My Brother, My Enemy (Star Wars: Rebellion, Vol. 1) (Hardcover Comic)

~ (Author), Brandon Badeaux (Author), Michel LaCombe (Author)

Editorial Reviews

From Booklist

As the history of the Star Wars universe becomes more crowded, writers scramble to find new time periods and characters to focus on. In the first volume of this new series, set just after Luke Skywalker joins the rebellion, Luke learns that one of his childhood friends, an officer for the Empire, wants to defect. Unusual moral complexity is introduced into the mix of thrilling escapes and space battles, which are well realized in the expressive and highly detailed art. The sense of joining a story already in progress may confuse some readers, but the panopoly of spies, heroes, thrills, and action will sweep most into that galaxy far, far away. Karp, Jesse

Product Description

Having rescued Rebel strategist Jorin Sol from the Empire, Luke Skywalker now leads X-Wing attack runs on Imperial convoys to rustle up much needed supplies for the Rebel fleet. Little does he know that within Sol lies a secret that will put the entire Alliance in danger. What's worse, when Luke receives a coded message from Lt. Sunber, he must decide whether to trust his old friend or obey the orders of Princess Leia who believes Tank may be part of an Imperial plot to capture the Rebellion's greatest hero!

Product Details

• Reading level: Young Adult
  
• Hardcover Comic: 128 pages
• Publisher: Dark Horse (March 14, 2007)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 1593077114
• ISBN-13: 978-1593077112
• Product Dimensions: 10 x 6.4 x 0.3 inches
• Shipping Weight: 10.4 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 3.8 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (4 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #200,170 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

  Popular in this category: (What's this?)

  #78 in

  Books > Comics & Graphic Novels > Characters > Star Wars

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars Star Wars the way it should be written, April 12, 2007

By	Tom Knapp "Rambles.NET editor" (Lancaster, PA USA) - See all my reviews (TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)

I've read quite a few Dark Horse offerings in the continuing Star Wars line. To date, none has been as exciting as the first volume in the new Star Wars Rebellion series, "My Brother, My Enemy," set at the perfect time in the Star Wars chronology. Luke Skywalker has destroyed the Death Star and is the hero of the Rebellion, but the rebels are still on the run and Darth Vader is turning up every stone in the galaxy to find them.

There's no mention anywhere of Vader being Luke's father. And there are no siblings involved, either; Luke still has a crush on Leia, it seems, so the whole ick factor that spilled out in "Return of the Jedi" is still far away.

Besides Luke, Leia and the immortal Wedge Antilles, the Rebels in this tale have a strong and diverse cast of characters. On the other side, besides Vader, there's Janek "Tank" Sunber, a Tatooine native who was one of Luke's boyhood chums. Just how does it feel when one of your best friends is on the other side of a brutal conflict? This book examines the question from both perspectives.

Rob Williams has scripted a brilliant new chapter in the Star Wars saga. He has a firm grasp on the central characters from the legendary first film, and his new creations fit into the story like old friends. The tale itself is exciting, a page-turner that will only disappoint you when it ends.

The art, by illustrators Brandon Badeaux and Michel Lacombe and colorist Wil Glass, is exquisite. Lush, full and highly detailed, with rich depth and colors that leap from the page, this is the real deal. Heck, Luke and Leia even look like themselves, which is no sure thing in comics.

by Tom Knapp, Rambles.NET editor

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars The self-exploration of troubled Lt. Janek Sunber, May 1, 2007

By	Andrew Pruette "Rancors Love to Read" (U.S.) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

Dark Horse Comics concluded their Empire comic series with an arc concerning Lieutenant Janek Sunber and his burgeoning internal crisis centered around the morality of his service to the Empire. Rebellion is a direct continuation of the Empire series and this sequence picks up right where Empire left off. In the last story arc, we learned that Lt. Sunber is in fact the "famous" Tank we first heard of in 1977 when Luke exclaimed "That's what you said when Biggs and Tank left" in A New Hope. Tank and Luke had a dramatic reunion and Tank was left reeling in shock that his best friend had joined the Rebellion.

Rebellion Volume One comprises issues zero through five. Issue Zero is a brief summary of events narrated in third-person to bring new readers up to speed. Issue One is entirely centered on Tank and deals with his inner turmoil; he no longer feels certain he is fighting on the right side of the war. This self-dialogue runs rather long for my tastes, but the art in the first issues is quite nice and the chaos around Tank as he journeys inward is an interesting reflection of what's in his mind.

