Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Where?, April 3, 2009
I have been to and lived in Paraguay multiple times, as well as other developing countries. It is clear Carver has not. Yes, Paraguay is corrupt. Yes, Paraguay has crime. Yes, Paraguay isn't the cleanest place, but, it is not the way that Carver describes it by any stretch of the imagination. It is too bad he is so ethnocentric and unable to view the many sides of beautiful Paraguay. It is too bad he things Paraguay is just so isolated and sooooo dirty and soooo impoverished (try Nigeria if you want to talk about poverty and dirt!) This is very clearly an inexperienced citizen of the world, trying to be one by making up a fantasy world of danger and intrigue. What he has written is actually a very sad reflection on himself.
Carver owes an apology to Paraguayans and to any one who reads this. Next time sell you book as non-fiction.
ROHAYHU PARAGUAY!
|
|
|
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
This book is a disgrace!, August 21, 2008
As a Paraguayan citizen living in London since 2003 (what a paradox), I feel deeply offended by this book by Mr. Carver. Other people have written extensive reviews at amazon.co.uk, so I wouldn't like to extend myself unnecessarily here over this issue. The book is full of inaccuracies about many things (language, local geography, names of people and places, historical facts and dates, etc.) which makes me think that Mr. Carver went somewhere else, got lost and decided to write a book about it. Any travel guide about South America will give you more accurate and credible information about Paraguay than this book.
It is true that there is a lot to be done in Paraguay in many respects. I would be the first person to acknowledge that. However, this book doesn't help at all. On the contrary, it makes a huge disservice to the country and its people. What a shame.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Lies all lies!, May 1, 2009
Ive lived in Paraguay since 2002, am married to a Paraguayan, have a Paraguayan son and am the author of the Rough Guide and Lonely Planet for Paraguay, so I feel quite qualified in stating categorically that this book is a pile of not very well written (and not very believable!) lies. It is written with a sort of condescending paranoia that distances any right minded person from the author almost from the start and frankly more often than not crosses the line into outright racism eg "My race, my pale skin made me an intruder" - would be funny if it wasnt offensive, wouldnt it?!. His constant unfounded fear of being mugged, raped, stabbed you name it prevents him from making even the most base level connection with the country or its people, and as a result what it means to be a Paraguayan or in Paraguay completely passes him by. Paraguayans are, quite contrary to the national character assassination forwarded in this book, an extremely friendly, upbeat and proud nation of people, not the savage band of corrupt, barely human criminals that he would have us believe!. Equally worrying is a sort of cultural superiority complex which he possesses that seems to infest everything that he does, thinks, says and writes, as though he is worshipped and revered on account of his white skin and English nationality - give me a break, its in your head!! Many of the things that happened to him in his presumably brief time in the country I seriously doubt ever happened at all but were included to make what was presumably a run of the mill visit to a perfectly normal South American country sound that bit more interesting. To cite a couple of the more stupid examples of this "treating the reader like a fool". The customs supposedly mistook him for the British Ambassador on arrival because the country doesnt see many tourists - I dont think so, but neatly illustrates what I mean about his superiority complex! He had a colony of vampire bats on hotel ceilings in the centre of Asuncion - what hotel in the world would have a colony of bats on the celing?, I mean come on! Besides is the author qualified to distinguish a vampire bat from any other? Or is the supposed danger posed by vampires just another attempt to "beef up" the story and make the author look big and brave? The savage attack on both Paraguay and Paraguayans is not only unmeritted and unfair, but factually inaccurate REPEATEDLY. The history is wrong, his grasp of the language is laughable to the point where you wonder where his information came from (what is an indigeno? or chantar?, these are nearly words that he has presumably made up or heard something similar and had a guess at both the spelling and the meaning!), his geography suggests he didnt visit half the places he claims to, and the sad obsession with supposed enclaves of holed up Nazis in Paraguay is so clicheed now that is boring even when it is much more well written than this. My advice to anybody even contemplating reading this pile of nonsense is go to Paraguay and then (if you must!) read the book afterwards so you can share in just how bad it is (get it out the library, youll regret putting money in the authors pocket if you buy it!). The other way round and you will mentally place Paraguay in the same band of current "stay-away" countries as Rwanda, the Congo and other war-torn areas that you would avoid like the plague, not to mention buying into the fantasy world of the author where he paints himself as an adventurous roving journalist visiting the most dangerous corners of the planet. He isnt! Come to Paraguay and see for yourself! And if you want to read a prejudiced, 19th Century, upper class "roving adventurer" type fiction novel then get something that was written by a Victorian colonial author. At least the bigotry and ignorance shown in those can be excused on account of the unenlightened time in which they were written!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|