Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
89 of 100 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Title should be 88 simple strategies for finanacial FAILURE, June 17, 2000
I bought this book because the hard back version was on the clearance shelf of my local bookstore for only $3.99. After reading it, I discovered why the book was so cheap. It appears that Edelman did not write this book because he cares about consumers/investors, he wrote it for the sole purpose of filling his own pockets with extra change. Mr. Edelman's inability to get his facts straight is blatantly visible throughout the book. For example, Edelman states that the Vanguard 500 Index fund did not exist 10 years prior to the publication of his book (published in 1998). But as a Vanguard investor I can tell you that the inception of the 500 Index fund was on August 31, 1976. He also tells readers to avoid inflation-indexed bonds, claiming that people only buy them hoping that inflation will rise so their bond values will jump. This is nonsense (please don't insult my intelligence Ric). People purchase these bonds as a small conservative part of their portfolio to provide protection against the investments (equities, high-yield bonds, etc.) that decrease in value during times of inflation. Lastly, Edelman completely trashes the Roth IRA. Although the type of IRA that one chooses depends on many factors such as age, income, tax bracket, and expected age of retirement, the Roth IRA is a wonderful choice for many (if not most) young investors. No taxes on accumlated earnings is usually more beneficial than no taxes on contributions (you can figure out the math for your own situation using an IRA calculator). Edelman distorts the facts in order to scare people and sell his book (shock grabs attention and sells a product). There are many other examples throughout his book of half-truths and misrepresentations, but since I am limited to 1,000 words here I cannot name them all. In conclusion, I must say that I do pity the novice investor who chooses this as an introduction to the financial world and heeds Edelman's advice as golden.
|
|
|
29 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This book will make you money!, August 8, 1998
By A Customer
Whoever said that money is a very, very controversial subject was only touching the surface! They should check out these reviews. I believe and know from nine years of investing that a good, emphasis on"good" 401 (k) plan is one of the best investments in America today. To the negative vibes on 401 (k) and other retirement plans, ask yourselves, "How much did you pay in taxes last year?" To the great mathimatical geniouses out there who don't understand non prepayment of mortgages, take out your calculator and figure out which will make you more money; prepaying on a 7%-9% mortgage or putting that same prepayment cash in a good mutual fund and making 15%-20% per year? This is known as "opportunity risk" in the later example, your money could double in 3-4 years with mutuals so why would you want to prepay a low interest mortgage?. As far as the other books recommended, I would suggest "The Millionaire Next Door", 'More Wealth With! out Risk" "Financial SelfDefense" and 'The Richest Man in Bablyon" a lot of the other books either all repeat themselves or are out of sync with the times.
|
|
|
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good advice from a highly qualified CFP, October 30, 2003
Ric Edelman may tell you a few things you don't agree with or don't coincide with other so called "experts" who write financial books, but, how are you doing financially? How much money have you lost in the market following their "expert" advice?I know I got smacked following a certain East Coast female author and got back on track with "What You Need To Do Now" and Ordinary People, Extraordinary Wealth." I have just strated to read this book along with "Discover the Wealth Within You." I also recommend Suze Ormans excellent books "The Road to Wealth" and "The Laws of Money" to get you on the fact track to financial success. A lot of what Ric teaches is different and controversial but the bottom line is, it works.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|