Drudgery Divine: On the Comparison of Early Christianities and the Religions of Late Antiquity (Paperback)

by Jonathan Z. Smith (Author) "It must surely stand as one of the most touching moments of rapprochement in western history..." (more)
Key Phrases: locative traditions, disciplina arcani, comparative enterprise, New Testament, New York, Late Antiquity (more...)

Editorial Reviews

Product Description

In this major theoretical and methodological statement on the history of religions, Jonathan Z. Smith shows how convert apologetic agendas can dictate the course of comparative religious studies. As his example, Smith reviews four centuries of scholarship comparing early Christianities with religions of late Antiquity (especially the so-called mystery cults) and shows how this scholarship has been based upon an underlying Protestant-Catholic polemic. The result is a devastating critique of traditional New Testament scholarship, a redescription of early Christianities as religious traditions amenable to comparison, and a milestone in Smith's controversial approach to comparative religious studies.

"An important book, and certainly one of the most significant in the career of Jonathan Z. Smith, whom one may venture to call the greatest pathologist in the history of religions. As in many precedent cases, Smith follows a standard procedure: he carefully selects his victim, and then dissects with artistic finesse and unequaled acumen. The operation is always necessary, and a deconstructor of Smith's caliber is hard to find."—Ioan P. Coulianu, Journal of Religion

About the Author

Jonathan Z. Smith is the Robert O. Anderson Distinguished Service Professor of the Humanities in the College of the University of Chicago.

---

Product Details Paperback: 160 pages Publisher: University Of Chicago Press (May 28, 1994) Language: English ISBN-10: 0226763633 ISBN-13: 978-0226763637 Product Dimensions: 8.6 x 5.6 x 0.5 inches Shipping Weight: 9.3 ounces (View shipping rates and policies) Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (2 customer reviews) Amazon.com Sales Rank: #496,374 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Front Cover | Table of Contents | First Pages | Index | Back Cover | Surprise Me!

Search Inside This Book:

---

Inside This Book (learn more)

First Sentence:
It must surely stand as one of the most touching moments of rapprochement in western history. Read the first page

Key Phrases - Statistically Improbable Phrases (SIPs): (learn more)
locative traditions, disciplina arcani, comparative enterprise, rising gods, opere operato, mystery religions, pagan mysteries

Key Phrases - Capitalized Phrases (CAPs): (learn more)
New Testament, New York, Late Antiquity, Old Testament, The Golden Bough, Late Antique, Imagining Religion, Roman Catholic, Map Is Not Territory, Near East, Joseph Priestley, Grand Rapids, Modern Churchman, Catholic Biblical Quarterly, History of Unitarianism, Isaac Casaubon, Magdeburg Centuries, Comparison of the Institutions of Moses, Day of Blood, Garden City, Harvard Theological Review, Myth of Innocence, New Haven, Pagan Christs, The Expositor

New!
Books on Related Topics | Concordance | Text Stats

Browse Sample Pages:
Front Cover | Table of Contents | First Pages | Index | Back Cover | Surprise Me!

Search Inside This Book:

---

Citations (learn more)

This book cites 81 books:

• St. Paul (Harper torchbooks. The Cloister library) by Arthur Darby Nock on 6 pages
• A MYTH OF INNOCENCE (Foundations & Facets Series) by BURTON MACK in Front Matter, page 39, and page 134
• Thomas Jefferson by Chinard on page 20, and page 26
• Pagan Christs by J.M. Robertson on page 88, and page 103
• Greek Myths and Christian Mystery by Hugo Rahner on page 79, and page 114

See all 81 books this book cites

 

100 books cite this book:

• A Magic Still Dwells: Comparative Religion in the Postmodern Age by Kimberley C. Patton on 11 pages
• The Rise and Fall of the Afterlife: The 1995 Read-Tuckwell Lectures at the University of Bristol by Jan N. Bremmer on 6 pages
• Liturgy Wars: Ritual Theory and Protestant Reform in Nineteenth-Century Zurich (Outstanding Dissertations on Religion in History, Society and Culture I: the Americas and the Carribean, 4) by Theodore M. Vial on 5 pages
• Beck on Mithraism: Collected Works With New Essays (Ashgate Contemporary Thinkers on Religion: Collected Works) (Ashgate Contemporary Thinkers on Religion: Collected Works) by Roger Beck on 5 pages
• Plagues, Priests, and Demons: Sacred Narratives and the Rise of Christianity in the Old World and the New by Daniel T. Reff on 4 pages

See all 100 books citing this book

---

Books on Related Topics (learn more)

