Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Indie masterpiece, November 25, 2004
The story of B&S is the story of a band without the intention of selling music, who still became one of the most influential indie-bands. Deriving their name from a French childrens book named "Belle et Sebastién", Belle and Sebastian is by all measures a band quite outside the ordinary.
"Tigermilk", their debut album, was originally released on Electric Honey Records - a small label run as a part-time project by students of the Glasgow School of Art. Originally the label only had capacity to release one EP a year, but when Stuart Murdoch turned up with ten songs and eight band members, they decided to make this one a full-length LP. As the belles had to cover most of the costs themselves, the original vinyl LP was only printed in 1,000 copies, and even so the band still had problems finding buyers for them all.
Today Belle and Sebastian have fans more or less everywhere - the band even has a nightclub in Korea named to their honour. And when listening to "Tigermilk" one instantly understands why the band achieved such fame, more or less against their own will.
Although "Tigermilk" was the bands debut - recorded with both limited time and resources at their disposal - it still shows the belles at their absolute best. Though musically it lacks some of the range of the three-ep box-set "Lazy Lane Painter Jane", its consistency and timelessness made it a classic all from the start. One needs only to listen through the opening track of the album, "The State That I am In", to see what makes the belles stand out from everyone else. Sarcastic lyrics about human failure and tragedy is mixed with upbeat pop-melodies form the basis of most of B&S' music, creating their signature soundscape. Although seemingly stealing some of its sound from classic pop, "Tigermilk" still stands out as fresh and new - different from everything done both before and after it. Seemingly coming out of nowhere, "Tigermilk" still does not distance itself from its audience, but invites the listener into a completely new - yet recognizable - musical universe.
"Tigermilk" fuses the sound of The Smiths at the height of their creative power with the ideals of the indie/lofi-movement of the 90s, creating - in all its simplicity - pop-music both more advanced and yet simpler and more truthful than anything done before it. The first listening might give the impression of a feelgood easy-listening album, but underneath it all lies a nerve equal to the works of Jeff Buckley and his like.
Though creating a universe of its own, distanced by a clear sarcastic tone, "Tigermilk" leaves the listener with the impression that this is something highly personal. The odd combination of lyrics and music leaves the listener unsure as to wether he should laugh or bawl.
Running the risk of ending up entangled in clichés, I daresay that "Tigermilk" stands out as an accurate description of modern life and culture; that the belles in their firm intention of creating an album completely unsuited of intellectual analysis (or commercial success for that matter), managed to create the album that described their own generation.
Sadly, at current point "Tigermilk" seems only a distant memory of the artistic capabilities of the belles, as "Belle" herself, in real life named Isobel Campbell, left the band in 2002 to focus on her solo career, and the band after their transfer to Rough Trade has started tuning their guitars and hiring professional musicians and producers - a move that has removed most of their original charm and created just another radio-friendly Scottish pop-band.
PS. Isobel Campbell is currently releasing on Snowstorm under her own name and has previously released on Jeepster as The Gentle Waves, both french-pop inspired projects and next door neighbours to B&S. Her Gentle Waves album "Swansong for You" is definetily worth both your time and money.
|
|
|
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Truly a masterpiece., September 1, 1999
By A Customer
...I must write in to say that this is truly a masterpiece of an album. Stuart Murdoch writes lyrics worthy of the great Lou Reed and melodies worthy of the Beatles. The instruments and identities of the eight band members meld into one to create a sonic stew of pop nirvana. "The State I Am In" and "We Rule The School" are undeniable works of genius, but the other songs also hold strongly. "Electronic Renaissance" is a great track, but it doesn't truly belong with this collection of indie pop-rock tunes.Belle and Sebastian is one of the best modern rock bands, as Stuart Murdoch's complex and intellectual lyrics are easily bent into hummable pop melodies, you find yourself loving it more with each listen. This is truly a great album. (This album deserves 4.5 stars, but 5 will have to do)
|
|
|
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Tigermilk Shakes! (Your Hips, That Is!), November 18, 1999
Okay - I'll confess. I was a former Smiths junkie looking for a quick fix of something beautiful, something that could come even remotely close to capturing the precious magic the Smiths so easily wielded. I was a teenage Morrissey - HALLELUJAH, BROTHER. CAN I GET AN AMEN? And then I grew up. Got over and uninvolved with Stephen Patrick. But the hunger -the lust - for something similar ate away at me with a dangerous voracity. Music was my drug of choice, and the Smiths - so much like a melodic heroin, were all that I once craved. Everything else was sugarwater and lacking substance. I tried shooting up Gene. It was a fairly pleasant trip at first.. but crashed hard. Then I dropped some Suede. What a rush! Then what a letdown! The trip ended just as fast as it began.. And then someone introduced me to a new drug of sorts. It was called Belle and Sebastian. Anything THAT TWEE sounding must surely be rubbish, thought I. How wrong I was.. The sounds that poured from my speakers took me north of heaven, enrapturing me in a ecstatic rhapsody - it was love. I knew - I mean I JUST KNEW - I had found the perfect replacement for The Smiths I once so dearly loved. Moreover, I didn't even WANT the Smiths Anymore. This was a new direction, a new sound. This stood up so solidly, so wondrously on its own - I could've cried. From Tigermilk to Arab Strap, this band has changed my life.. their music speaks to me like none other. I cannot reccomend them strongly enough. Bravo, Belle. Bravo, Sebby. Je T'aime, Je T'aime.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|