Personnel.
VII. Zheng He's Career after 1424 and His Final Voyage.
Ming China in the Hongxi (1424-25) and Xuande (1425-35) Reigns.
Zheng He's Career from 1424 to 1430.
Zheng He's Inscriptions at Liujiagang and Changle.
Zheng He's Seventh and Final Voyage, 1431-1433.
VIII. The Legacy of Zheng He.
Appendix. Translations of Primary Sources.
Zheng He's Biography in Mingshi 304.2b-4b.
Zheng He's 1431 Inscriptions.
Glossary.
Note on Sources.
Index.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good study of the treasure fleet and the man who led it, February 9, 2010
This review is from: Zheng He: China and the Oceans in the Early Ming Dynasty, 1405-1433 (Library of World Biography Series) (Paperback)
In the early 15th century, the coastal states of Southeast Asia and the Indian Ocean were the sites of a remarkable event, as they received repeated visitations by a large fleet of Chinese ships. Dispatched by the order of the Ming emperor Yongle, they consisted of thousands of men on board the largest wooden ships ever built. The expeditions were all commanded by Zheng He, a eunuch with a long history of service to the emperor. Yet in spite of the dramatic novelty of the voyages, they and their commander received only the scantiest attention in the Chinese historical sources, with many of their exploits becoming as much myth as reality. In this book, Edward Dreyer attempts to uncover the man behind the myths, assessing his goals and achievements by evaluating them in the context of his times.
To do this, Dreyer reconstructs Zheng's life as completely as possible from the available contemporary and near-contemporary sources. This provides at best only a sketchy outline, which the author then fills in with a broader analysis of the voyage, the ships and men involved, and the broader background of events. He argues that, contrary to later writers, Zheng's expeditions were not voyages of exploration or assertions of naval hegemony but an effort to extend the Chinese tributary system to that part of the world. Though far less inspiring a motivation than the others, it is one that helps to explain the subsequent abandonment of the effort after a final voyage in 1431-33, as the returns were far outweighed by the considerable expense of the effort - a factor that became critical during a time of enormous expenditure on military expeditions to Mongolia and construction of a new imperial capital in Beijing.
Though thin in some areas and repetitive of its major points, Dreyer has succeeded in writing a clear and accessible study of a legendary figure. Though it, readers can better understand both the scope of his achievement and why it was not followed up by Yongle's successors. For anyone seeking to understand the early Ming dynasty or why a tantalizing opportunity was never fully exploited, Dreyer's clear, thoroughly researched, and well-argued study is an excellent place to begin.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
