Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
65 of 82 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The "Jigsaw Killer" plays another bloody little game, November 17, 2004
When I went to go see "Saw" late last night I was thinking "saw" as the past tense of see and not "saw" as the noun ("a hand or power tool or a machine used to cut hard material and equipped usually with a toothed blade or disk") or as the verb ("to cut with a saw"). What was I thinking? "Saw" is in the Grand Guignol of "Seven" and "The Bone Cutter," and apparently had to make some last minute cuts to avoid getting saddled with a NC-17 rating. That alone with give you an indication of what first time director James Wan and first time writer Leigh Whannell were going for in "Saw," even with only $1.2 million to make the film and 18 days to shoot it.
Adam (Leigh Whannell), a young man, wakes up underwater in a dark room with a chain around his ankle. He is not alone, and when the light come on he finds himself is what appears to be a long abandoned public restroom. At the other end is Lawrence (Cary Elwes), who is also chained to a pipe. On the floor in between them, out of their reach, is the corpse of a man who apparently killed himself with a gun. In his hand is a tape recorder. After becoming oriented to his strange surroundings, Adam discovers a plastic bag in his pocket, containing an envelope. Inside is a key and a small cassette tape with the words "Play Me." Let the game begin.
Beyond that you really do not want to know that much about this before you see it, and given the dreck that passes for horror thrillers in recent years "Saw" is worth the seeing in the theater. The last time I actually went to see a film in this genre in a theater was probably "Hannibal," and I have not had any reason to regret being selective in this regard. However, this is not going to be a date movie, but one for hardcore fans of the genre who prefer their DVD editions to be the director's unrated cut of the film. "Saw" is a film that works more in the world of horror films than it does in the real world, but that is certainly part for the genre at this point.
The entire film does not take place in the abandoned restroom, although that is main arena. Lawrence knows something about the "Jigsaw Killer," who has been constructing elaborate dances of death in which his victims have to try and save themselves. Only one victim has survived to date (Shawnee Smith), so it is possible to get out of this alive, just extremely difficult and we are treated to a couple of examples of where it did not go as well. Investigating the case are a couple of detectives, Tapp (Danny Glover) and Sing (Ken Leung), and the chronology of the film gets skewed as the present and the past become confused. The game also involves more than the two men chained to the wall, because Lawrence's wife, Alison (Monica Potter) and daughter, Diana (Makenzie Vega) are part of it as well.
During the film's endgame things are moving fast enough that you probably will not be able to figure out how it will all play out even though "Saw" overplays the obvious red herring card. The film pushes one of my least favorite buttons a couple of time, which is when somebody has a gun on the villain and does not blow them away. If there is one thing we have learned from all of these movies it is that hesitating when you have the bad guy in your sights is never a good thing. I especially go through the roof when a trained law enforcement officer is pointing the gun right at the killer and the killer still gets away (even Clarice Starling is guilty of this sin in "The Silence of the Lambs"). So there is some heavy handedness to Whannell's script that hopefully will be replaced by something more elegant when he and Wan make their recently announced "Saw 2" sequel for 2005.
But "Saw" is not an elegant horror film, although Wan gets points for keeping the most horrific moment of the film off screen (even though the rationale is small budget and not true aesthetic choice, which makes me fearful for what will happen when Wan and Whannell have a much bigger budget for the sequel). The "Jigsaw Killer" has a warped interest in having his victims better appreciate their lives, so getting out alive has to do not only with Lawrence and Adam solving the tasks they are given, but also with finding out some important things about each other. The important thing here is that the film's final scene is pretty horrific, even if the film cheats a bit to get to that point, and that even when the screen goes dark and the credits start to roll, Whannell keeps the horror going.
