From School Library Journal
Grade 8 Up-The editors' intention in this necessarily limited collection of quotations is to put the excerpts into the context of the original lines in the plays or sonnets from which they have been taken. The book is organized by topics ("Age," "Duplicity," "Fish"), followed by passages of about five or six lines. After each selection, the citation, the character, and usually the context of the lines are given. If a reference is obscure, the explanation is more elaborate. Indexes provide access by play and poem, by character, and by keyword. While the explanations of context are useful, this is a secondary reference tool. Some of the best known quotations are hard to find. "Double, double, toil and trouble..." is found in the keyword index only under "Double," which most people routinely mix up with "bubble"; it is listed in the topic index under "Occult" rather than the more ordinary "magic" or "spells." The topics are cross-referenced, but the use of both "Avarice" and "Greed" to split up a total of three quotes seems awkward and unnecessary. This is unlikely to be the first choice of novice scholars.
Sally Margolis, Barton Public Library, VTCopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Reginald Foakes, a noted Shakespearean critic, and Mary Foakes, once a librarian at the Shakespeare Center at Stratford-upon-Avon, combine their talents to produce a well-organized, well-indexed, and instructive resource. Arranged topically, it presents quotations on 600 subjects ranging from absence to youth. Each quotation includes the title of the play, character speaking, act, scene, line number (keyed to the Riverside Shakespeare), and notes that place the quotation in context. Students and casual users will love the contextual information, and reference librarians will welcome a resource that provides the answer when patrons ask, "Who said this?" Because notable collections such as the Folger Book of Shakespeare Quotations and the Longman Guide to Shakespeare Quotations are out of print, this work and Hugh Rawson's A Dictionary of Quotations from Shakespeare (Meridian, 1996) are the two best sources available for Shakespeare quotations. Smaller libraries already owning the less expensive Rawson text will not need to add this title, but it is highly recommended for all academic and large public libraries regardless of their current holdings.?Neal Wyatt, Chesterfield Cty. P.L., Richmond, VA
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
See all Editorial Reviews