Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
46 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fine book, somewhat mis-titled, May 4, 2005
This is a very nice piece of work but not exactly an atlas of ancient history. It is a cultural geography of Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East. It has far fewer place names than I wanted from an atlas and much of it is pre-history beginning some 40,000 years ago.
It starts with a brisk and entertaining account of the author's methods for interpreting scanty archaeological and linguistic evidence. This is at once accessible, learned, detailed, acerbic, and engaging. There is a funny bit about how archaeologists will say "a major new civilization" when they mean "a particularly disappointing dig", or will say "earliest known" when they mean "undated", and more. There is a terrific account of what it took to re-settle humans in Europe as the last ice age retreated. The effects were strong on Northern Europe into historical times (indeed Scandinavia and some of Russia is still rising and drying out today). The author estimates the human population of all of Europe and the Middle East was only about 100,000 in 9,000 BC.
The book describes movements of peoples, languages, technologies, and writing systems. It maps out the earliest known trade relations. It includes many maps but with few place names. Rather they indicate where various ethnic groups lived and what technologies were used where. As it enters historical times the book describes the campaigns of rulers and empires. It is a beautiful piece of work and beautifully concise.
On the other hand, if you are reading Euripides and you want to know where Lemnos was, you won't find it here. You will find the most famous places: In Greece, besides
Athens and Sparta, are Mycenea, Lesbos, Argos. That is like finding Chicago and San Francisco in an atlas of the US. But you will not find general Meno's birthplace of Larissa--which you would read about in either Plato or Xenophon. It is like not finding St. Louis in a US atlas. Those places are found in the Atlas of the Greek World (Cultural Atlas of) by Peter Levi. And they are found in another book you should read anyway, namely the Landmark Thucydides. It is a terrific edition available in paperback and it shows these places in detailed maps.
|
|
|
32 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Atlas of Ancient, Modern, Recent, Medieval History Series, August 13, 2001
I have taught History for over 15 years. In all of my years of study and teaching I have never seen a series that was so succinctly, and logically protrayed. I have been asked to help college students who were failing Western Civiliazation. I gave them this series, and none ever came back with less than a B+. I have taught teachers with multiple Masters Degrees who couldn't understand why none of their college classes ever put history in such a simple and straight forward way as this series does. This series gives you one page of narrative with a facing page displaying the information pictorially. How delightfully simple can it get. I recommend this series to any student of History, particularly to those in Biblical studies.
|
|
|
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Looks so-so, but IS great, February 24, 2003
Having studied history, I'm still interested in lots of historical subjects. But since I'm not 'doing' history on a daily basis I find that my historical knowledge has become rusty in places. Books like the Penguin Atlas of Ancient History get it well oiled again. In was a bit dissapointed by the size of the book and the lack of colour on the maps, but when you start using the book, it turns out to be a wonderful tool. It made me dust off my old books from university again and dig into things again. Texts are realy condensed, so if you have some background information that helps. But the maps, and that's what it's all about, are great.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Colin McEvedy
by Colin McEvedy
by John Haywood
by William McNeill
See all 39 books citing this book