The Study of Liturgy by Cheslyn Jones

Discusses:

• disciplina arcani
• opere operato
• pagan mysteries

A Magic Still Dwells by Kimberley C. Patton

Discusses:

• comparative enterprise
• Late Antiquity
• Imagining Religion

Map is not Territory by Jonathan Z. Smith

Discusses:

• locative traditions
• comparative enterprise
• Late Antique

The Study of Liturgy by Cheslyn Jones Discusses: disciplina arcani opere operato pagan mysteries A Magic Still Dwells by Kimberley C. Patton Discusses: comparative enterprise Late Antiquity Imagining Religion Map is not Territory by Jonathan Z. Smith Discusses: locative traditions comparative enterprise Late Antique Loading...

---

What Do Customers Ultimately Buy After Viewing This Item?

	73% buy the item featured on this page: Drudgery Divine: On the Comparison of Early Christianities and the Religions of Late Antiquity 5.0 out of 5 stars (2) $17.10
	8% buy Relating Religion: Essays in the Study of Religion 5.0 out of 5 stars (1) $24.75
	8% buy To Take Place: Toward Theory in Ritual (Chicago Studies in the History of Judaism) $25.00
	6% buy Imagining Religion: From Babylon to Jonestown (Chicago Studies in the History of Judaism) 5.0 out of 5 stars (1) $21.60

Explore similar items

---

Suggested Tags from Similar Products  (What's this?) Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product). Check a corresponding box or enter your own tags in the field below. religion(5) early christianity(3) robert louis wilken(3) theory of religion(2) rome(2) rare books(2) christian history(2) peter brown(2) philosophy(2) christianity(1) god(1) Your tags: Add your first tag

Search Products Tagged with   See most popular tags

Help others find this product — tag it for Amazon search

No one has tagged this product for Amazon search yet. Why not be the first to suggest a search for which it should appear?

---

Sell a Digital Version of This Book in the Kindle Store

If you are a publisher or author and hold the digital rights to a book, you can sell a digital version of it in our Kindle Store. Learn more

---

 

Customer Reviews

2 Reviews 5 star:  (2) 4 star:    (0) 3 star:    (0) 2 star:    (0) 1 star:    (0)           Average Customer Review 5.0 out of 5 stars (2 customer reviews)		Share your thoughts with other customers:
Most Helpful Customer Reviews 29 of 32 people found the following review helpful: 5.0 out of 5 stars Expose of early Christian v. Pagan as Protestant v. Catholic, June 5, 2004 By  Michael Hoffman (Egodeath.com) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)    In the book Drudgery Divine, J. Z. Smith portrays Christianity and mystery religions in their late-antique phase as similar simultaneous parallel developments. He emphasizes diversity in all the religions, against the monolithic assumption that underlies the usual project of comparing "the" Jewish religion, "the" Christian religion, and "the" Pagan type of religion. Drudgery Divine is an expose of the biased and flawed nature of the Protestant, anti-Catholic project of portraying early Christianity as completely non-Catholic, non-ritualist, and non-initiatory. This Protestant scholarly project was based on illegitimate approaches to comparison of early, pre-Catholic Christianity to the pagan/Hellenistic religions. The Protestant project sought to portray Christianity as far from ritual and initiation and mystery-religion as possible, and implicitly equated Catholic practices with Hellenistic ritual, initiation, and mystery, arguing that because pure, original Christianity was not at all like Hellenistic religion, original Christianity was not at all like Catholic Christianity. According to the Protestant scholars, original Christianity was completely unlike Catholic Christianity, being strictly a matter of revealed, not secret religion; being strictly a matter of straightforward rational ethics, not initiation and ritual; being strictly a matter of sermon study-lectures, not magic-like ritual practices; being strictly a matter of doctrinal principles of pure faith, not ritual activity. Insofar as the older Jewish religion could be portrayed as unlike Hellenistic secret ritual initiation, the Protestant scholars emphasized that real, original Christianity derived purely and strictly from the Jewish religion, as opposed to having anything to do with pagan/Hellenistic (read 'Catholic') secret ritual initiation. According to those Protestant scholars, the word 'mysterion' in Jewish writings has only one meaning to consider, and this meaning is purely secular, and simply connotes 'secret', and does not connote secret ritual initiation -- therefore, the use of the word 'mysterion' in original (which is to say, non-Catholic) Christianity had nothing to do with Hellenistic-type (read 'Catholic-type') secret ritual initiation. Smith's book does not serve the purpose of putting forth an elaborated correct positive model of the nature of earliest Christianities. Its focused purpose is to sweep away the bunk, biased, covert project driven by anti-Catholic concerns, to enable the next generation of scholars to completely re-approach the question of the relationship of early Christianity to Hellenistic religion, including an adequate treatment of multiplicity within Christianity and within the other religions, and development over time. He points out that some kinds of Christianity were similar to some kinds of Hellenistic religion. One of many tenets of the Protestant project of comparing original Christianity/Jewish religion against Hellenistic/Catholic religion, Smith briefly points out, is the idea that the Jewish religion was completely unlike secret ritual initiation. 2 of 27 people found the following review helpful: 5.0 out of 5 stars Impressive service, August 30, 2006 By  Sandra F. Swift "sidury" (Norfolk, VA USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)    The delivery of "Drudgery Divine" was quick, and the packaging was secure. I will definitely recommend this dealer.		Ad feedback   Search Customer Reviews Only search this product's reviews

