From Publishers Weekly
Reading this curious and frustrating book is like playing a game of Trivial Pursuit based on the history of fashion. There are lots of anecdotes, well told, many familiar, about the five disparate women spotlighted here: Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis, Marlene Dietrich, the Duchess of Windsor, Elinor Glyn and Eugenie Bonaparte. We learn that Eugenie's famous Parisian designer, Worth, was originally from a British village and was the first male to design clothes for women. Elinor Glyn was famous for her draped tiger skins and "it," whatever "it" was. (Douglas Fairbanks Jr., she opined, didn't have "it" because his ears stuck out too much.) There's little new about Wallis Simpson, and Jacqueline Kennedy is portrayed as a fanatic, extravagant shopper who wore 400 outfits in 16 months in the White House. The telling of tales is competent, but Fowler (In a Gilded Cage) tries to force the book to carry a sociological weight far beyond its strength. A heavy-handed introduction that quotes, among others, Thomas Carlyle and Thorstein Veblen, is followed by an absurd afterword in which Fowler insists: "There's another lesson here, and it's a moral one. Outer beauty can produce inner." Illustrations.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Combining biography with social commentary, Fowler (In a Gilded Cage, St. Martin's, 1994) provides an intelligent analysis of the style and influence of five very different women who turn out to have had more in common than one would have expected. She gives a fascinating chronological look at the lives and fashions of Empress Eugenie of France, Elinor Glyn, Marlene Dietrich, the Duchess of Windsor, and Jacqueline Onassis. Though readers will probably pick the book up for the chapter on Onassis (which unfortunately makes no mention of the Sotheby's auction of her property), the chapters on the other women are also well worth reading. One learns, for example, that the Duchess of Windsor's formidable mother, on her deathbed, asked her daughter if she was wearing a brown dress. Wallis replied that she was. " 'Thought so,' sniffed her mother in the same exasperated tone that had greeted Wallis's childhood misdemeanors and preceded the hairbrush's whack. 'Whatever made you choose such an unbecoming color?'" Fowler's work is full of revealing moments like this and will be enjoyed by anyone with an interest in fashion or in the lives of these five fashionable women. Recommended for public libraries.?Elizabeth Mellett, Brookline P.L., Mass.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.