Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
41 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Synology DS209 High Performance 2-Bay NAS, July 7, 2009
The Synology DS209 is a good alternative for a two drive Network Attached Storage (NAS). There are other choices for a dual drive NAS with decent performance but for me the combination of performance, features, and price stands out.
The Synology DS209 is housed in a sturdy white plastic medium sized box just large enough to hold two 3.5" drives and the system board. It is powered by a Marvell CPU clocked at 1.2 GHz and 256 MB of main memory. This compares to the "upscale" DS209+II Ultra High Perf NAS with a Freescale floating point CPU clocked at 1.06 GHz CPU and 512 MB of main memory, and to the "economy" DS209j Economic 2-Bay NAS with a 266 MHz CPU and 64 MB main memory.
According to Synology, performance for Windows XP transfers are 11.46 / 39.09 / 48.31 MB/sec (upload) and 27.75 / 49.49 / 52.53 MB/sec (download) for the DS209j / DS209 / DS209+II. In my quick informal testing copying files to and from a Vista laptop over a gigabit LAN the DS209 transferred files anywhere from 30 MB/sec to 43.5 MB / sec, depending on the file size.
All recent Synology NASes including the DS209 run the same application software, Synology Disk Station Manager 2.1. Some highlights of DSM 2.1 include:
- Support for file sharing with Windows / Mac / UNIX, with definable user accounts and groups.
- Web based file management (File Station 2).
- Support for FTP, Telnet/SSH, BitTorrent / eMule download, etc.
- Support for Basic, JBOD, RAID 0, and RAID 1.
- Support for attached USB drives, printing to attached USB printer.
- Support for recording/playback of IP video (surveillance) cameras attached to the network.
- Servers for iTunes, uPnP, photo sharing, e-mail, etc.
See attached screen shots for a few views of DSM 2.1.
I'm running with two WD Green 750 GB drives in Basic mode, with one disk as "operational" and the second as a backup, using File Station 2 to sync the two drives. To date I have not experienced any problems with DSM 2.1, but there are so many features available to the Synology NAS products that I can't do justice here to the quality or issues with all of them. Rather, I'll point to the user forums at the Synology website and to posts in the Synology forum at SmallNetBuilder for information / concerns about the specific applications you are interested in. I'll also point out SmallNetBuilder as a great place to get comparison performance data on many NAS units; the DS209 is not listed in the site's NAS charts, but it should perform the same as or a bit better than the single drive DS109 which has the same CPU but only 128 MB main memory.
The DS209 can be compared to the DS209+II mentioned above, as well as the QNAP TS-219P NAS Superior Performance All-in-One Server with iSCSI for SOHO and Home Users and QNAP TS-239 Pro Turbo NAS Superior Performance All-in-One Server with iSCSI for Business. There are also cheaper alternatives such as the DS209j mentioned above, the D-Link DNS321 2-Bay NAS, and the Buffalo Technology LS-WS1.0TGL/R1 LinkStation Mini 1TB Compact Shared NAS, but you will be giving up significant performance to save money as these less expensive NASes tend to have slow CPUs and less memory. IMHO the DS209 hits a sweet spot on the performance / price curve.
In summary, the Synology DS209 offers a good combination of performance and features. And while it is not the least expensive option for a dual drive NAS, it offers value for those who need more performance than an entry level box.
|
|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A great purchase -- if you're tech savvy, September 1, 2009
I picked up this unit because of a favorable (although, not the most favorable) CNet review and the customer comments here at Amazon that said the unit was geared more towards people with a strong technical background. The Amazon reviewers are right -- this product is geared to people who have a solid understanding of how a NAS works. If you're comfortable with that, then by all means, get this product. The setup was relatively easy and the performance has been far better than I expected. I give this unit four stars instead of five for three basic flaws.
The first flaw is the manual hard drive installation. I had a couple of WD 640GB hard drives lying around and bought the unit without drives planning to use those. Rather than having a simple drive caddy system, I had to crack open the case, wire up the hard drives, screw them into the chassis, then put the case back together. The step-by-step instructions for how to do this were very clear, and the package came with 1 extra chassis screw and 2 extra hard drive screws. I just think for a unit like this, a simple drive caddy mechanism should be part of the package.
The second flaw is that the software that came with the unit did not work with MacOS X Snow Leopard. The PPC-based software required Rosetta to be installled. After Rosetta was installed, it crashed reproducibly every time I attempted to run it. Intel-capable Macs have been out for several years. Synology should update their software. If you have MacOS Snow Leopard only, I believe you'll be unable to install the unit. I have another Windows machine I was able to perform the initialization with. That Windows software ran without issue.
The final flaw is that the fan on the device is rather loud. It's a normal PC fan, and it blows a good amount of air. Luckily, when not in use the disks hibernate and the fan will rev down, so it's not constant, but it was extremely noticeable when I first turned the unit on.
Despite those three flaws, my experience so far with this product has been great. The upload and download speeds via SMB/CIFS over an internal wired network have been very fast. It comes with a plethora of features. Whatever way you want to use this unit, you can use it. I will probably only use maybe 3 or 4 of the 20 or so features I can enable. Furthermore, the unit looks nice as a standalone box on my shelf. Overall, I'd recommend this to anyone with the technical confidence to install it.
|
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent product that will make Synology a leader in this market., August 18, 2009
I normally do not write reviews, but I have to share this one because purchasing a NAS is a tough decision. There are SO MANY of these things on the market. Many companies think they can just give users the bare minimum because they think their users are just using it for storage and that's it. Synology understands its users. The applications that come with the DS series are well designed, solidly implemented, and just beautiful. The product just works, and the throughput is phenomenal. I had the Buffallo LinkStation Duo Pro, and used it for about a month, but it just started to get unbearable when you start putting a ton of small files in one directory. Stay away from Buffallo Technology products, and consider Synology as an EXCELLENT alternative. Yeah, you pay a bit more, but in this NAS market, you get what you pay for.
I cannot explain how satisfied I am with this product. It is dependable, robust, and well designed. You will not regret owning this product because it will let you have peace of mind, and mobility. I am using two 1TB Western Digital drives, and Synology claims that this supports 2TB drives from Seagate. I would have bought the 2TB if they were out on the market longer.
Thank you Synology for researching your audience, understanding their needs, and for creating an exceptional product.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|