Tank makes his decision on where he stands and sets off to join up with Luke and his friends. The storyline is somewhat predictable and doesn't really conclude much. The climax features an impressively large-scale battle which is quite visually exciting. I enjoy how Dark Horse continues to work prequel-era technology and vehicles into their stories, further linking the two film trilogies. One odd note is the art in the middle issue must have been drawn by different artists, as it takes a sudden left turn into a very simple style and then returns to how it started.

Several non-film characters are featured in this story arc. A segmented cyborg gangster, Raze, shows potential but doesn't have that much to do (yet). Tormented Rebel mathematician Jorin Sol is restored to the Alliance, but it is unclear whether he can be trusted after spending so long in the hands of Imperial tormentors. Luke partners up with the beautiful Rebel pilot Deena to attempt a rescue of Tank from an Imperial facility. Luke's credibility and Tank's trustworthiness are challenged by the intriguing Rebel spymaster Tungo Li.

Rebellion is slated to cover events from the Battle of Yavin to five years after, so there is plenty of fertile ground for the series creators to play in. These books overlap the era of the Marvel comics, but are completely different in tone (it is far more serious and dark in the modern comics). I assume there will be a sequel to this storyline down the road and I hope the next round will be a little more conclusive as far as the Tank/Luke relationship.

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars The rebellion relaunched, April 10, 2007

By	ShriDurga (Japan) - See all my reviews (TOP 1000 REVIEWER)

Last seen questioning the motives of the Empire and taking a beating from his childhood friend Luke Skywalker, Imperial Lieutenant Janek Sunber has grown out of his naiveté, thrown of his doubt, and is dedicated now to nothing more than hurting his old chum from Tatooine.

My Brother, My Enemy is a collection of the first five issues of Rebellion (plus the promotional issue #0), one of four new series from Dark Horse Comics launched in 2006 following the completion of the film franchise. This particular series is a retooled version of the rebellion in the days following the destruction of the first Death Star, and this volume picks up where The Wrong Side of the War (Star Wars: Empire, Vol. 7) left off, with the rebels' mathematician Jorin Sol recovering from Imperial torture. What the Rebels don't yet know is that Sol has been programmed by the Empire to betray the location of the Alliance fleet. Lt Sunber, aka "Tank," meanwhile reveals to Darth Vader his relationship to Luke Skywalker, a confession that puts Sunber on the hook as bait for the farmboy hero of the Alliance.

Following their work together on Nomad, one of the better and longer stories of the now defunct anthology series, Star Wars Tales, British author Rob Williams and American artist Brandon Badeaux prove here that they are more than one-hit wonders. Badeaux presents some exceptionally fine work, particularly in a two-page space battle, a depiction reminiscent of the opening sequence from Revenge of the Sith, as well as the uniform design for Rebel Alliance special ops, tight-fitting black coveralls with matching black helmet and insignia. Badeaux's style is so distinct that it is sorely missed in the middle chapter, penciled by Michael Lacombe (who has since taken over regular artwork on this ongoing series). The change in style is noticeable, but the switchover happens at the start of a dream sequence and by the time you're out of the dream, you've not noticed that it's the artist, and not the style, that's changed.

For reasons that are not evident from the story, Williams has written in the first person for three different characters, switching to third person for bridging scenes and for the finale. Besides having no obvious reason for this authorial conceit, especially for one of the minor characters, there seems in one case a clear reason not to use it - the reader is prematurely tipped to a character's motivation.

Where the scripter excels is in recapturing Luke's youth, who in this period is often written as an experienced pilot, fighter, motivator, strategist, and jack-of-all-military trades. In fact he should be more as portrayed here, a wide-eyed farm boy wanting to help and do well but with still much to learn and prone to misjudgment and mistakes. Williams also does a good job capturing Luke's old friend and current nemesis, Lt Janek Sunber, a boy from Tatooine who once showed some regret at having joined the Imperials but whose doubt has been consumed by a fiery rage at himself, rage he redirects at his childhood chum. A few new characters slated to reappear in future stories are so far largely unremarkable.

While not an exceptional addition to the Star Wars EU library, this first volume of Rebellion is a solid effort that holds promise for a grittier and darker version of the rebellion than we've seen previously. I'm personally looking forward to future volumes, though disappointed that Badeaux seems to have left the series for the time being.

Set in the days immediately following A New Hope, Rebellion is one of Dark Horse Comics' four new Star Wars series. Chronologically, Knights of the Old Republic takes place several thousand years before the film series, Dark Times in the immediate aftermath of the Clone Wars, Rebellion in the period following A New Hope, and Legacy some 100 years after Return of the Jedi.

#