82 of 83 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Zone convert extremely disappointed, June 14, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Zone Food Blocks: The Quick and Easy, Mix-and-Match Counter for Staying in the Zone (Hardcover)
This book should get the prize for completely BAD representation of information. I am a total zone convert, it has changed my life, but if I had this book to start with, it would have hindered, NOT helped me in my path. Most of the measurements are not helpful, they are not consistent. Some are in cups, some are in ozs, some in slices, all in decimal amounts (where is my .1 cup measure?). They are in block amounts rather than serving amounts. (Is it useful to know that .8 of a 3/4 oz slice is 1 block? or is it useful to know how much 1 slice is???). Some items are in the wrong group. Ice Cream is a *protien* rather than a carb as it belongs. The foods have a decidedly east coast bent as many of the foods listed are either not available on the west coast, or common west coast brands are missing.
I was really looking forward to this book to help out friends and family members that want to start the zone. I was very disappointed. Mastering the Zone still represents the best effort by Dr. Sears, though I would hope that before he is allowed to write again, that he gets an qualified editor that can help in the presentation of ideas.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
His other 3 books are great......but pass on this one!!, July 1, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Zone Food Blocks: The Quick and Easy, Mix-and-Match Counter for Staying in the Zone (Hardcover)
Well, after three well-written, very successful books, Sears's latest publication leaves his ardent followers (of which I am one) very disappointed. The book can basically be described as an unedited (numerous errors exist) computer dump of food counts, and a poorly organized one at that. It appears to this reviewer that those responsible for this new release were too anxious to get it on the market. Also, I understand from individuals who have postings on Sears's web site, that the first printings of this book contain errors in the amounts listed for fresh fruits and vegetables. Apparently, the block amounts listed for these foods do not take into account their fiber content, hence the amounts given are too small. Make sure when (if) you order that you are ordering the corrected version.
The book itself is printed on cheap quality paper. I was hoping for a book that would stand up to the rigors of daily kitchen use (good quality cookbook-type). This one will not, as the ink has already started to smear on the paperback-quality pages of my copy. I was also hoping for an easy to use reference, and all I can say to that end is, at least the items are alphabetized. Sears organizes the food entries into Carbs, Proteins, or Fats. On the surface that would seem to make sense because, based on the principles of The Zone, you want to include "blocks" of each of these macronutrients in everything you eat. But, on the practical side, this limited organization makes the book very difficult and frustrating to use. If you want to look up, for example, BEANS, you must sort through ALL carbohydrates beginning with "B", not just the vegetables.
Finally, I cannnot understand why Sears, who tells his followers not to obsess about exact amouts, would not have rounded some of his measurements to the nearest half, third, or even quarter - 0.9 of an apple? - I think I'll eat the whole thing.
The book would have been much better if it had been printed on kitchen-quality paper, divide! d with colorful tabs into meats, dairy, vegetables, fruits, etc., and would have been LESS precise, rounding to the nearest common full measurement.
Pass on this one, wait for the recall, and hope Sears and company start over.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Zone help line says book will be revised because of errors, September 10, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Zone Food Blocks: The Quick and Easy, Mix-and-Match Counter for Staying in the Zone (Hardcover)
After noting several mistakes I called the help line. They weren't real helpful. Said that book contains many errors (including the one I was asking about - Zone preferred items were suppose to be checked) and that a revision was in the works with no idea when it would be out. She suggested I return the book for a refund. GOOD ADVICE! If there are so many errors they should do a recall!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No