|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
BRILLIANT, BUT TOO PRO-DE KLERK AND ANTI-MANDELA., September 3, 1999
By A Customer
This is an interesting, and most impressive, autobiography. Its weakness is that it is so anti-Mandela and pro-De Klerk. Mandala's role in the making of the new South Africa is marginalized and De Klerk's role is accentuated.De Klerk makes clear that South Africa "avoided [a] racial cataclysm" by means of a great compromise: (a) whites kept economic power and got a court system to protect their rights and (b) blacks, or the ANC in alliance with Inkata, got political power. All segments of South African society, Indian, colored, blacks, and whites, are now, in 1999, however, according to De Klerk, disillusioned with the new dispensation of power. Indians and coloreds had more power under the ancien regime, blacks expected but did not get an improvement in their conditions, and whites have not been able to adjust to their "disempowerment." On the other hand, at least white rule, and the injustice and discrimination inherent in the ancien regime, passed into history. De Klerk shows how South Africa became a multi-racial democracy and believes that he, and not Mandela, was the primary actor in this turn of events. However, he refuses to take responsibility for the arrest, torture, or murder of more than 20,000 black South Africans. He claims that he cannot be guilty for covert actions "of which we [in the cabinet] were not informed." De Klerk and Mandala are like Gorbachev and Yeltsin. The new Russia is unthinkable without either. However, as De Klerk's book shows, neither he nor Mandala controlled events. The "river of history was in full flood. It was sweeping us all along in its course." What De Klerk and Mandala did, for their respective racial groups, was to reach a great compromise. De Klerk's book is brilliant in its elucidation, often in details, of the making of that compromise. We even learn that the De Klerk family concealed their biracial, that is, their white and Indian, genealogy. Mandela was going to win. But F. W. De Klerk's autobiography is a winner in twentieth century autobiography.
|