Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
29 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Hoped to give this 5 stars, but..., October 17, 2009
While I'm not a big fan of comics, as such, I found this one very easy to follow, and quite true to the spirit and tone of the series in many respects. It was great to finally get another dose of Farscape, which I've been missing like crazy. Farscape is still my favourite TV show of all time, and I still re-watch the entire series frequently on DVD. Nobody wants more Farscape than me.
Unfortunately, this effort --subtitled The Beginning of the End of The Beginning -- is nothing more than a coda tacked on to the end of Peacekeeper Wars. In fact, it begins only MINUTES after the final scene in Peacekeeper Wars, and merely chews away on a few old plots for a while. It reads more like a Deleted Scene from one of Farscape's DVDs than any new story.
BEWARE. SPOILERS FOLLOW:
What do we get with this 'new' story?
Rygel gets his throne back and becomes a wise, but humble despot -- after a short burst of mild Farscape pyrotechnics and a smidgen of crude intrigue -- but we already knew that was going to happen, didn't we? Ho-hum.
A mysterious Black-Cloaked-Critter-With-Red-Eyes is following Crichton around, taking pot-shots at him and Aeryn. Their baby slows the bullets by blinking. Exciting stuff? Ermm ...not really, at least not yet. We're only mildly curious, that's all.
Chiana and Jothee grieve for D'Argo by having lots of sex. Aeryn obsesses (constantly!) about being a "bad" mother, just like Xalax! -- hold me back. Shallow, overcooked, predictable rubbish.
And Scorpius ...the most marvellous 'dark' character ever committed to screen? In this story, Scorpius's character has lost all the subtle ambiguity Wayne Pygram built up during the entire TV series. With a bound, Scorpius is once again the power-hungry, ruthless, friendless villain from Season 1, who is willing to choke Crichton's child to death in order to extract a basically irrelevant hunk of 'truth' from Crichton and Aeryn. We're given a token explanation for his action (he no longer has an Aurora chair!) but none at all for the complete regression of such a thoughtfully-constructed character. Come back Wayne Pygram. Please.
A few new topics touched-on in this book ARE interesting, and worth further exploration in another Farscape story. For example, the Peacekeepers may indeed begin to fragment their society, now that their war with the Scarrans is over, and they have discovered their true origin with the Eidelons. (However, it's hard to believe that this sea-change would happen OVERNIGHT as it seems to have done in this book.) The idea that the Scarrans will eventually violate the peace treaty is also a good one. The idea that Scorpius suspects this might happen, is also an idea well worth keeping.
Of course, still lurking in the background but not touched-on in this book, are the Nebari -- another group bent on domination, with mind-control as their major weapon of choice. Indeed, they were built-up initially as a very dangerous and powerful race, so they should certainly figure in any new story. (And we would love to see Chiana and Nerri reunited at some point, wouldn't we?)
And there is still Earth to be reckoned with. Humans are stuck behind a closed wormhole at present, but Crichton left "us" with all that new technology as well as all our old prejudices. Earth is, after all, the key to Farscape. It always has been. It MUST be a major player in any new Farscape story. Without it, Farscape is just another space opera in a galaxy far away, and Crichton might as well be Buck Rogers.
Any story should always begin with a life-changing moment for its main character -- like John Crichton unexpectedly getting sucked down a wormhole into another galaxy. That story held us spellbound for five seasons, and ended most satisfactorily, with Crichton holding his newborn son up to the window of Moya so the baby can see the stars, and saying: "This is your playground." (And they all lived happily ever after.)
The original Farscape story ended there -- at least for now. Crichton needs a rest -- and we, the audience, need some distance -- before he gets hammered with another life-changing moment and a new story. We also need a few new major characters to replace the ones who have been killed off. And -- BIG warning to the writers who seem to be starting down this path already -- this new story should NOT involve the entire Universe chasing Crichton's ass around, as per usual. The writers seem to find this funny. It's not. It's boring. It's been done to death. Farscape's main strength lies in its unpredictability. The writers should give Crichton something else to do in the next story besides running for his life. Maybe he could even call the shots himself from now on.
Of course, I'll be delighted to eat my shirt and rescind all this criticism, if the upcoming issues of this comic book series take a huge turn for the better. In fact, I've pre-ordered the lot, so my money is already where my mouth is! Here's hoping for the best ...again. Meanwhile, just three stars for this one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic Continuation of the Series, December 5, 2009
This book brought me home again. Being able to rejoin the Farscape crew was great and Rockne's story was where I expect he would take it if he had a huge budget and the show was still on.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|