Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
121 of 123 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic, September 19, 2007
Do you really need a GPS device?? If you are reading this review the answer is probably yes.
We have used them for a number of years and I'm now at the point where I wonder how we ever got along without one. No more trips to the computer for confusing Mapquest directions or frantic searches to find the car atlas after a wrong turn. Both facts leading to a significant reduction in "marital moments."
I could give many examples where GPS has "saved the day". Here is a recent one:
This summer my wife and our three small children traveled from Chicago to South Dakota for a wedding (I had to work). Like many rural wedding, each part of the event was in a different place. The church was in one town, the reception in another and their hotel in a third. After the wedding she wanted to visit cousins on their farm in Southern Minnesota, followed a stop in the Twin Cities. Lastly, she was going to travel to Northern Minnesota to spend some R-n-R at a lake cabin.
The night before the big trip I added all of the addresses in our GPS unit. I then labeled them: church, reception, hotel, farm, Twin Cities, cabin. Now all she had to do is press the right address and go. No worries about missing a turn or taking the wrong road, even on a pitch black rural night. If she decided to change her plans the Magellan would take care of it. GPS units figure out the route from where you are to your location, something Mapquest can't do. The peace of mind that the Magellan gave both of us was worth its purchase price alone.
I have to tell you that even a basic GPS unit could have done the above routing task. In fact, for most people, a basic unit is all that they need. However, sometimes you want something more. Does the Magellan Maestro 4050 deliver this "more?" Read on to find out!
Unit Overview
The Magellan Maestro 4050 is really an evolution of the popular Road Mate series. However, there are many significant improvements. First is the fact the 4050 has a large 4.3" screen. Although the typical 3.5" screen would work fine, I like the larger screen as I suffer from FFS or Fat Finger Syndrome. A bigger screen gives me a bigger on-screen keyboard when typing in an address. This results in less error and less growling on my part.
The icons have also changed with this series and now they have a friendlier, more polished look. The Maestro units use the very popular (and highly sensitive) SiRF star III GPS chipset which acquires signals quickly. Like other Magellan units, the underlying OS is Windows CE. The Maestro also has a built in battery that should allow a couple of hours of use. This would make it possible to use the unit outside of the car for a short period.
Routing
In my opinion, routing is the most important function of any GPS unit. Magellan units, in general, have always had excellent routing engines and the Maestro is no different. The maps on my unit are dated from late 2006 and so they are pretty recent.
Adding an address (or intersection) is a snap. Older Magellan units (like the Roadmate 300 series) ask for a street first. When you added a common street name like "River" or "Washington" you were forced to pick from a dozen or more choices ("North River," "River Drive," River Road," etc.). Later models, including the Maestro series ask for the city first eliminating a lot of confusion. It is amazing what a simple change can do to make a product more useable. Thanks Magellan!
I had no problems entering addresses, even difficult ones that have confused other units. I think that this is in part due to the fact that the maps are newer and therefore, more accurate. Magellan units always ask for your route preference ("shortest time," "least use of expressways," etc). Many other units require that you dig into menus and sub-menus to do this which often causes undesirable results. For instance, when traveling in a city during rush hour it may be easier to take regular roads in lieu of expressways. Since the Magellan always asks routing preferences this is easy to accomplish.
Naturally, it is very easy to exclude a particular street or routing direction (perhaps you know that street is under construction). You can also route up to up to 20 different locations using the "trip planner" option. The Maestro will then "optimize" the list for you making the trip more efficient. This option would be great for a delivery driver who has to travel to multiple locations on his route. The Maestro also tells you what side of the street your destination is on. Surprisingly, many other brands do not. Knowing what side of the street your destination is on can be really important, especially if it is on a busy, multi-lane street.
The unit can present map data either as 3D ("bird's eye view") or in a traditional 2D map view. It will automatically switch to a nighttime map at night. I really like the fact that Magellan products always give you a clear indication what direction you are traveling by placing your direction directly on the screen. This is much more convenient than using a "north pointing" arrow which other units have.
The Maestro is very good at giving your multiple, clear, auditory and visual indicators of your next maneuver. I have used other units (the Mio brand) where I couldn't even figure out what the maneuver icon was telling me (it looked like a letter from the Klingon alphabet). This has never happened using Magellan units (and I have used them for years).
A really useful feature on Magellan units is the "locate" key. This function tells you were you are, the closest cross streets and even a computer generated address (when possible). When you are on an expressway it will tell you the last and next exits and their distance. The locate button is really useful if you ever need roadside assistance (or when you just want to know where the heck you are).
