Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
182 of 195 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Beware of the Professional F/T Reviewers, August 14, 2007
There are people who market their consulting services by writing glowing 5 star reviews of *every* new book that appears on Amazon. Ignore these people.
Here's an honest review.
This book is basically the business version of "Chick Lit". The author's real passion is for recounting her affairs with various billionaires. First, there's Bill Gates with whom she had a one stand. Frankly, I thought Bill was too much of nerd to do this sort of thing. Then there's another short-lived relationship with Oracle's Larry Ellison who, according to her, has "buns of steel." Talk about TMI! Finally, there's a third mystery billionaire who is never identified.
Then there is the tiresomely long section on her problems with her New Age guru. He turned out to be a con man just like most western religious leaders. Apparently she couldn't see this coming.
The remainder of the book consists of high school level "wisdom" on how to succeed in life. For example, you need to master GSD (Getting Stuff Done). What a great insight!
To pad RfR out to book length she throws in a completely out-of-place chapter (CEO as Cash Extraction Officer) near the end on business funding sources which feels like a quickie Google "cut n paste" job.
The book's greatest strengths are the catchy chapter titles. Just scan them and you will absorb the book's total value in seconds.
Before the dotcoms exploded the author claimed to be a venture capitalist. All I know of her exploits as a VC is that she appeared in a business magazine sitting in a bubble bath wearing nothing but a cowboy hat and holding a cigar. That picture sums up the author nicely: a self-promoter and lime-light seeker with little of substance to offer the reader.
I was really hoping to like this book since there's so little writing from female entrepreneurs. Unfortunately, it's just disappointing fluff.
|
|
|
22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Hoped for alot, got lost in the sexual relations, December 28, 2007
Ok, found this book in Business Week. A HUGE ad. Should have listened to my intuition. Great book for breaking old thoughts, getting out there and doing it! Yeah! But... Then the numerous parts on her 'relations' with 'various billionaires'. Yes, she outright brags! It's ridiculous and ruined her credibility for me. I did get something from the book, but without the kissing scenes. I reaffirmed my empowered feelings etc... but not much else. I did join her website: she sends you 'SPAM' about her teleconferences (the 1st wasn't too bad). Then builds you up for the Finale: the $200 conference she's holding. You had me at 'Unsubscribe'. Don't really recommend this one, but would highly recommend: The Magic of Thinking Big by David Schwartz (Wow, REALLY gets you going) or 4 Hour work week (bit analytical but good inspiration and NOT just for those who want to quit their job). Hope that helps. Smile everyone, Have a great day!
|
|
|
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
More Entertaining than Self-Help, November 18, 2007
Renegades usually don't follow rules because that is what makes them renegades. Rules for Renegades aims to share Christine Comaford-Lynch's experiences. She states that she started with no special advantages and that 10 life lessons -- the rules -- she shares will help readers gain confidence and self-esteem, build strong relationships, and become financially independent.
The book oozes Comaford-Lynch's fiery style and rivets. This is a woman whose history consists of running away to New York to try modeling, becoming a Buddhist monk, inventing several products earning millions of dollars, and making a mistake that cost $8 million. She tells fascinating stories while interweaving advice on funding and starting a company. Reading the book is akin to reading People Magazine and getting the inside scoop on celebrities from a business perspective. Instead of reading about actors, read about an executive who meets celebrities and attempts to motivate.
What are the chances any of us will experience such meetings? Very little. The celebs with the biggest parts are Microsoft's Bill Gates, Oracle's Larry Ellison, and an anonymous billionaire. She drops plenty of names of people she meet along the way including Connie Chung, Maury Povich, Jane Fonda, and Barbara Walters. This book qualifies more the autobiography section than for the self-help section.
The author's writing feels loud and she sounds like she bounces off the walls. Few successful people have a personality resembling Comaford-Lynch's maniacal and hyperactive style. Thus, her experiences aren't something many of us can do or make happen even if we tried. Her advice seems more kitschy than insightful.
In talking about what it takes to be success, she believes a person's GSD (Gets Stuff Done) is more important than an MBA. She doesn't mean to slam education, but tells readers that the real world experience is what matters instead of the pile of degrees. A GSD means you know how to get your foot in the door, set goals, listening to the voice in your head, and avoiding pushiness. If you want to earn a GSD-style degree, David Allen's GTD (Getting Things Done) is better.
The most interesting thing in the "Work Your Money Mojo" chapter is its title. The advice on raising money from outside the company doesn't offer anything new: Prove you have a viable product, set measurable goals to track progress, and report to management. However, she does a valuable service in providing resources for getting funding. This information, though, feels out of place in the disjointed book.
Comaford-Lynch deserves congratulations for making millions, working as a CEO for multiple companies, and learning from her mistakes. Her path to all of money, career, and happiness isn't one most people would want to take to grow and prosper. In sum, Rules for Renegades proves an entertaining read with too much emphasis on things that are bigger than they really are.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|