The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire (Hardcover)

~ Edward N. Luttwak (Author)

Editorial Reviews

Review

The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire is written with a profound knowledge of the field, a thorough mastery of the sources and secondary literature, and a lively and engaging style that both specialists and general readers will appreciate.
--Peter B. Golden, Rutgers University (20091122)

Edward Luttwak makes a persuasive, well-documented argument that the Byzantines--given the continuity of their institutions, their sense of a historical mission, and their own manuals on statecraft and warfare--had a coherent strategy that enabled them to preserve an empire shielded by few geographical barriers and surrounded by a host of hostile neighbors.
--Eric McGeer, author of Sowing the Dragon's Teeth: Byzantine Warfare in the Tenth Century (20091220)

If there's a single overriding lesson for Americans from Byzantium in Luttwak's fine and definitive work, it is that we ought to make use of Byzantine methods so that we may never be in Byzantine straits.
--Joshua Trevino (New Ledger )

Luttwak tells his story well. He is especially good on fine detail. Whether describing the lethal "composite reflex bow" used by Hun archers or the complex but surprisingly efficient Byzantine tax system, he is both vivid and exact...Though no Hun bows survive, Luttwak's meticulous descriptions convey their deadly efficiency. It is through such details that a modern reader captures some sense of the sheer terror that those ancient raiders inspired. Even on obscure theological matters, such as the wrangles over "monotheletism"--the proposition that Christ had two natures, human and divine, united by a single will--he is refreshingly lucid...Notwithstanding its erudition, this is an impassioned book, and all the better for that...Historically remote as they are, the Byzantines may have something to teach Americans about long-term survival.
--Eric Ormsby (Wall Street Journal 20100312)

Nothing Luttwak writes is uninteresting...His ventures into the military history of antiquity and the Middle Ages are unlike the work of academic historians and equally unlike the superficial surveys produced by journalists for the general public. Thanks to his polyglot reading, his many scholarly contacts and his opinionated style, he succeeds wondrously in reaching both specialists and the public...If the practicality of what he suggests is less than obvious in any given contemporary crisis, the historical analysis which has brought him to his conclusions is exciting, challenging and erudite. It is rare and refreshing to find such deep research on a great empire of the past deployed so eloquently for the guidance of the beleaguered governments of the present.
--Glen Bowersock (London Review of Books )

One of America's leading strategic minds...The traditional stereotype of the Byzantine Empire, established by Edward Gibbon in his Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, has undergone considerable revision of late, thanks to a renaissance of Byzantine studies, to which Edward Luttwak has now made an important contribution. Luttwak had long promised a sequel to Grand Strategy of the Roman Empire covering the Roman Empire in the East from the fourth through the fifteenth centuries, and finally it is here.
--Stuart Koehl (Weekly Standard 20100211)

The volume's grand sweep is appealing. It unpicks the hard-nosed considerations underpinning the Byzantine complexities of the strategies that permitted the eastern Empire to outlast its western counterpart by almost a millennium, introducing key diplomatic factors such as Christianity, prestige and marriage, surveying the tradition of Byzantine military analysis, and highlighting the issues at the heart of Byzantine survival.
--Michael Whitby (Times Literary Supplement )

This book is good history as well as being an insightful commentary on strategy...American soldiers and diplomats who helped turn enemies into allies in creating the Sunni Awakening in Iraq will recognize and empathize with what the Eastern Romans did for centuries. This is a timely and relevant work...Luttwak does an excellent job of describing the intelligence system of the Eastern empire, from its tactical use of scouting and patrolling to its strategic use of spies and double agents in the courts of its enemies...Luttwak does a great service in giving us a readable account of how the Byzantines managed national-security strategy in a way that should be useful to contemporary soldiers and civilian policymakers. It is also a very good read.
--Gary Anderson (Washington Times 20100301)

When students of grand strategy search the past for lessons, rarely do they look to the Byzantine Empire. Luttwak, who wrote a well-regarded history of the grand strategy of ancient Rome, thinks this is a mistake. In this exhaustive study, he shows how the rulers of the eastern half of the late Roman Empire were the true masters of the craft. Although the Byzantine Empire occupied a more vulnerable geographic position than its western counterpart, it lasted almost 1,000 years longer. Luttwak argues that the Byzantines survived by relying less on brute military power and more on allies, diplomacy, and the containment of their enemies. They were able, he claims, "to generate disproportionate power from whatever military strength could be mustered, by combining it with the art of persuasion, guided by superior information." The book makes this argument through fascinating chapters on religion and statecraft, envoys, dynastic marriages, and the Byzantine art of war, as well as through evocative details about weapons, military tactics, and taxes. Although the Byzantine Empire did not have a foreign minister, intelligence agencies, or theories of "smart power," it certainly acted as if it did.
--G. John Ikenberry (Foreign Affairs )

