|
|
110 of 117 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
DO NOT BUY - ALL UNITS ARE DEFECTIVE, August 31, 2009
***** WARNING: THIS DRIVE IS GARBAGE - DO NOT BUY - DO NOT BUY - DO NOT BUY - DO NOT BUY *****
I picked up one of these a couple of weeks ago. The concept of a good ruggedized portable USB hard drive for the consumer market is LONG overdue. The 500GB SimpleTough worked fine the first few times I used it, plugging the fold out USB ribbon cable into a laptop or desktop...everything seemed ok and it worked like a champ...and was faster than any other external USB drive of its size that I've ever used. Now all of a sudden I start getting "Device Not Recognized", no matter what laptop or desktop, USB port, or even USB hub (powered) that I plugged it into, and regardless of OS (using XP or Vista). After several iterations of patiently unplugging it, letting it spin down for a minute, then plugging it back in...still not recognized. So during my last attempt I was going to give up, box it back up and return it...I started to reach to unplug the drive and lifted it up off of my desk a little bit...and suddenly...it WORKED and my system recognized it. So I tried the theory, I unplugged it again, let it sit, plugged it back in while it was sitting flat...didn't work...then as soon as I elevated it to about a 45 degree angle off my desk it was recognized and worked again. Diagnosis...bad USB ribbon cable, and bad workmanship. I have treated this drive with kid gloves and it never got any kind of abuse, period. The drive may be ruggedized, but clearly the ribbon cable is a serious Achilles heel. I can't say all of these drives are bad since it was just this one, but if you buy one of these KEEP YOUR RECEIPT AND ORIGINAL PACKAGING...it may end up like mine did. I am probably going to get a replacement, if I do...I'll update this review good or bad based on what happens. For now, it's definitely a 1 star (0 star) product in my opinion.
UPDATE 8/31/09 - *3 stars now*
...got a replacement SimpleTough 500GB, so far it is working great...time will tell, and I will update this review with any good or bad news soon. I would have given this product at least 3 stars for the fact my replacement works fine, but Amazon...why do you allow people to edit reviews and not change the star rating if their opinion has changed? The stars are the first (and sometimes only) thing people look at...
11/4/09 - NO STARS, Amazon, how about giving us negative star review capability?
***FAIL*** THIS IS GARBAGE. After being used for very light duty (probably have copied about 100GB+ data to it that was read statically off and on afterwards, not much writing/deleting after that), and being treated like a fine piece of delicate glass artwork for a few months, the USB cable on my replacement is dead too. But if I gently tilt the unit to a 45 degree angle, magically the USB cable works...just don't bump it or it disconnects. This is ridiculous especially in this day and age where portable hard drive technology is MATURE AND WELL ESTABLISHED.
- Tried emailing Hitachi about this issue, no response.
UPDATE:
12/7/09 - Opened support case with Hitachi's Storage support (aka their SimpleTech division)
[...]
12/9/09 - no reply from Hitachi support, not even an acknowledgement of my support issue that I filed through their portal.
HITACHI - *RECALL* THESE DRIVES before someone forces you to do so legally. You rip off consumers and expect to be rewarded with continuing business? I am never recommending anything made by Hitachi to anyone. A little business common sense 101, you fix product quality problems instead of ignoring them, letting them worsen, and eat at your bottom line. I predict Hitachi will not have an external storage business at this rate, and will spin SimpleTech back off as an "unprofitable" venture. Quality is an investment that pays back one hundred fold.
2/8/10 - UPDATE - HITACHI, YOU NEED TO REPLACE THESE DRIVES. After this unit failed, like 99.9% of them do, I decided to see if I could fix the problem. I opened up the case by cracking off the side panels and prying the top from the bottom after removing the case screws and then the screws securing the drive to the plastic enclosure. What you have inside is a HACK JOB of USB cable splicing onto a HD-2523 v1.2 USB header (wafer) board...and the cable is hanging on literally by a THREAD. You have 2 black cables, one of which is twisted into the sheathing filament wire and is literally hanging by a thread...then the other green, white, and red wires are very badly crimped near the connection to the USB board...almost to the point where they are severed). THAT is why when this unit fails, you have to angle it at 45 degrees up or down, or flip it over and plug it upside down into say a USB 2.0 hub - but eventually the delicate wiring will snap in half internally. You basically have 5$ worth of cheap plastic, rubber, and electronic parts, attached to a Hitachi 500GB 5400RPM drive (model# HTS545050B9A300 / part# A57915) which is worth about $45.00 at mfr cost. This unit is worth about $50-60 TOPS leaving the factory...and the 500GB models were originally sold for nearly $200.00!!!! The markup isn't as much of a shocker as is the dirt poor quality of this unit. I am trying to see if I can find or cobble together another USB enclosure or wafer board/USB cable combo compatible with this drive, or...try to find someone with a laptop that could take this drive and at least get the data off of it.
This is the hard drive itself, same model/revision, etc on Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Hitachi-Travelstar-5K500-B-Internal-0A57915/dp/B0029LHVLO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1265685083&sr=8-1
***** WARNING: THIS DRIVE IS GARBAGE - DO NOT BUY - DO NOT BUY - DO NOT BUY - DO NOT BUY *****
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|