---

Customer Discussions

 Beta (What's this?)

New! See all customer communities, and bookmark your communities to keep track of them.

This product's forum (0 discussions)   Discussion Replies Latest Post   No discussions yet Ask questions, Share opinions, Gain insight Start a new discussion Topic: First post: Receive e-mail when new posts are made Prompts for sign-in   [Cancel] Guidelines Active discussions in related forums   Discussion Replies Latest Post religion What religious freedoms will be taken away if gay marriage is allowed? 1449 13 seconds ago religion Hey, Theists, why do you find the notion(s) of "evidence" and of "proof" so troubling? 1808 1 minute ago religion Can consciousness and mind be wholly accounted for within the materialist paradigm? 597 2 minutes ago religion You are born. Then one day you die. If one does not believe in the afterlife, what is the purpose of life? 40 2 minutes ago religion Explain Hell to me 323 4 minutes ago textbook Textbooks for Kindle DX? 40 1 day ago textbook Does anyone use Discovering Geometry: An Investigative Approach? 5 1 day ago

The Religion community Latest activity 20 minutes ago 13,081 customers have contributed 14,278 products, 1,023 discussions and more... › Explore the community The Rome community Latest activity 5 minutes ago 1,831 customers have contributed 4,555 products, 141 lists & guides and more... › Explore the community Related forums religion (1023 discussions) religious... (9 discussions) rome (7 discussions) textbook (16 discussions) Explore more › See all Customer Communities › Your communities

---

Product Information from the Amapedia Community

Beta (What's this?)

Be the first person to add an article about this item at Amapedia.com.

› See featured Amapedia.com articles

---

Listmania!

Trans-Academics.org Recommended Reading list: A list by Genderwarrior   New Testament Studies Must Have: A list by Gerardo Rodriguez "lokko53"   Tools for Studying the Historical Jesus: A list by "andrew_eccentric" Create a Listmania! list

Search Listmania!

---

So You'd Like to...

understand atheism and atheists: A guide by Dianna Narciso "Author, Like Rolling Uphill: Realizing the Honesty of Atheism"   Connect Gnosticism with Alexandrian Judaism?: A guide by Didaskalex "Eusebius Alexandrinus"   Relate Messianic & Rabbinic Judaism: A guide by Didaskalex "Eusebius Alexandrinus" Create a guide

Search Guides

---

Look for Similar Items by Category

• Books > New & Used Textbooks > Humanities > Religious Studies > Comparative Religion
• Books > Religion & Spirituality > Religious Studies > Comparative Religion

---

Up to 30% Off Lansinoh This July, enjoy savings of up to 30% on select Lansinoh products offered by Amazon.com. Lansinoh is dedicated to providing breastfeeding solutions. ›Learn more

Best Books of 2008 Find our top 100 editors' picks as well as customers' favorites in dozens of categories in our Best Books of 2008 Store.

Summer Reading for Kids & Teens Discover everything from beach reads and board books to teen romance and action-adventure series in Summer Reading for Kids & Teens. And, check off the kids' required reading lists in our Summer School Reading Store.

Introducing Subscribe & Save Get automatic reorders plus extra savings on items you use frequently, including coffee, shampoo, and laundry detergent, with our new Subscribe & Save program. ›More about Subscribe & Save

Ad feedback

 

Feedback If you need help or have a question for Customer Service, contact us.  Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images? Is there any other feedback you would like to provide? Your comments can help make our site better for everyone. Please note that we are unable to respond directly to all feedback submitted via this form, but we'll ask you to sign in so we can contact you if needed.