|
|
|
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Horror Classic, May 25, 2007
SAW is a true horror classic no doubt about it. Damn he {or she} who remakes this film...EVER. In the world of gore-porn and endless remakes or "re-imaginations", {I have to say this ~ Rob Zombie is pathetic for "re-imagining" Halloween...thanks for trashing it Rob} SAW stands alone as a film that is sick, very disturbing, scary, intense, frightful, mentally numbing, thrilling, avante garde, theatrical, spontaneous, evil, and macabre! This is a film where the villains recorded voice is as disturbing as his actions..and the villain is not even revealed until the last minute of the film...literally the final scene. The film cannot be compared to Se7en because we see most of the torture in the film and the villain takes up more time giving his monologue than Jigsaw's "Most people are so ungrateful to be alive...but not you...not anymore."
Two men wake up in a grimy abandoned bathroom chained and unable to escape. We see a dead man laying in the middle of the floor. His tape recorder reveals the two men are part of a deadly "game" in which only one of them will survive...if he can find the primal instinct..the "will" to survive. As the film progresses we learn about "Jigsaw" who tortures his "test subjects" in order to make them appreciate their lives they have apparently abused. Jigsaw's "test subjects" include: Jeff a man who attempted suicide but failed, Amanda the drug addict, Adam the voyeur photographer and loser, and Dr. Gordon a doctor who neglects his wife and daughter. Jigsaw makes them realize their blessings in his tortuous devices where the subject must maime his/her self or another to escape.
The films gives us clues to the identity of Jigsaw, directing attention to the orderly called Mr. Hindel aka "Zepp"...or is the killer one of the men chained in the bathroom? Dr. Gordon? Adam? The film is a Hitchcockian mystery to figure out 'who is doing this...and why?' that draws you to an intense and disturbing {not to mention disgusting} climax that will leave you stunned.
I like the film because like Se7en there is a sick twisted pathos that is plain and painfully clear in our times: "most people are so ungrateful to be alive...."
The Curse of Aleister Crowley: Descent into Lies and Madness
|
|
|
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Differences in UNCUT Edition!, December 25, 2005
Here are the differences for those of you wondering between the theatrical release and the uncut version. These shots were cut to retain an R rating, about 8 seconds total:
-When they first notice the body in between them in the bathroom, there is an extra close up shot of the head.
-During the "razor wire" scene a few close up still shots of the wounds are inserted.
-In the "reverse beartrap" scene, there are inserted shots of Amanda sifting through the intestines.
-During the confrontation or Jigsaw, the demise of Detective Sing is longer.
-In the scene where Adam is about to be kidnapped. The music playing while he is wearing headphones has been changed back to the original score which in my opinion is far better, rather than the band song that was only there to promote the soundtrack.
-The hacksaw scene is slightly longer.
-The color tones of the movie have been improved also
On top of that you get new bonus features and an entire second disk:
-An audio commentary with the writer/actor who plays Adam, the director, and actor carey elwes who plays Dr. Gordon, replaces the old commentary with just the writer and director.
-DTS ES 6.1 surround sound!
-An additional commentary with the producers and filmmakers.
-A making of featurette that recycles some of the footage from the old making of featurette but adds a lot more.
-Original short film "Saw", which is an early version of the reverse beartrap scene, filmed with the writer who plays Adam instead of the girl Amanda, which was filmed to sell the movie.
-A fake special report on the Jigsaw murders, kind of cheesey.
-An alternate storyboard sequence that shows how the scene with the detectives in jigsaws lair was originally planned to be.
-Director's art gallery
-Jigsaw's workshop, lets you make your own puppet on the computer.
-Saw II trailer and preview of the intro scene.
*The only features lost were the music video for "Bite the hand that bleeds" by Fear Factory, and the making of the music video.
*Although the packaging for the initial dvd release was awesome...this one definatly tops it. It is a clear slim case with blood that trickles when you shake it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
DVD ~ Donnie Wahlberg
DVD ~ Tobin Bell
DVD ~ Tobin Bell
DVD ~ Scott Patterson
DVD ~ Tobin Bell
on 
