The Iraq Study Group Report: The Way Forward - A New Approach (Paperback)

~ The Iraq Study Group (Author), James A. Baker III (Author), Lee H. Hamilton (Author)

Editorial Reviews

From Booklist

*Starred Review* Recent residence on Mars would be the only excuse for someone being unaware of this document, delivered by the Iraq Study Group to the Bush administration and simultaneously and inexpensively published for the general public. And there is no excuse for any public library, large or small, not to own a copy. Whether or not the report's recommendations will be adopted by President Bush in whole or in part is a question to be answered in upcoming months. As it stands at this moment, the report is the orphan of all documents, unembraced by beltway Republicans and Democrats alike. Nevertheless, every citizen should read it. It is a gloomy experience to enter its pages, to be sure; the opening line is now famous: "The situation in Iraq is grave and deteriorating." But it is also a surprisingly crisply and clearly written report, an incredibly cogent look at where we are in Iraq and how we should proceed. The text is divided into two primary sections: "Assessment" and "A New Approach," with the second section including 79 precise recommendations to the administration for "moving forward." Agree with the points made or not, no reader can come away from this trenchant account without a more enhanced opinion. Brad Hooper
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

Review

More e-Books from MobileReference - Best Books. Best Price. Best Search and Navigation (TM)

All fiction books are only $0.99. All collections are only $5.99
Designed for optimal navigation on Kindle and other electronic devices

Search for any title: enter mobi (shortened MobileReference) and a keyword; for example: mobi Shakespeare
To view all books, click on the MobileReference link next to a book title

Literary Classics: Over 10,000 complete works by Shakespeare, Jane Austen, Mark Twain, Conan Doyle, Jules Verne, Dickens, Tolstoy, and other authors. All books feature hyperlinked table of contents, footnotes, and author biography. Books are also available as collections, organized by an author. Collections simplify book access through categorical, alphabetical, and chronological indexes. They offer lower price, convenience of one-time download, and reduce clutter of titles in your digital library.

Religion: The Illustrated King James Bible, American Standard Bible, World English Bible (Modern Translation), Mormon Church's Sacred Texts

Philosophy: Rousseau, Spinoza, Plato, Aristotle, Marx, Engels

Travel Guides and Phrasebooks for All Major Cities: New York, Paris, London, Rome, Venice, Prague, Beijing, Greece

Medical Study Guides: Anatomy and Physiology, Pharmacology, Abbreviations and Terminology, Human Nervous System, Biochemistry

College Study Guides: FREE Weight and Measures, Physics, Math, Chemistry, Organic Chemistry, Statistics, Languages, Philosophy, Psychology, Mythology

History: Art History, American Presidents, U.S. History, Encyclopedias of Roman Empire, Ancient Egypt

Health: Acupressure Guide, First Aid Guide, Art of Love, Cookbook, Cocktails, Astrology

Reference: The World's Biggest Mobile Encyclopedia; CIA World Factbook, Illustrated Encyclopedias of Birds

--This text refers to the Kindle Edition edition.

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Paperback: 160 pages
• Publisher: Vintage; 1st Authorized Ed edition (December 6, 2006)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0307386562
• ISBN-13: 978-0307386564
• Product Dimensions: 7.8 x 5.2 x 0.6 inches
• Shipping Weight: 6.4 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 3.6 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (65 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #487,221 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

31 of 33 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars You Break it, You Bought it, January 4, 2008

By	!Edwin C. Pauzer (New York City) - See all my reviews (TOP 1000 REVIEWER)

This review is from: The Iraq Study Group Report: The Way Forward -- A New Approach (Paperback)

With an economy of words, the book begins: "There is no guarantee for success in Iraq. The situation in Baghdad and several provinces is dire.... There is great suffering and the daily lives of Iraqis show little or no improvement." It then details the problems with security, politics, economics, and international support that transcend a purely military solution to Iraq.

The problems of security begin with the factions of Shiite leaders who do not want to surrender their new-found power and disarm their militias. The Sunni Arabs, long the rulers of Iraq are not ready to abandon their insurgency, al-Qaeda must be progressively pursued and destroyed, and the Kurds are not willing to give up their autonomy.

The politics is equally bleak. The Iraqi government is unable to provide essential services. There is no security for key infrastructure. Corruption is rampant and capacity is inadequate. Their elected representatives "treat ministries as political spoils." The judiciary is also weak and intimidation against them has been ruthless.

With inflation at more than fifty percent and unemployment running from 20-60 percent, Iraq is not ripe for international investment. Oil production has fallen because of a lack of security, investment, and technical expertise. With corruption and negligible security accounting for as much as 500,000 barrels of oil a day being stolen, international support and investment are not likely to occur in the near future.

