Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
great book, August 25, 2005
I learned about the book after reading Holland's "Rubicon" (also a very good book), in which it was used as one of the primary sources. The translation is very readable and really reads as a novel. Appian wrote the history a few centuries after the events described, but it remains the only continuous narrative of the period between the fall of the Gracchi and rise of Augustus. This is obviously an event-filled and fascinating period in Roman history. For those interested in the period, I would recommend Holland's book and follow it up with this one.
|
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Notes from the Chaos, or: Infamy Unvarnished, December 17, 2007
Ancient Mediterranean history seems to have entered a revival period in 2007 (...or, at least, this was what TIME magazine informed me a few months ago). Copies of the *Illiad* and *Odyssey* gain new shiny covers and return to prominence on upper-middle coffee tables. Frank Millar's *300* captivated millions of college kids with its bald and rather bad triune-stroke. Vin Diesel (!!) is apparently scripting a version of Hannibal Barca's trek across the Alps. And HBO concluded its visually-magnificent-if-liberally-altered account of the fall of the Roman Republic with style and aplomb and certainly no lack of visceral carnality. I imagine, after the fact, that certain curious consumers interested in the fall of the Roman Republic / rise of the Roman Empire searched amazon.com and like retailers for the "real" story behind the lurid invention. Thus it is rather surprising that this tome - Appian's *The Civil Wars* - has been reviewed two times, considering it is the only surviving *continuous* history of the period, detailing the fall from beginning to end without serious lacunas or missing chapters.
Fans of HBO's Rome, casual neophytes of Latin history - this is what you are looking for. Appian chronicles the `good / bad old days' of the Roman Republic with taut precision, outlining the central conflict (land ownership, upper class greed - how times change, how... ) that eventually led to the rabble-rousing and subsequent murder of the Gracci Bros, the Catiline conspiracy, the rise and messy fall of the tyrants Sulla and Marus, the rise of Pompey and Caesar and the formation of the First Triumvirate, the assassination of Caesar, the struggles of Antony and Octavian to retain power in war-torn Italy, the creation of the Second Triumvirate and the cracking of its façade...
Appian wrote his histories around 200 years after the fact (this Penguin edition estimates its composition between AD 145 and 165), so - as with all ancient histories - the facts and minutiae will ever be in question. Appian's style is not the easiest to read, either: he favors long complex sentences, occasional tangents and the usual influx of names, names, names - happily, this edition contains voluminous footnotes and detailed maps. For a greater reading experience, I recommend having copies of Plutarch's *Makers of Rome* and *Fall of the Roman Republic* on hand - though not chronologically paced like the Civil Wars, they give insight into the major movers and shakers, offer a sort of conclusion with the portrait of Antony, and augment the overall impact of this turbulent, fascinating period of human development.
'Limitless human ambition, terrible lust for power, indefatigable patience, and evil in ten thousand shapes' -- the glory and the infamy, still unvarnished two thousand years postscript...
|
|
|
7 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing, July 19, 2000
One of the best comprehensive histories of the Roman civil wars. Contains almost everything you want to know and more. A must for any Roman history fan or buff.
|
|
|
|