|
20 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Please read this book before reading it to your child., December 19, 2002
My daughter and I just finished reading this book together a little over a week ago.This book has upset her more than any other book we have ever read together (and we have read thousands.) She cried for nearly an hour after we finished and basically fell asleep crying. She was still very disturbed the next day and I wasn't sure if she would be able to go to school. My daughter bought this book from her second grade book form and it was, of course, highly recommended. It has won an award and everyone we had spoken to about it while we were reading it, said it was a great book, even though they hadn't actually read it. I am not sure after actually reading it how appropriate it is for a young girl such as my seven year old. I discussed the book with my daughter's school's librarian. He did a research on it and said that it was geared towards a minimum of 5th grade level and that it was definitely inappropriate for a 2nd grader. I was very shocked by the ending - something very bad happens to one of the main characters in the story and you should know this before reading this book to your child. This is what upset my daughter so greatly. It is definitely a good book, I will not argue that. It is well written and has interesting characters. But, for an imaginative 7 year old who is drawn in to the magic and wonder of this story, you will find that the ending can be quite psychologically disturbing to the young reader or listener when the violent ending occurs. If I had read this book before reading it to my daughter or been warned at least about its content, I would have never shared this story with her at this age. Please read this book before reading it to your child and decide whether or not it is appropriate for them.
|