From School Library Journal
Grade 3-6?In the frame story, an Aboriginal elder begins to teach his young charge the ways and beliefs that will initiate him into manhood. They walk into the outback and stop to rest at a campsite surrounded by rock paintings. The next morning, the elder tells a creation story based on the paintings. In it, greedy birds decide they want the wetland to themselves, and the other animals fight them. Three creatures do not join in the battle?a kangaroo, a turtle, and an emu; instead, they go to the place where the boy and elder now stand. The three animals each has a dream connected to water; these dreams are depicted in the stylized paintings on the rock. Upon awakening, they use the power of their dreams to help restore peace. There is no attempt to impose a moral, or to explain what motivates the birds' greed. The power of the book resides in the vividly realistic depiction of the humans and the setting, and the equally vivid but highly stylized representation of the dreaming. Although the palette is dominated by the brown tones of the Australian earth, interesting textures and tonal contrasts give richness to each page. Morin sensitively and effectively draws on Aboriginal paintings in the myth-based sections of the book. His strong compositions and dramatic verve are riveting.?Patricia Lothrop-Green, St. George's School, Newport, RI
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 3^-4, younger for reading aloud. As in Tololwa M. Mollel's
Orphan Boy (1990) and Alice McLerran's
Ghost Dance (1995), the dark power and haunting images in Morin's illustrations give the accompanying story a hieratic tone. For what is evidently an original creation myth inspired by stories heard from an Aborigine elder in Australia's Northern Territories, Morin begins with realistically portrayed Australian animals, then transforms them into the stylized forms of rock paintings, the glowing, dotted patterns of dreamtime art, and at last into the story time's hills and rock formations. The story is framed as a ritual tale told to an Aborigine child of an ancient war between the animals that goes on until dreams show the Ancestral Kangaroo, Long-Necked Turtle, and Emu how to give each creature a place in the world. With their sharply defined edges and bright, bright colors, the dream images seem more real than the hazy, impressionistic scenes that alternate with them; tempt young readers into the dreamtime with this, and then with a collection such as Sally Morgan's
Flying Emu and Other Australian Stories (1992).
John Peters