Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
19 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beyond a Beautiful Mind, January 17, 2002
Strange Brains and Genius is by far the best book I have read that catalogues numerous examples of the fine line between genius and frailty in a wide range of colorful and influential people. Nikola Tesla had a horror of women's pearl earrings. Oliver Heaviside, the father of modern electric-circuit design, painted his nails cherry pink. Renowned scholar Samuel Johnson had so many tics and quirks that some mistook him for an idiot. Jeremy Bentham, the British philosopher who promoted the idea, "the greatest good for the greatest number of people", fell in love with rats. He also advised rich people to plant embalmed corpses of their ancestors upright along highways. There apparently is a link between extreme genius and madness in certain individuals. Pickover also goes further and discusses the role of the brain in religious and alien abduction experiences. Pickover points out that in repressive times, strange geniuses have been persecuted, but in more enlightened eras these nonconformists have had the freedom to make great contributions to science and society. Are their minds like our own, or are they so different that these geniuses should be viewed as entirely different beings? What do geniuses have in common, and how can we foster their continued emergence? Is their a link between their obsessions and their creativity? This book is organized into three parts. In Part I, Pickover discusses several geniuses with obsessive-compulsive (and Asperger's) tendencies. Many of the individuals might have Asperger's syndrome (characterized by an impairment in social interaction and development of restricted and repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, and activities). Part II is smorgasbord of short subjects ranging from IQ to the influence of the brain's structure on behavior. Part III discusses how individuals were selected for this book and describes the effect of other disorders such as bipolar disorder and temporal-lobe epilepsy on creativity, religion, and even the alien abduction experience. Buy this amazing book and go beyond "A Beautiful Mind"
|
|
|
12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Probably Pickover's Worst Book, June 9, 2001
This is a survey book of Eccentricity and Genius. The first 180 pages are organized into sections on Biographical Fact (Fact Files), Technical Contribution (Straight Dope), and Litany of Eccentricities (Strange Brain) for the following individuals: Nikola Tesla, Oliver Heaviside, Samuel Johnson, Richard Kirwan, Jeremy Bentham, Henry Cavendish, Francis Galton, Geoffrey Pyke, and (?!) Unabomber Theodore Kaczynski.Pickover's premise is that the personal 'strangeness' of these individuals significantly contributed to their brilliance and accomplishments. If they had been 'less strange' they would have accomplished less. He also provides 20 pages of mini-biographies of people who missed the first cut, including: Paul Erdos, Richard Feynman, Charles Darwin, Howard Hughes, Edward Leedskalnin, and others. The shallower parts of this survey include rehashes on topics like Einstein's Brain, the 10% Brain Use Myth, and IQ. He meditates pointlessly on Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (in all of it's varieties), Trichotilliomania, Temporal Lobe Epilepsy, and other aspects of Genius and Strangeness (including Autism, Homosexuality, and Schizophrenia). There are also 2 other very weird parts of the book. The first is a 'Human Mind Questionnaire' which spends 25 pages reporting on an anonymous (and unscientific) survey which he conducted on the internet. In another part of the book, he spends a dozen pages on extracts from 'Science' and 'Science News' from 1995/1996 to show that neuroscience and psychological issues are topical. The book has some lackluster footnotes, a skimpy biblography, and a Table of Contents. Pickover has written some wonderful, insightful, original books and technical articles over the years. It's hard for me to believe that the same guy wrote this book. Perhaps he didn't ... it seems more like the work of a summer intern or inexperienced research assistant. If this book was 150 pages shorter and better edited, it could have been extraordinary.
|
|
|
19 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Sloppy Writing and Scholarship: An Insult to Great Figures, November 20, 2003
It is hard to imagine that a book with such promising and interesting subject matter could be executed in a poorer fashion. Pickover repeatedly blows his credibility with unsubstantiated speculations and personal comments. He writes the book in a first person sense with frequent interjections of "I think..." and "What interests me...". Within the first few pages, not only are his research methods and facts called into question, but one starts to wonder if even his personal credentials are legitimate.The content of the book, kindly refered to in the editorial review as "eclectic", is a scattershot collection of Pickover's ramblings as muddled as the books front cover. Apparently, the title "Strange Brains and Genius: The Secret Lives of Eccentric Scientists and Madmen" was neither vague nor general enough for Pickover who, midway through the book, drifts off into such varied subjects as cryonics and UFO abduction. The unforgivable disgrace of this book comes from Pickover's reduction of intellectual giants to "Strange Brains" as he revels in the dirty little details of great scientist's lives. Frequently the narrative takes the tone of mocking these men and women of history for their personal habits. Pickover writes in the schoolyard manner (and quality) of singling people out because of their differences and ridiculing them. This vice is then combined with a tabloid sense of sensationalism and sold behind a glossy cover. If, after reading these reviews, you are still set on buying this book - more power to you. If you are interested in a more scholarly and objective examination of creativity and genius, however, consider "Creating Minds" by Howard Gardner
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|