|
|
119 of 121 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Superb Book, April 17, 2000
This book is the one text I'd give to someone who aspires to learn the mathematics of general relativity. Aimed at a reader who has a grasp of three-d vector calculus and a firm basis in special relativity, this book is an ideal bridge between a text like French's "Special Relativity" and the Big Book--Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler's "Gravitation." Schutz says that his book should prepare a reader to move confidently into texts like MTW, and I think he's spot on. I'd put Rindler's "Essential Relativity" at a slightly lower level than this text. Rindler demands less of the reader going in, and probably gives more in the way of conceptual intuition regarding black holes and modern cosmological models, but Rindler doesn't leave the reader with the mathmatical understanding that Schutz does. One could stop after Rindler with a sense of having learned some things--one ends Schutz with a sense of being prepared to learn a lot more.The first chapters refreshes the reader's mind about SR, and then proceeds to build tensor analysis in SR. What makes this book stand out it uses the language is that of modern GR--one learns the language of one-forms and vectors, not co- and contravariant vectors. Cultivating a geometrical intuition about these strange new objects (a la MTW) is given equal or greater weight than developing skills at index manipulation. Those are two reasons I'd recommend this book over Foster and Nightingale, for example. For me personally, Schutz's path toward the mathematics of curvature beginning with Cartesian and polar coordinates in 2d was easier to follow than any treatment I've seen. Once the mathematical structure (which is the book's core) has been laid out, the physics that follows is a bit different than most texts: slightly curved spacetimes, then the field equations, and then chapters on gravitational radiation and stellar theory. I liked that. Gravitational waves are a sexy topic and an area of lively research, so putting the chapter where it is left me feeling that I'd really accomplished someting by getting that far, and had caught at least a glimpse of the frontier. The last two chapters--Schwarzchild spacetime and cosmology--are still good, but also more abbreviated; one can't fit everything in. (MTW clearly tried, and although it's the book I'd have on a desert island if I had only one GR book there, Schutz has a big edge over MTW in being portable.) This book has a good selection of problems, with brief hints and answers. It's excellent for self study--I think actually having it as a course material with a teacher would be rapture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|