Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
97 of 110 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Mad Race to Thwart a Conspiracy, June 24, 2005
This taut thriller about a conspiracy of (yet another) secret religious sect of the Catholic Church delivers all the punch of a well-plotted novel. Grayson Pierce, an operative for the U.S. top secret Sigma Force, is called to command a group of two other agents, Monk and Kat, to investigate the mysterious massacre of church goers in Cologne, Germany and the theft of the cathedral's relics, the bones of the Magi. They are assigned to work with an intel group from the Vatican, Monsignor Vigor Verona and his niece Rachel, a lieutenant in the Carabinieri Corps. The five quickly discover that the deaths in Cologne were carried out by the Imperial Dragon Court, a secret society dating back to the Middle Ages, and that the theft of relics in that church was just the beginning. Through Vigor's vast knowledge of church symbolism, history, and architecture, and the others' combined education in chemistry, physics, and engineering, they begin to solve the mystery that could lead to Armageddon. Their lives are threatened at every turn as they race the ruthless members of the Dragon Court to uncover the next clue.
Umberto Eco, with his novel Foucault's Pendulum, launched the literary premise of a complex religious conspiracy by a secret sect, and Dan Brown popularized it with The Da Vinci Code. James Rollins's book is much better than The Da Vinci Code because of its smooth writing and plotting and better integrated historical details. While he cannot compete with Eco in the writing and density of thought, Rollins's approach allows for a breathtakingly fast pace and incredible suspense. Sometimes the connections between the past and the riddle at hand are tenuous, although the information itself is usually fascinating. Rollins moves convincingly from one point of view to another, using all to satisfying effect, but he falls flat when trying to stir up the emotional connections between characters. Not to worry, though, since the action easily distracts the reader from this flaw. The truly intriguing aspect of this novel is that every character believes that Biblical Armageddon will occur if the Dragon Court solves the final riddle. Although the clues are solved using science, they lead to what is ultimately a supernatural mystery.
Map of Bones is billed as "the first in the exciting new Sigma adventure series" so it should be interesting to see how Rollins follows up this series debut. He'll need to deepen the characterization of his Sigma Force if he wants his readers to identify with them throughout a series, but his excellent storytelling ability will serve him well.
This novel makes fantastic escapist reading and yet delivers some intellectual depth to distinguish it from many other thrillers. Highly recommended for readers looking for a good thriller.
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Average storytelling at best., January 22, 2006
Rollins is an author whose works consistently shows potential but always falls short of realizing it. Having read several of his other works I decided to give Map Of Bones a try, hoping this time I wouldn't be met by two dimensional characters, which is his main weakness as a writer.
Alas, once again he puts forth characters that are at best caricatures. The good guys are all nice and well-mannered, just as the bad guys are all sadistic serial-killers. He overdoes this good versus bad thing to the point that it becomes laughable.
The good guys are all blessed with an exceptional high IQ, or so Rollins tells us explicitly, yet their dialogues never shows it.
Things like that keep the story from taking off as it is hard to impossible to get the feeling that you are dealing with live human beings, an illusion that a good writer manages to evoke.
This is not to say that Map Of Bones is all bad, far from it, it has much going for it. It has an exciting plot and does keep you wondering what will happen next, the reason why I finished it. So, if what you want is an adventure story, and don't mind characters who lack depth then this certainly is worth the purchase.
|
|
|
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fun Story, But VERY Sloppy Research, July 28, 2005
I enjoyed Mr. Rollins previous book, Sandstorm, so much that I was really looking forward to this one. Mr. Rollins' research was much sloppier in this book, as anyone with a Catholic school background will immediately notice. Indeed, the glaring and numerous inaccuracies about European history and Catholic tradition became such a distraction that I was unable to ever really get into this novel, even though it has a good story.
For example, it attempting to establish that Rachel (the heroine) is some kind of archeological dynamo at the beginning of Chapter 2, he has her utter Dante's famous phrase, "Lasciate ogni speranza, voi ch'entrate!" ("Abandon all hope, ye who enter!") A learned "professor" marvels at Rachel's knowledge of the quote "in the original Latin no less" (page 37). This is an amazing bit of praise -- as any reader of 2004 break-away best seller, The Dante Club (by Matthew Pearl) will notice -- since that famous quote is in Italian -- not Latin! Sadly, throughout the book Rachel is straining to interject awkward classical Latin two-word phrases (obviously culled from a "famous quotes" book) even though the subject that she is discussing is medieval -- not classical -- in nature.
The errors are not limited to problems with the author's use (and recognition) of foreign languages. The plot of this novel is centered around the theft and possession of certain holy relics (viz., the "Bones" in the title). You'd think the author would get his information right at least as it relates to relics, right? Wrong. In the opening chapters, he makes some sweeping pronouncements about the use of relics in Catholic church altars which, although they may be arcane rules, also have not been rules for years.
Although the above criticisms may seem somewhat petty, Mr. Rollins' sloppy research cannot be forgiven when it affects major plot points -- especially those occurring at the very beginning of the book. For example, the story essentially begins when nearly everybody attending a mass is killed after ingesting a batch of "poisoned" communion wafers at a cathedral. The only people who live through this episode of mass murder are those that did not take communion -- and the archbishop who was officiating at the mass! Indeed, the old archbishop begins arguing with the assailants (in LATIN, or course) afterwards until he is finally shot in the head. Even the most basic of research or the simple attendance of a single Catholic mass would reveal that the priests and officiants are the very first people to ingest the communion wafer at a mass, and that therefore, there does not appear to be any reason whatsoever that the archbishop would have had an opportunity to argue with the murders once his flock had perished.
When so many minor things are wrong with the story, how can I be expected to buy his explanations of the more complex components of his technological thriller?
In the end, I gave the book "3 Stars" because the story is undeniably good. However, if you know your European history or if you have even a rudimentary knowledge of Catholic tradition, this book simply does not hold water and is more of a "1 or 2 Star". Pick up Sandstorm instead.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|