Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
28 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best in many a year, April 18, 2000
This book has it all--great writing, characterization, action, magic and mystery. The plot makes sense, the emotions are real, and it is entrancing. The marketing copy on every fantasy book that comes out heralds its author as the new master. This one actually could live up to that title.Achmed the Snake has to be one of the all time great characters in recent fantasy literature. Flawed, cranky and brutal, he nonetheless rises to greatness in a real and plausible transition through the long trek the three main characters make within the pages of the book. Grunthor is great as well, the comic relief sidekick that also has a very realistic, very serious side. I was reminded of noncommissioned officers in the military when I read about him, the men who follow a leader without question. This rang very true to me, and made the story even more poignant. The relationship between these two men, who often communicate without needing to use words, shows that Haydon is a keen observer of human behavior. I found the characters of Rhasody and Jo refreshing. Jo is an obnoxious teenager, and anyone who has a child or siblling this age will recognize the behavior at once. While you many not feel fondly for her, she is certainly amusing and a great foil to the other three. Rhapsody represents a great risk for an author to take, a heroine who is strong yet flawed, and who is dealing with powers of a magnitude she can't understand. I found this more realistic that the standard Richard Rahl type, who gets handed a sword and suddenly goes from humble wood guide to war wizard in the blink of an eye. You get to see Rhapsody struggle to learn how to fight, to feel out of place in a land where her skills are not wanted. This is brilliant, risky stuff. People who are only comfortable with cookie cutter heroes and heroines will probably not like this book and these characters. And while taste differs, and I respect that, I don't get these people who feel the need to tear down a book without any good reason. Ignore anyone who duns this book without giving you any specifics. They haven't read it.
|
|
|
34 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Rhapsody, November 23, 2000
My biggest problem with this tale is that I simply couldn't figure out the book's intended target audience. The story is too unsophisticated for adults and is too full of sexual references for children. It might have made a fine "young adult" novel if not for the frequent sexual content.The first chapter reads like some sappy "true confession" romance magazine and involves a sex scene between a 13 year old girl and a 14 year old boy, which occurs not long after they first meet. There seemed to be no reason for the children to have had sex. Why not have them share a first kiss instead? Or, if the sex serves some purpose, why not make them older? The heroine of the story, Rhapsody, is just too good to be true. She begins the book as the most beautiful woman living, but a few chapters later, she transforms herself into a goddess-like being who is the most beautiful woman who has ever graced the planet. She is good and kind to all she meets, talented at everything she attempts, and humble too. Every single man she meets, from the youthful to the elderly priest, from friend to enemy, is filled with lust at the sight of her. A child might have accepted this description and been able to view Rhapsody with admiration, but an adult reader is quickly going to be grinding teeth over Rhapsody's perfection. It is nearly impossible to identify with her, or to want her to succeed. The story is full of holes and leaps of logic that, again, will leave an adult frowning. For instance, during her transformation into the goddess-like being, Rhapsody also regains her virginity. How this is done is never fully explained, but let's look at it logically. Rhapsody and her lovers apparently still have their sexual memories, so if she knows that she's had sex, how can she possibly be a virgin? And as any doctor will tell you, there is no physical proof of virginity. Prior to the start of the novel, Rhapsody worked as a prostitute. Her previous occupation seems to make no sense, given what else we learn about the character. Since the author makes Rhapsody talented at virtually every skill there is, why would she choose such a profession? Rhapsody is miserable throughout the entire story because she's been dragged forward in time and desperately misses her family, especially her mother. Yet Rhapsody admits that she ran away from home as a young girl. She was apparently gone from home for years, but she made no effort to write to her family or to travel to see them. During a brief stay, Rhapsody "adopts" some children that she meets and during the rest of story, she worries about them, she writes to them, and she stops to buy them gifts. If Rhapsody is such a caring person, why didn't she show the same concern for those she claims she loved most of all? Rhapsody's major talent in the book is her ability at music and singing. She is apparently able to change the very nature of reality with the power of her voice, as is shown when she sees an abusive father and his son and is able to completely change their relationship. If she is this talented, why doesn't Rhapsody use this incredible power to to fix, for example, the murder/war situation that occurs with Achmed's people? And finally, if she is so lonesome for home, why doesn't she sing her way back in time?
|
|
|
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good enough..., August 14, 2000
..But not without its share of flaws. The strongest aspect of this book is its imagination and a certain originality that awakes your curiosity (I, personally, am waiting for the sequel with mounting impatience). The supporting cast of characters are very good. The intriguing characters of Achmed the Snake (who is very cool and my favorite character in the book) and his sidekick, the giant and cannibalistic Grunthor were really the best thing about the book. The humor was great if, yes, occasionally juvenile, but it worked, right? The pacing was surprisingly excellent for a story that spends several centuries travelling in a monotonous Root. :) The heroine herself, of whom all rhapsodize in a very annoying manner, was a different story. By herself, I would probably consider her the perfect fantasy female protagonist. After all, she didn't whine (too much) and she wasn't overly self-centered, but neither was she some arrogant princess with a lot of "spunk" or a toughy-tough warrior woman, the equal of every and any man. No, she was human, but better yet, feminine, while still holding her own, being capable and sympathetic, and not thrown in for romantic interest. So where does she go wrong? When the author keeps sticking down our throat how wonderful Rhapsody is and when she suspends our belief by transforming her late into the story into a really irresistable, completely gorgeous, surreal being. Please, Ms. Haydon, what purpose did that serve? I was deprived of getting an honest reaction from the people (especially men) who encountered her ever afterwards, and couldn't add to my understanding of the character, because no one reacts to HER anymore, just to her stunning beauty. That was a bad move in my mind because her meeting with Ashe, which should have been special, was just made really disappointing and commonplace instead. But if the author actually has a reason for this transformation (it wasn't neccessary in the least; Rhapsody was already naturally beautiful and winning) then I guess it's not a real problem. After all, normally something so irritating as Rhapsody's utter gorgeousness would have been devastating to the story plot and interest, but the book takes it in stride and somehow continues to be worth the reading. So, I'm recommending this book I guess, and pretty strongly. Though I never cried (and usually I do), I did laugh a lot (and in all the right places) and was drawn effectively into Ms. Haydon's world.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|