The Study Group adds seventy-nine recommendations for change in Iraq. First and foremost, it would be wrong for US forces to leave, which has consequences if we do stay, and consequences if we don't. It's the classic lose-lose situation. Unfortunately, the study does not go into any depth how these recommendations are to be accomplished.

Initially, I was skeptical of a board that was co-chaired by James A. Baker III, the virtual Bush family lawyer who argued before the Supreme Court that the all the votes had been recounted when they hadn't been. Seeing the name of Edwin Meese didn't allay my suspicions that this study group might end up throwing soft balls George Bush's way, or would not hold him accountable. On the contrary, they have made it clear that this administration made many mistakes and severely underestimated the situation after it declared that "major combat operations in Iraq have ended."

The study group makes it abundantly clear that Iraq is a complex problem that goes far beyond simple-minded phrases of "stay the course," or "we will not leave until victory is achieved."

For anyone wishing to get a thorough and concise description of the complex problems we face in Iraq, this is an excellent compendium.

It's not surprising that George W. Bush rejected the report.


ECP
01.04.08: 1,710 days since major combat operations in Iraq have ended.




P.S. Also recommended:

"The Battle for Peace" by General Anthony Zinni
"Fiasco: The American Military Adventure in Iraq" by Thomas E. Ricks

12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars A must read for anyone interested in contemporary affairs, January 31, 2007

By	bryan12603 (Poughkeepsie, NY USA) - See all my reviews

This is a review of The Iraq Study Group Report by James A. Baker, Lee H. Hamilton, et al.

If you have any interest in having an informed opinion about the war in Iraq -- regardless of your political orientation or current level of knowledge -- I highly recommend this book. This book is still worth reading despite the fact that the President has chosen not to implement its primary recommendations.

First, this book is an easy read. It's 142 pages long, but the real content of the report is the "Executive Summary" on pp. xiii-xviii (read this if you read nothing else and you'll get the gist) and the main body of the report on pp. 1-96. The rest of the book is a series of Appendices, which include some helpful maps, but also some less crucial information like biographies of the Study Group members.

Second, whatever your political orientation, this book gives you a quick, readable overview of what problems face us (and the Iraqis).

Third, the President's proposal to inject signifiantly more combat troops was considered and rejected by the Study Group. Even if you disagree, it is worth knowing why they considered this a losing strategy.

The Report gives a series of recommendations aimed at achieving a stable, democratic Iraq that no longer needs the support of the US military. After reading the Report, I am personally not optimistic that this can actually be achieved. (Most of the criticisms of the report focus on the likelihood that its recommendations would succeed.) However, I suspect that the Study Group felt it was not politically viable to simply declare that Iraq cannot be saved. Consequently, they had to suggest some actionable policy besides immediate withdrawal. But the Report makes clear that the US must gradually withdraw from Iraq, and what continued US support there is must be contigent on the Iraqis taking substantive steps toward resolving their own problems. If the President had followed these recommendations, we would have been out of Iraq within a couple of years at most -- one way or the other.

Again, one may not agree, but the Report gives many interesting and pertinent facts. Shia, Sunni and Kurds do not trust one another, and divide the military and police forces along sectarian lines. Because of the lack of reliable central political authority, "Sunni insurgents will not lay down arms unless the Shia militias are disarmed. Shia militias will not disarm until the Sunni insurgency is destroyed" (20). Furthermore, 61% of Iraqis APPROVE of attacks on US forces (35).

The Study Group argues that increasing the US military presence (as suggested by the President) will not help the current situation because of three facts. (1) More troops would strengthen the impression that the US plans a long-term "occupation" of Iraq. (This impression will, in turn, increase anti-US sentiment and violence.) (2) Maintaining forces in Iraq will decrease US readiness to deal with problems in other parts of the world, including Afghanistan, Iran and North Korea. (I would add myself that a crisis could erupt between Taiwan and China within the next few years.) (3) As long as the US is propping up the Iraq government, it has no incentive to undertake the fundamental reforms that are necessary to achieve peace and stability.

To put it really simply, if we put a US soldier beside every man, woman and child in Iraq, it would (probably) stop the violence for as long as we could maintain it. However, the second we turn away, the violence will start up again, unless and until the Iraqis decide that they want to end the violence themselves. We cannot make them do that, and they have no incentive to do it as long as we are propping their government up.

Even if you are sure the President is right, this book is a must-read for anyone who wants to be well informed.

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars An easy and very worthwhile read., January 11, 2007

By	J. P. Barnes Jr. (Houston Texas) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

The book arrived in excellent condition and in short order. It was fascinating to see the degree to which the media distorted the study group report by selection. eg. Did you ever hear that the committee recommended a surge of 20,000 troops as part of its report? Neither did I, but its right there in the executive summary and in the internal options section of the report. And there are 77 other recommendations, not just the three or four that the media keeps talking about.