The Maestro also has a "detour" function. If you are traveling on highway at lower than expected speeds, the Maestro will ask you if you want to take a detour. If you agree you can choose the length of the detour in miles. The Maestro will then get you off the highway for the designated number of miles and return you back afterwards. Great if an accident is up ahead.
The Maestro features text to speech (or TTS) which will give your specific verbal directions, like street names. Professional reviewers love this feature. I think it is pretty cool, but units that don't have this function are perfectly useable too.
Like other Magellan units, the Maestro is excellent at recalculating your route where you go off course. If it can calculate a route based on the new road that you are on, it will do so. Other brands can sometimes insist that you need to take their original calculated route and they will tell you to "turn around" or "make a U turn" when you don't have to.
POI Data Base
If the heart of a GPS unit is its routing engine, its soul is its POI Data base. Virtually all GPS units have such a data base and virtually all have inaccuracies and omissions. With that said, using a POI data base can really enhance your trip. I think the Maestro has the best POI data base ever. It feels like the programmers were thinking of me when they designed it.
First, you have a standard POI data base, but it is huge at 3.5 million entries. Even more important, it is reasonably current. I didn't find stores that had closed years ago as I have in other systems (including some older Magellans). The data base is very extensive covering tons of categories beyond core POIs (gas stations, auto services, ATMs, hotels, restaurants). There are many categories perfect for people like me, who go on family car trips. Campgrounds, grocery stores, pharmacies and even veterinarians are listed (to name a few). When appropriate, a general category will offer subcategories. For instance, the grocery category includes grocery stores, specialty food stores, convenience stores and Liquor stores. Stores like Target and Wal-Mart are typically under represented on many GPS units, but well listed on the Maestro. I was able to find both when searching locally. The standard POI data base not only gives you distance but also direction from your location (some other brands do not). It may be easier to go to a store that is 20 miles ahead rather than backtracking 10 miles. Naturally, you can not only search from your current location but you can also search around another address/city, like your destination. Perfect if you have to reserve a hotel room.
Many Magellans, including the Maestro have a unique and useful feature called "exit POIs." When you are on an expressway you can search for core POI services at upcoming exits. The Maestro will tell you the distance to the exit and the core services available (like gas). Touching the gas icon will then allow you to look at the various choices for that category (like Shell or Mobile). Since it only gives you services around the exits, the "exit POI" function can be extremely useful when traveling.
The 4050 also has the AAA Tour Book built in. This is a fantastic resource that combines the power of GPS location with tour book data. Now, when you look for a restaurant, you not only get a name but a detailed description, plus a rating. The AAA Tour Book gives information on rated hotels, campgrounds, restaurants, approved auto repair shops and other information like special events that may be happening in a particular area. You also get a phone number so you can make your reservation. The Tour book will also tell you if you can get an AAA discount (for AAA members). It is a really wonderful and unique resource. No other GPS manufacturer has it.
In addition to all...
Read more ›
|
|
|
61 of 62 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A great device that should rank amongst the top, July 23, 2007
Since the maps and GPS chip in this model are the same as the Garmin NUVI 660 what sets them apart feature wise is the 4050s AAA database, and its' voice control (which isn't as useful as you'd think) --and the Nuvi's MP3/Picture player/Calculator/etc. Since the unit is likely destined to sit on your dash and serve as a GPS, the Garmin's features don't strike me as real incentives either.
What you get here is a robust, and solidly built unit with a strong mount, loud and clear voice, and responsive touch screen. by contrast the Garmin voice seemed quiter, and the overall build quality left me wanting more. The Garmin feels flimsy. the Magellan is built like a tank.
The unit gets strong signals even indoors, and the routing engine is very fast. It re-routes off course in only a few seconds, and the POI database paired with the AAA database is a HUGE plus. The traffic feature is actually pretty neat, and useful if you drive at different times of the day.
Also, everything is self contained in the <agellan, whereas the NUVI puts the blu-tooth reciever, and traffic receiver in the lighter power cord. THat's great for making the unit smaller, but what if you run off the battery or want a permanent installation? You lose the traffic and Blue-tooth. The Magellan has these in the unit itself (the traffic receiver is part of the mount).
I had no trouble connecting my Motorola SLVR to the Blue Tooth receiver, and the POIs have phone number attached that can automatically be dialed. If you are a AAA member th choice is a no brainer. to be able to search for restaurants, car rentals, hotels, etc. that give AAA members discounts is awesome. just search your area and select your favorite to route too.
There is no perfect GPS though. A couple of times the voice sounded gurgly (probably a CPU overload) and the voice command feature takes a few trieds to hear you sometimes. Unlike the other reviewer I have never had the voice recognition come on unless I directly addressed it.