Product Description

In this book, the distinguished writer Edward Luttwak presents the grand strategy of the eastern Roman empire we know as Byzantine, which lasted more than twice as long as the more familiar western Roman empire, eight hundred years by the shortest definition. This extraordinary endurance is all the more remarkable because the Byzantine empire was favored neither by geography nor by military preponderance. Yet it was the western empire that dissolved during the fifth century. The Byzantine empire so greatly outlasted its western counterpart because its rulers were able to adapt strategically to diminished circumstances, by devising new ways of coping with successive enemies. It relied less on military strength and more on persuasion—to recruit allies, dissuade threatening neighbors, and manipulate potential enemies into attacking one another instead. Even when the Byzantines fought—which they often did with great skill—they were less inclined to destroy their enemies than to contain them, for they were aware that today’s enemies could be tomorrow’s allies. Born in the fifth century when the formidable threat of Attila’s Huns were deflected with a minimum of force, Byzantine strategy continued to be refined over the centuries, incidentally leaving for us several fascinating guidebooks to statecraft and war.

The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire is a broad, interpretive account of Byzantine strategy, intelligence, and diplomacy over the course of eight centuries that will appeal to scholars, classicists, military history buffs, and professional soldiers.

(20091028)

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 512 pages
• Publisher: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press; 1St Edition edition (November 1, 2009)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0674035194
• ISBN-13: 978-0674035195
• Product Dimensions: 9.4 x 6.2 x 1.7 inches
• Shipping Weight: 2.1 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 4.7 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (12 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #6,677 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

  Popular in these categories: (What's this?)

  #1 in	Books > History > World > Byzantine
  #1 in	Books > Arts & Photography > Schools, Periods & Styles > Byzantine
  #4 in	Books > Nonfiction > Politics > International > Diplomacy

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

32 of 34 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Lessons from the ancients, applicable to our modern world, December 14, 2009

By	J. A Magill (Sacramento, CA USA) - See all my reviews (TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)    (VINE VOICE)

What can America learn about strategy from a vanished empire whose very name means "devious?" Almost everything, according to "The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire," by Edward Luttwak. A leading strategic theorist and intellectual provocateur, Luttwak's previous writings include the much praised "Strategy: the Logic of War and Peace" and "Coup d'état: A Practical Handbook." Here he brings his keen research and analytical skills to explaining how Byzantium, surrounded by hostile powers that possessed superior natural resources, managed to not only survive but flourish, outlasting the Western Roman Empire by almost 1,000 years.

Yet this work is not an academic exercise - throughout Luttwak offers an implicit roadmap for US decision makers, a plea that they shed their narrow dogmatisms with its search for "the end of history," and replace it with Byzantium's subtle practicality. "The Byzantines knew better. They knew that peace was a temporary interruption of war, that as soon as one enemy was defeated, another would take its place...Even the destruction of the enemy was not a definitive gain, because in the unending war, yesterday's enemy could become the best ally." And as everywhere, their success abroad rested on sound finances at home, Byzantium's advanced tax collecting methods, unmatched at the time, providing the Empire a deep purse.

Practical rules abound. Avoid war at all costs (since war is expensive and even victory's results are unpredictable). Maintain a military as if war could come at any time (which is the most efficient deterrence). Use force prudently. If enemy strategies or techniques prove superior, adopt them, without hesitation. Invest in gathering intelligence. Embrace diplomacy. Eschew occupations and over-commitment in favor of flexibility and mobility.

For Luttwak, realism and judiciousness are the hallmarks of a successful sustainable national program. Nor is this an abstract book. Leader by leader, conflict by conflict the author distills valuable lessons as well as offering an excellent overview of the empire's strengths and weaknesses, their successes and failures, often drawing useful analogies to more recent history. Even details that many think would be dry - the importance of composite bow technology and the over-emphasis on the stirrup by historians - are presented in a way that is not only digestible, but entertaining. His command of detail, from small unit tactics, to the impact of epidemics on Byzantium, to immigration patterns of the tribes of the Asian steppes, would make this amateur historian the envy of most professionals.

Perhaps most interesting, Luttwak shows how the empire was several times driven to the brink, only to reemerge more vibrant than before. In a period marred by pessimism, this work offers hope, and that should be reason enough for anyone with a serious interest in international affairs to reflect on "The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire" and recognize how much they have to teach us.

