|
27 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Clueless, March 13, 2004
There are lots of unusual opinions in this book. Here's a good example: Page 315 says "No matter what you may have heard or read, toilet training is unnecessary." He says it's a normal part of development and "does not require training." Huh? My toddler's going to do it all on his own??? He says to let him run around naked at 18 months, buy a potty chair, and when he has to go he'll "remember this new piece of furniture". (Oh, so that's where the book cover idea came from.)He thinks dentists and dental care are unnecessary for a baby, advising on p. 320 "don't bother with toothbrushing until 12 to 18 months" while the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry advises parents to brush at the first sign of a tooth - mine get teeth at 4-5 months old. Under sleep he answers the question "When is my baby going to sleep through the night?" with "Never." That's reassuring. Colic - Page 73: "As far as I'm concerned, colic does not really exist." (One of mine had colic, and yes, it does exist!) He says they cry because they "never get the opportunity to cry" so they "cry all the time." I'm confused... And how to deal with excessive crying? Let her cry herself to sleep. Gas doesn't exist either, according to the author "Gas is not a sign of discomfort" "do not give in to the temptation to help Lucy get rid of gas my massaging her belly or pumping her legs or burping her." As a woman who has breastfed my children, and overcome many obstacles I cannot believe the erroneous information this author writes on the topic. He makes plenty of assumptions based on ignorance. He refers to breastfeeding as "popular" and says that the ideal breastfeeding consultant is "your mother or an older sister" and says of lactation consultants "beyond the expert hand-holding, however, I take a dim view of their professional equipment and theories." (p.48) and the first choice for help is a female family member, but if you don't have one "hire a lactation specialist to come help out at your house, as long as she leaves her equipment at hers." (Whatever that means, my LCs never had any strange equipment!) He goes on to say that breastfeeding is easy and gives odd advice, for example, if your baby has difficult latching on "let her work harder for her meal." (Oh that oughta work!) Under the family bed he says that "it's a challenge to create a larger family when your family is in your bed." Lots of co-sleeping families have more than one child! William Sears, the most vocal proponent of the family bed has eight children. There's an odd disrespectful tone throughout, such as when talking about crooked teeth "If Lucy's fangs initially erupt crookedly don't be concerned." I'm afraid to read any further. Definitely look for an alternative to this questionable book such as What to Expect, Gentle Baby Care, The Baby Book, the AAP Guide.
|