Divine Mother, Blessed Mother: Hindu Goddesses and the Virgin Mary (Hardcover)

~ Francis X. Clooney (Author)

Editorial Reviews

Review

"Divine Mother, Blessed Mother is a groundbreaking study of comparative theology as well as a beautiful book to enjoy, a work that appears to be as much the fruit of devotion and meditation as of scholarship and philosophical reflection." --Theological Studies
"...a notable achievement. It allows new questions to flow about the nature of the divine, letting gender issues take their rightful place in mutually enriching conversation." --WATERwheel
"Divine Mother, Blessed Mother is a signal contribution to the growing theological literature on goddesses. Indebted to feminist scholarship and promoting women's well-being, Francis X. Clooney provides a close reading of Hindu and Christian texts, offering an elegant, accessible, and insightful treatment of Sri, Devi, Apirami, and Mary. His genius is in sparking their mutual conversation on their own terms. Clooney invites the reader in, and lets the theological implications flow as they will. Interreligious work is enriched immeasurably by this creative contribution."--Mary E. Hunt, Women's Alliance for Theology, Ethics and Ritual
"Many have looked forward to this kind of book for years....Reading each of the paired texts allows for extraordinary illumination between the two, as the author gives close textual analyses dealing with theology, the use of images, and textual and ritual structures. A final essay is especially valuable, as it focuses on some of the larger, broader questions of goddess worship."--CHOICE
"Francis Clooney is virtually unique in the field of Hindu Studies as a Catholic theologian with the linguistic and philosophical expertise necessary to produce sophisticated comparative analyses. Written at the intersection of feminist studies, Hindu theology, and Catholic theology, Divine Mother, Blessed Mother is a juxtaposition of three Hindu goddess-centered and three Catholic Marian texts with the aim of investigating the relationship of gender imagery to the practical purpose of liberation. This is an invitation for feminists to view male-authored depictions of sensuous female figures as potentially undermining, not expressive, of patriarchal values; for Catholics to gain empathy for Hindu goddess worship; and for scholars of comparative religion to learn from a master of the art."--Rachel Fell McDermott, Barnard College
"Francis X. Clooney, S.J. once again demonstrates the value of a comparative approach to theology. Through a close textual analysis of particular hymns from each tradition, this study of Hindu goddess traditions in relation to Christian understandings of Mary reveals fresh insight into both traditions and raises new questions to each. Entering both into the vigorous contemporary discussion of gender and divinity, and into the largely intra-Roman Catholic discussion of the historical and symbolic dimensions of Mary's role, Clooney's work is both substantive and provocative. I expect it will engender lively and productive dialogue." --Mary E. Hines, Emmanuel College

Product Description

The Virgin Mary has long been the object of both devotional and scholarly interest, and recent years have seen a proliferation of studies on Hindu goddess-worship traditions. Despite the parallels between the two, however, no one has yet undertaken a book-length comparison of these traditions. In Divine Mother, Blessed Mother, Francis Clooney offers the first extended comparative study of Hindu goddesses and the Virgin Mary. Clooney is almost unique in the field of Hindu studies as a Christian theologian with the linguistic and philosophical expertise necessary to produce sophisticated comparative analyses. Building on his previous work in comparative theology, he sheds new light not only on these individual traditions but also on the nature of gender and the divine.

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 288 pages
• Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA (November 11, 2004)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0195170377
• ISBN-13: 978-0195170375
• Product Dimensions: 9.4 x 6.3 x 1.1 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.3 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 2.2 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (6 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #1,543,343 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Highly Recommended: An Original Contribution to Hindu/Christian scholarship, May 18, 2006

By	Pravrajika Vrajaprana "Vrajaprana" (Vedanta Society, Santa Barbara) - See all my reviews

It is always a matter of celebration when Francis Clooney writes a new book. I have a number of his books and have consistently found in them a rich intellectual and spiritual feast. Divine Mother Blessed Mother closely analyzes three texts devoted to three Hindu goddesses and compares them with three Christian texts devoted to Mary. Clooney's close reading brings out the best from each text and makes for fascinating reading. My strong recomendation comes from my position both as a scholar of Hinduism as well as a Hindu nun of 30 years standing. Clooney's treatment of Hindu texts is deeply respectful and enlivened by his profound knowledge of the Hindu traditions. I highly recommend this book for Hindus and Christians who will learn about their own traditions as well as readers who are newly acquainted with each tradition.
Pravrajika Vrajaprana

6 of 15 people found the following review helpful:

1.0 out of 5 stars Low grade product in inter-faith dialogue, August 7, 2005

By	Ajaatshatru Rajiv "Feet of the Lord" (Houston, TX, USA) - See all my reviews

I read Xavier Clooney's book. I spent my money assuming that author is serious about fostering intellectual inquiry for inter-faith dialogue. However, the whole book was disappointing to say the least. Clooney's intellectual "inquiry" seems to be more of defending the orthodox christian position, rather than a serious exposition of both from their respective positions -conceptualization of Goddess in spiritual terms in Hinduism, and comparing that to Virgin Mary in Christianity. Clooney's work seems to be a hagiography of Virgin Mary, rather than serious comparative theology. I will not recommend this to anyone.

8 of 20 people found the following review helpful:

1.0 out of 5 stars Misleading and offensive, August 9, 2005

By	Julia Kingsley (Ipswich, Sussex, UK) - See all my reviews

As someone brought up in the Catholic tradition and as someone who has spent time in India, I found this book offensive and insincere. The position of women in Christianity and in particular Catholicism is nothing to write home about: everything from the wholesale burning of women as witches in medieval Europe and America to the notion that women do not have souls and are therefore not equal to men, have persistently emphasised the second-class position of women in Christian theo-politics. The extreme patriachal nature of Christianity is not in doubt. What I have observed in my time in India is that there are undoubted prejudices against women there too, but on a theological basis, their female deities are far more equal. Catholics have attempted to create Madonna cults in India, just as they have successful done via Lourdes and Guadaloupe in Europe and Latin America. However, this is mostly a conversion tactic. There is no comparison between the status of goddesses in India (high) and of Mary in Christian tradition (dubious); therefore this book is an attempt to cynically use the relatively good theological treatment of females in India and argue that therefore women are well-treated in Christianity as well.