|
24 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Would that it were so, April 4, 2002
By A Customer
What's the difference between marriage and living together? Well, let's see: ". . . for better or worse, in sickness and in health, for richer or poorer, so long as we both shall live."Marriage takes relationships out of the realm of consumer services--"I'll stay with you as long as the product meets my liking"--and puts them into the realm of moral commitment. For all her good intentions, Staheli puts marriage back into the realm of consumer services. I guess therapists just don't understand ethics--everything has to be self-interest. You affair-proof your marriage by making yourself essential to your spouse's self-interest, basically. Good luck, I guess--but what's the point? The point of marriage, I thought, was that your partner would stick by you in good times and bad--not just when you're boosting their self-esteem. Speaking of which, Staheli seems not to know the massive, conclusive research literature showing that, in fact, self-esteem does NOT correlate with behavior. So keep on boosting your partner's self-esteem, if you want--and I think that's a good thing to do, just because it's nicer--but don't think that will cause any particular behavior. This book contains some good tips on relationships, but it betrays little understanding either of the ethics--and whole point--of marriage, or of current research. The notion that you can "affair proof" your mariage is just superstition, and this book provides nice superstitious procedures that let you believe you can protect yourself--that is, things you can do to create an illusion of control, which nonetheless actually give you none. Whether your spouse chooses infidelity as a way of making him or herself feel good is simply beyond your control. What makes marriage an ethical commitment? You and your partner promise to put each other's interests, and the welfare of the relationship, above your own, rather than seeking self-interest primarily. You can't make your partner keep that promise by turning yourself into a meeting-his-interest-machine. Love your spouse as best you can--but don't suffer the illusion that this affair-proofs your marriage. And if an affair is committed, don't think it's because you forgot, in essence, to knock wood.
|