Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
32 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great lens for the price, September 27, 2009
I received this lens a few days ago and immediately started using it. The lens came with a lens hood and caps only, no carrying pouch. The lens is slightly bigger and bulkier than my 18-70 Nikkor that it is replacing. It feels great in the hands and in the camera, I can feel the quality. The lens focused accurately and speedily. I can't comment on its speed versus the non VC version, but its faster than my 18-70 Nikkor (as it should since its $300 more expensive). It locked on in low light pretty good too, something I had trouble with in my 18-70. I tested the VC out and found that the VC has a delay of about a second before taking effect. You will notice the effect because the viewfinder will have a slight jerking motion before taking effect. The VC worked quite well though, taking sharp pics most of the time (if done properly) down to 1/8th second. This lens is TACK SHARP, even at F2.8 it is very sharp.
The zoom ring comes with a zoom creep lock that works at 17mm, but the rings are stiff enough that you won't need to use it.
There are three things that this lens wasn't so great on. The focus is loud, its not an ultrasonic motor. The VC has the 1 second delay which is not so hot. The VC is also loud, you can hear it take effect.
Overall, this is a fine lens for myself. Those who find the VC delay, or noise, might be turned off by it, so take that into consideration.
|
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Tamron 17-50mm f/2.8 SP XR Di II VC for Nikon, October 16, 2009
Been going back and forth with lenses for a while now, and finally have my bag full. It's filled mainly with Sigma, but when this Tamron came out, I just couldn't resist the 2.8 through the zoom range and the VC (vibration compensation). So how is it? Well, I love it. The other reviewer here mentioned it's a little loud, and that's true. But that doesn't bother me one bit. It's very, very sharp, generally focuses well and quickly, even in low light, and has accurate color representation. At 17mm 2.8 it's a LITTLE softer, but not much, and once you stop down it gets tack sharp, which is true for most lenses anyway.
As an end note, something needs to be said for Tamron's vibration compensation technology. I recently sold my 18-55 VR Nikon kit lens because I got this Tamron, and the VC works at LEAST as well as the VR does, if not measurably better. Yes, there is a jump when you depress the shutter button halfway, as the motor starts up, but it's something that you get used to extremely quickly (or at least I did), and once that's over, the image is still as a quiet summer lake. The VC works VERY well.
Overall, I'd say the build quality of this lens is very good, and it's definitely a keeper.
The one con I'll personally give it is that the macro capability leaves something to be desired. This isn't billed as a macro lens, so I can't really knock it, but my Sigma 17-70 w/macro smokes it.
Other than that, great lens, especially if you can't afford the Nikon lenses.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good lens, October 17, 2009
I was initially looking for the older version of this lens without VC and the AF motor as it is suppose to focus better than on the non VC with built-in focus motor. But when this revised version with VC came out I had to get it because of the following:
1.) No other manufacturer (Nikon/Sigma/Tokina) provide stabilization for this range of zoom.
2.) Previous versions have been known to be a great lens, with image quality rivaling the much more expensive Nikon.
3.) It's half price of the Nikon.
4.) Available on Amazon. :)
Compared to Nikon's 17-55mm which is built _and_ sized like a tank, the Tamron is lighter and sized considerably smaller. The lens is mostly plastic, but the workmanship is great. Both the zoom and focus rings rotate smoothly. I'm very happy with the lens and it's image quality.
Some other lens I shoot with: Nikon 10.5mm fisheye, Sigma 30mm f1.4, Nikon 50mm f1.8.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|