21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars The Byzantine Empire restored, December 27, 2009

By	Adam Golba (Virginia) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

I have previously reviewed Mr. Luttwak's "The Grand Strategy of the Roman Empire" (which I gave 5 stars) and I can say with all veracity that Mr. Luttwak has truly surpassed his previous book. "The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire" is truly a wonderful book. I personally found chapters eight (Bulghars and Bulgarians, 26 pages) and nine (The Muslim Arabs and Turks, 38 pages) to be especially fascinating. In short, both chapters cover the major events of the players involved. While I realize that one could write entire novels about the interactions of the three states, Mr. Luttwak gives the reader a very good overview of the major events in a modicum amount of pages. For example, in chapter 8, Mr. Luttwak starts with why a Bulgarian state was so dangerous to the Empire, then moves on to the first interactions between the two, and then moves on to the war of 811 (the Empire's failed attempt to extirpate Bulgaria). Finally, it concludes with Emperor Basil's II successful war that destroyed Bulgaria and ensured that "...Byzantine rule was restored from the Adriatic Sea to the Danube for the first time in three centuries" pg 195.

Another point that I believe is interesting is Mr. Luttwak's re-examination of Emperor Justinian I. In spite of all the Justinian bashing that is commonplace in this era; Mr. Luttwak puts forth good arguments that Justinian's ambitions were not acts of megalomania, but rather reasonable goals. Mr. Luttwak believes that it was the unforeseen "Plague of Justinian (also known as the plague of 541-542)" that wrecked Justinian's plans. Indeed, Mr. Luttwak states "...the new biological evidence...compel a reassessment of Justinian and his policies. He could have been just as successful in his military ambitions as he was in his jurisprudential and architectural endeavors. It was Yersinia pestis that wrecked the empire..." pg 92. In my humble opinion, despite Mr. Luttwak's good arguments, I still believe that the fundamental problem of Justinian's expansion was that it proceeded with too much celerity. After conquest, a period of consolidation to ensure total Byzantine authority should have occurred before the next advance. Just my opinion.

One minor problem I have with the book is that very little is said the Fourth Crusade, which resulted in the loss of Constantinople on April 13, 1204. In fact, only a few scattered sentences and two connecting paragraphs (pgs. 232 and 234) are written about it. I believe Mr. Luttwak could have written about the flaws in Byzantine strategy before and during the Fourth Crusade. Then, Mr. Luttwak could have written what the Emperor's should have done to prevent the calamity. The first sack of the city in nearly nine hundred years could have been added in. But this is a minor complaint.

In conclusion, this is a magnificent book about the Byzantine Empire, which for far too long as been disregarded. I would highly recommend this book. I will end with what the front panel of the dust cover states, "It will appeal to scholars, soldiers, classicists, and readers of military history."

8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Byzantine in Every Way, December 27, 2009

By	Retired Reader (New Mexico) - See all my reviews (TOP 1000 REVIEWER)

Amazon Verified Purchase

Edward Luttwak has devoted much of his career to the analysis of the concepts of strategy especially what is called `grand strategy'. In this book he has attempted to distill the basics of the grand strategy used by the Eastern Roman or Byzantine Empire to out last the Western Roman Empire by almost 1000 years. Since grand strategy is a modern concept, Luttwak had to analyze the history of the Byzantine Empire and infer the strategic designs that it followed from relevant historical evidence, including events, fragmentary comments, and official writings. All in all, he has done a pretty good job of it.
Constantinople (Istanbul) was at the center of Byzantine strategy since for much of its history it was the most prosperous and populous city in Western Christendom. Its unique location made it highly defendable and indeed until it was successfully captured in the Fourth Crusade (1204) it was the anchor of the Empire. The Byzantines used the magnificence and wealth of the city as well as the carefully staged extreme opulence and ritual of the imperial court to overawe enemies and allies alike. Operating from this nearly impregnable bastion, successive Emperors and their bureaucracies were able to employ a complex mixture of intelligence information, bribery, diplomatic maneuvering including duplicity, and military force to thwart all imperial enemies even in the face of much stronger military forces. Perhaps their greatest enemy was the high cost of their strategy for in spite of a very effective system of taxes Byzantium was very near to bankruptcy several times in its history.
Since the very survival of the Empire was at stake, the Byzantines studied and analyzed the strengths and weaknesses of their potential enemies in a very modern and effective manner. Their military forces evolved over the years, but until the last 200 years before the destruction of the empire, always included a strong navy and an army consisting of a core of well trained native troops supplemented by large contingents of mercenaries. After the Emperor Justinian (ce 6th Century) the empire was largely on the defensive. As Luttwak explains in considerable detail the Byzantines developed a strategy that enabled them to defend and maintain the empire against a variety enemies bent on its destruction. This is an interesting and well researched book