Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
25 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Movie!, February 4, 2006
Ok, first of all, the movie is done as well as it could have been. It does leaves out some facts that the book felt was important to include. But miniscule things must be omitted. They did the best job possible that they could have done to eliminate less important plot lines. The opening scenes could have been allowed more time, and made it feel less rushed, but it worked out well. The acting in this movie is a definite improvement over those last 3 movies. You will applaud Daniel Radcliffe's performance. Emma Watson is as much of an amazing actress as she has always been, and I still think that she is underused. Her scenes at the Yule Ball were awe-inspiring. The effects, visual and CG, are amazing. You can feel as if you are there right now. Ralph Fiennes plays Voldemort beautifully and sends chills down your spine and makes you loath him from his first second on screen. Miranda Richardson really hit the nail on the head with Rita Skeeter. Her scenes are some of the funniest of the entire movie. The Director of this installment of the highly successful Harry Potter series was Mike Newell. He does an outstanding job. There are some scenes that are so cinematically amazing. The overall feel of the film is without a fast-paced action thriller. You fear for Harry's life every second of the film. I was thoroughly impressed with this film, and with the fifth book being my favorite, I am praying that the film works wonders.
The bonus features for this DVD include:
Commentary by the Film's Director, Mike Newell
Featuretts:
Reflections on the Fourth Film (14:11)
Meet the Champions (13:01)
Harry vs. the Horntail: The First Task (5:51)
Preparing for the Yule Ball (8:39)
In Too Deep: The Second Task (9:23)
The Maze: the Third Task (6:30)
He Who Must Not Be Named (10:40)
Deleted Scenes
SCENE 1: Dumbledore ask to his pupils to welcome the Durmstrangs and Beauxbatons students. All the Hogwart students then start to sing Hoggy Hoggy Hogwarts or the school song.
SCENE 2: A Durmstrangs student asks a girl if she wants to go with him to the Yule Ball. She says "yes" and the two friends make gestures in the background.
SCENE 3: Harry tries to speak with Cho Chang, but her friends are around her and the opportunity never works out .
SCENE 4: At the Yule Ball, Flitwick introduces the Weird Sisters band. The star singer addresses the crowd and then the music begins.
SCENE 5: Karkaroff tell to Snape about the mark on his arm. Snape ignores him and removes points to Fawcet and Stebbins, who are briefly shown, and Snape disregards Karkaroff's concerns then.
SCENE 6: Mr. Crouch and Harry are speaking, then Madeye appears as Barty leaves.
SCENE 7: The trio speaks about the death of Mr. Crouch. Ron thinks that the Daily Prophet will cover it up on Fudges orders. Hermione believes that this death, Harrys burning scar, and the fact that the Dark Mark had been cast , are too much of a coincidence, and she thinks Harry should go talk to Dumbledore about all of this.
SCENE 8: The trio discuss their suspicions about what Karkarov has on his arm. Hermione asks Harry what ingredients Snape think he stole from him, and she relises that they are all ingredients in a polyjuice potion.
Games, AND MUCH MORE
P.S. It doesn't matter that Hermione's dress is Pink instead of Blue. It does matter that Harry's eyes are supposed to be green, when they are Blue in the movies!
|
|
|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Goblet of Fire - Why you should graba a peice of the action!, January 22, 2006
In this forth instalment in the ever popular Harry Potter series based on the novel by JK Rolwling we see Harry mature in many ways, he must over come three deadly tasks, face a fully formed Lord Voldermort and possibly the most horrifying task of all for the 14 year old Harry, he must get himself a date for the Yule Ball!
The performance of the trio in the Goblet of Fire is amazing, every scene seemed to be executed perfectly and the on screen chemistry between the young stars is evident. Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter) reaches new heights in this movie perfectly portraying the uncomfortable adolescent Harry has become; he faces the new emotional roles in the movie with confidence and enthusiasm, like wise for Radcliffe's young co-stars Rupert Grint (Ron Weasley) and Emma Watson (Hermione Granger) Once again we see terrific performances from the likes of Dame Maggie Smith (Professor McGonagall), Alan Rickman (Professor Snape) and Robbie Coltraine (Hagrid) as well as meeting some new faces amongst the students, including students from two other magical academies who join the students at Hogwarts school of Witchcraft and Wizardry to participate in the Tri-Wizard Tournament! Another highlight of this marvellous movie is Ralph Fiennes' portrayal of Lord Voldermort which can be rather alarming even to an adult!
I believe this movie to be of an excellent standard not only due to the charismatic trio, but also thanks to the special effects of this movie. We see many fascinating creatures including a ferocious fire breathing dragon (which Harry must fight armed with nothing but his wand!) and while watching you can truly forget that these creatures were created using blue screen and you can honestly believe that you are in this world, that it truly exists just behind closed doors. This is very true to the novels making this a movie every Potter fan can enjoy and indeed fans of spectacular plots and mind-blowing special effects alike can appreciate this, making the Goblet of Fire a movie for all the family! Overall I would call this movie riveting and n absolute gem of the movie world. You do not want to miss this brilliant piece of film history, no DVD collection would be complete with out it! Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire amazing 5 stars!
|
|
|
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Guy Playing Dumbledore Does Not Get the Character At All, March 20, 2007
This is a good movie, as most of the reviews say. I wanted to focus on one specific big problem, though. The guy playing Dumbledore since Richard Harris died does not get the character at all.
The way JK Rowling writes Dumbledore, he's exceedingly charming and warm. He's always one step ahead, and seldom surprised. He never really gets excited, he's never rushed, but he always gets to the answer before anyone else -- even when taking things slow. And he always seems to find things just a little bit funny. The way Rowling writes him, he's always in control, always friendly. He seems to know a joke that no one else does, and always seems to be letting those around him in on it even if they don't know what "it" is. In short, he's very likeable, reasuring, confident, and composed. That's the way Rowling writes him, that's the way Richard Harris played him in the first two movies, and that's the way he's read in the audio books.
The guy who's playing Dumbledore now (from the third movie on,) is ruining the character. He gets Dumbledore all wrong. His Dumbledore has no warmth and no charm. His Dumbledore is exciteable, and seems a bit mean and distant. His Dumbledore doesn't seem in control or knowing, but rather aloof and rigid. Harry and Dumbledore in the books are very close - with this new guy playing Dumbledore, there's no sense of friendship between the two. The way this new guy plays Dumbledore, their relationship comes off more like a teacher who doesn't know and doesn't really care how to relate to a student, and a student who would avoid the teacher if he could.
I honestly don't know what the directors of the third and fourth movies were thinking letting the actor get the part so wrong, or what the actor was thinking when he has Rowlings books, the reader from the audio books, Richard Harris's performance, and millions of fans expectations to go by, and yet still manages to completely missinterpret the character.
Dumbledore has one of the best scenes in the fifth Potter book when he good naturedely refuses to be arrested. With Richard Harris playing the part (or someone playing the part the way it is written and meant to be played,) it could be one of the best scenes in the movie -- the way the current actor plays Dumbledore, it could be terrible. Without the charm, warmth, wit, and humor Dumbledore is supposed to have,the scene will be completely flat. In other words, if Dumbledore is played the way he's been played the last two movies, the scene will not work despite being brilliant in the book and in the audio book.
Hopefully the director or producer will get a better grip on the character this time and will try to improve the portrayal. Right now I can't help thinking back to right after Richard Harris's death when rumors said Ian Mckellan was being considered for the role -- now that would have worked. He would have gotten the character. He would have had the warmth and charm this current guy is missing -- the warmth and charm that defines the character in the books and in the minds of the fans.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|