After a trip to LA and using Hertz neverlost we were determined to get a GPS. While the Neverlost was bulletproof, this GPS feels the closest to it. The Garmin looks good too, it just feels a little lacking in quality and the blutooth/traffic receiver being in the lighter bothered me. Also, the mount is smaller, so for those of you who drive a truck the GPS might just be out of reach with the Garmin.
EDIT - Just wanted to add that this thing caluclates time almost exactly. I have yet to arrive at any destination more than 5 minutes (more or less) off from the 4050s estimates. Remarkable!
|
|
|
40 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Shouldn't have been released this early..., June 11, 2007
June 12, 2007
I have used portable GPS units for some time, namely my old Garmin 2720, which has been a trouper over the years. The biggest problem was when we updated the software, and Garmin stopped getting satelite reception whenever it was turned off. This could be quite annoying, with the only solution being to tell Garmin that you were not in the state you were actually in, so it would use a wider search pattern. Because of this bad experience, and noticing prices were much cheaper now, I went with a different brand, and tried what I thought was top of the line.
The Maestro met all my initial expectations. It linked up with satelites quickly even when I was surrounded by tall buildings. The maps seemed more updated than the updated Garmin map I was using. The map style was improved over Garmin, and the detail level better. You could have POI's show up on the map, even if you were not routing to them. The voice prompting was much better, and had more customization (not voice but what information is communicated) than Garmin. The turns were described better (not everything is left and right some you keep on the highway you are on)and pictures described the turns as well. All the basic things were better.
Then there was the voice recognition.
The voice recognition comes on all the time, even though it is only supposed to come when you say Magellan. When it does, you can just say cancel, but the popup is annoying. And if you verbally cancel route, it does not default back to the map. There are not a lot of voice command options either. A lot of time the voice recognition stops responding, and will only start up again when you 'reset' the device. Overall, you just want to stop up the microphone with a wad of bubblegum.
And then I saw an add for this same model (in Smart Home I think) which mentions an mp3 player, which my machine does not have. Which I thought it might, since it has a slot for an SD card.
This machine is fine in the basics, but the rest is just messed up. I am hoping to get a software update to get the kinks ironed out of this one.
July 10, 2007 UPDATE...
Well, thought I might add a few updates to this review, as it takes a while to fully test a GPS unit, especially one that is quite loaded with features. So, let me just say that there is STILL no official update to the software on this unit, which I purchased on memorial day, and I find this a bit surprising. I suppose they are trying to get a fix-all patch, or a combo firmware software update. If they ever do get a fix, I feel I owe it to you to let you know if they have it and how well it works...
Address/POI routing: Most attempts have been pretty close(I usually use the address, not POI's), but the ones that are off might be off MORE than 1 block (happened at least four times to me). One time, when I POI routed to Radio Shack, Magellan told me it was five miles north of Shawnee. I found a natural gas well at the actual location it routed me to. But still, overall, pretty good with address routing.
POI's: Mostly current, but some quite out of date, and it seems to be missing some places I would expect (like Bass Pro Shop, and Abuelo's in OKC).
Traffic updates: Coverage is very sparse (say it limited to interstates in Oklahoma City), but I have not been routed to a major construction delay. I have, however, been routed to a 10 mile stretch of construction on I-35, but it did not prove to be much of a delay. Now, you could call that failure of the system, or you could say that the traffic update was geared towards traffic DELAYS. I don't know what to make of it.
08/01/07 Update
Miscellaneous Weirdness: Interupting the power while routing can cause catastrophic reboot. Basically what happens is if your DC car outlet switches off with your engine, and you happen to stop for gas while you are routing, it can cause problems. You might expect this, and it was a real problem with my older unit because it took some time to relocate the satelites. In general, relocating the satelites is not a problem this unit, and you can interupt the power on the unit any time and start up again while routing without a problem. In fact, since it has a battery, when the power is interupted it goes into a 30 second countdown if you want it to go into sleep mode. Yet, on at least four occassions, I have had a problem with the unit under power interuption circumstances. Basically, it wont come back on. Normally, when you restart the power, it comes out of sleep mode, but on these occassions, even when I have double checked the power connections on both ends of the cord, the unit does not power up. When the power button is held for a few seconds (the normal method of powering up the unit), the unit does not power up. When the button is held for longer than a few seconds, the unit does not power up. Only after the button is pressed several times for extended periods of time does the unit power up. And then, when it does, it shows a progress bar, which indicates that it has rebooted. The routing is not reset however. I have not tried the reset button, however, although it has occurred to me to try it next time...
Till later then...
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|