Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
19 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A great read for parents and kids alike, November 9, 2006
I was very intrigued by the exceptional reviews it had received here on Amazon - no review received less than three stars! After reading it, I understood why.
This very solid, well-written book displayed remarkable accuracy with respect to its portrayal of what I'll call "medieval life". Such accuracy is usually reserved for older readers.
The main character was immensely likable, not to mention well portrayed and tangible. Halt - who seems to be a fan favorite if the reviews here are any indication - is a bit too archetypal and at one point displays a remarkable departure from his "core identity". I'm referencing the scene where Horace faces his three tormentors. Halt actively encourages revenge, and this - while certainly enjoyable - was shocking. Vigilante justice doesn't fit his core identity.
Still, this book held its audience captive even without the use of magic. Considering what some young adult fantasy novels need to do to captivate their audience, this is a remarkable feat.
|
|
|
18 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I wanna be a Ranger, too!, January 31, 2006
This is actually the first in a new fantasy series for juveniles, but I thought it was excellent. Lord Arland has taken in the orphans of the area, and in their 15th year, they have Choosing Day. Will, whose parentage is unknown, wants to go to Battleschool more than anything. However, his slight stature stands in his way, and he, instead is lured into apprenticeship with the Ranger. Will comes to enjoy his apprenticeship, although he still finds his master, Halt, a little strange. When danger threatens the kingdom, though, Will finally realizes the importance of his job and his master. I really liked this story - and I look forward to the next in the series, The Burning Bridge, released in June.
|
|
|
18 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
worth a read, not worth buying., March 1, 2007
Of the book(s) themselves - I read The Ruins of Gorlan and the sequel, The Burning Bridge in a night - I have very few complaints. The other rewiewers are correct. These are juvenile books, intended for younger boys, and I found the pace and tone of them to be highly appropriate for that age-range.
The core of the first book - a coming of age tale - may be a bit slow for modern impatient boys, as the action and suspense don't pick up til nearly the end of the book. The focus is on Will, who realizes that he doesn't have to be a knight to be a good person, and a good warrior. As he grows, he learns more about his history, his kingdom, and his character. Because it is a character focus, there isn't much action/adventure for most of the book. Despite this, it is a strong introduction, and was very similar to the feel of C.S. Lewis' intro, The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe. Both stories contain little actual action, but feel interesting and full.
I respectfully disagree with the reviewer who mentioned that the mentor Halt (an older ranger character) acts outside himself when he encourages revenge, and suggests that the revenge-taking itself is not morally appropriate. For them, perhaps. Everyone has their own beliefs.
HOWEVER, it is important to realize exactly what the context is. There is a distinct mark between vengeance and revenge. I suggest that reviewer (and everyone else) watch V for Vendetta, and understand that occasionally it is JUSTICE for bullies and torturers to be forced to endure the pain they inflicted on others. Because of this distinction, also based on character development throughout this book and the next, and also based on the understanding that the Halt character has the authority of the KING to act independently to punish wrongdoers in the realm as he sees fit, I firmly believe that Halt acted entirely within his character, and that it was a defining moment for both boys.
The second book has much more action, and develops a few more characters. I read this, and I am reminded highly of the old "serial" novels which were released as magazine articles in the past centuries. These stories have that same highly structured, episodic feel. Excellent for reading aloud over a series of nights, a bit repetitive for an older lady devouring two books in an evening. Despite the style, the author writes very well, refusing to tone down his language or historical details to make the story easier to read. The second tale quite definitively rids the world of the overarching threat which has been the tension of the story thus far, but events create a more personal threat to our growing hero and his friends, and the story ends on a cliffhanger similar to the Lemony Snicket Unfortunate Events tales.
In short, the stories themselves are well done, but not quite to the level that this poor lady will splurge on them for her library (yet) When I am old and rich, these will be on the list, but for now, and for anyone - I highly suggest your local library, as at the very least, we don't know whether the author will improve or decline in his writing style, as he has a few more novels to go.
The complaint that I have, and it is a HUGE one, is that the author has already written and PUBLISHED 5 of his series in his home country of Australia (which so far has 6 titles announced)
For the US, the third book won't be released until July '07, and the 4th until late 2008. Now I completely understand that it takes a long time to write. I've waited patiently for the Harry Potter books, just like everyone else in the world. HOWEVER, these books are ALREADY WRITTEN AND PUBLISHED!!! ... but only in Australia.
Now, I could go to an Australian online seller, convince my credit card company that the charges are legit, buy the other 3 that we don't have yet, pay to have them shipped half across the world, and then pay customs (both in Australia and here), but for books which I finish in a night, it really isn't worth the bother.
Instead, I'm going to shelve this series in the back corner of my mind, and have yet another reason to dislike publishing companies.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|