Where's My Stuff? Track your recent orders. View or change your orders in Your Account. Shipping & Returns See our shipping rates & policies. See FREE shipping information. Return an item (here's our Returns Policy). Need Help? Forgot your password? Buy gift cards. Visit our Help department.

Your Recent History

  (What's this?)

You have no recently viewed items or searches. After viewing product detail pages or search results, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. Look to the right column to find helpful suggestions for your shopping session.	Continue shopping: Top Sellers Free by Chris Anderson 3.6 out of 5 stars (14)$0.00 Paranoia by Joseph Finder 4.1 out of 5 stars (201)$0.00 My Soul to Lose by Rachel Vincent 4.2 out of 5 stars (4)$0.00 Glenn Beck's Common Sense by Glenn Beck 3.8 out of 5 stars (283)$6.59

Amazon.com Home  |   Directory of All Stores

International Sites:  Canada  |  United Kingdom  |  Germany  |  Japan  |  France  |  China

Business Programs: Sell on Amazon  |  Build an eCommerce Site  |  Advertise With Us  |  Developer Services  |  Self-Publish with Us

Help  |  View Cart  |  Your Account  |  1-Click Settings  |  Join Associates  |  Join Advantage

Careers at Amazon  |  Investor Relations  |  Press Releases  |  Corporate Responsibility

Conditions of Use | Privacy Notice © 1996-2009, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates

Product Details

• Paperback: 160 pages
• Publisher: University Of Chicago Press (May 28, 1994)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0226763633
• ISBN-13: 978-0226763637
• Product Dimensions: 8.6 x 5.6 x 0.5 inches
• Shipping Weight: 9.3 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (2 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #496,374 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

29 of 32 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Expose of early Christian v. Pagan as Protestant v. Catholic, June 5, 2004

By	Michael Hoffman (Egodeath.com) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

In the book Drudgery Divine, J. Z. Smith portrays Christianity and mystery religions in their late-antique phase as similar simultaneous parallel developments. He emphasizes diversity in all the religions, against the monolithic assumption that underlies the usual project of comparing "the" Jewish religion, "the" Christian religion, and "the" Pagan type of religion.

Drudgery Divine is an expose of the biased and flawed nature of the Protestant, anti-Catholic project of portraying early Christianity as completely non-Catholic, non-ritualist, and non-initiatory. This Protestant scholarly project was based on illegitimate approaches to comparison of early, pre-Catholic Christianity to the pagan/Hellenistic religions.

The Protestant project sought to portray Christianity as far from ritual and initiation and mystery-religion as possible, and implicitly equated Catholic practices with Hellenistic ritual, initiation, and mystery, arguing that because pure, original Christianity was not at all like Hellenistic religion, original Christianity was not at all like Catholic Christianity.

According to the Protestant scholars, original Christianity was completely unlike Catholic Christianity, being strictly a matter of revealed, not secret religion; being strictly a matter of straightforward rational ethics, not initiation and ritual; being strictly a matter of sermon study-lectures, not magic-like ritual practices; being strictly a matter of doctrinal principles of pure faith, not ritual activity.

Insofar as the older Jewish religion could be portrayed as unlike Hellenistic secret ritual initiation, the Protestant scholars emphasized that real, original Christianity derived purely and strictly from the Jewish religion, as opposed to having anything to do with pagan/Hellenistic (read 'Catholic') secret ritual initiation.

According to those Protestant scholars, the word 'mysterion' in Jewish writings has only one meaning to consider, and this meaning is purely secular, and simply connotes 'secret', and does not connote secret ritual initiation -- therefore, the use of the word 'mysterion' in original (which is to say, non-Catholic) Christianity had nothing to do with Hellenistic-type (read 'Catholic-type') secret ritual initiation.

Smith's book does not serve the purpose of putting forth an elaborated correct positive model of the nature of earliest Christianities. Its focused purpose is to sweep away the bunk, biased, covert project driven by anti-Catholic concerns, to enable the next generation of scholars to completely re-approach the question of the relationship of early Christianity to Hellenistic religion, including an adequate treatment of multiplicity within Christianity and within the other religions, and development over time.

He points out that some kinds of Christianity were similar to some kinds of Hellenistic religion.

One of many tenets of the Protestant project of comparing original Christianity/Jewish religion against Hellenistic/Catholic religion, Smith briefly points out, is the idea that the Jewish religion was completely unlike secret ritual initiation.

2 of 27 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Impressive service, August 30, 2006

By	Sandra F. Swift "sidury" (Norfolk, VA USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

The delivery of "Drudgery Divine" was quick, and the packaging was secure. I will definitely recommend this dealer.