|
|
31 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Run of the mill., April 27, 2002
George Harrison (1943-2001) was my favorite Beatle, and because he spent much of his life "trying to hide from us" (p. xi), few would disagree that he was also the most elusive Beatle. In the first biography published after Harrison's November 29, 2001 death, Marc Shapiro attempts to "discover the real George Harrison in all his varying shades of light and dark" (p. xi), but it don't come easy.Shapiro's 205-page biography of "The Quiet Beatle" manages to follow Harrison's life from his birth in Wavertree, England during World War Two (p. 13), to his obsession with guitars at age twelve (p. 21), to his first encounter with Paul McCartney at the Liverpool Institute, where they were both students (p. 23), to joining the Quarrymen with Paul and John Lennon in 1958 (p. 28), to playing music to Hamburg audiences of "drunken sailors, street thugs, prostitutes, and college students" in strip clubs as the Beatles (pp. 37-8), to the Beatles' first visit to America in 1964 (p. 55), to his marriage to model Pattie Boyd in 1966 (p. 72), to his first LSD experience (pp. 69-70), to his search for spiritual enlightenment in India, to the "growing personal and legal entanglements" that brought the Beatles to an end in 1970 (p. 93), to losing his wife, Pattie, to his friend, Eric Clapton (p. 111), to the Concerts for Bangladesh in 1971, to his affair with Ringo's wife, Maureen, which led to the breakup of Ringo's marriage (p. 121), to Harrison's bouts with drugs and depression (p. 136), to his marriage to his "soulmate," Olivia Arias (pp. 147; 159) and the birth of their son, Dhani in 1978, to the 1999 knife attack that punctured his lung (p. 190), and to his unsuccessful fight with cancer. Ultimately, however, Shapiro not only fails to bring his subject to life in this book, but he also fails to reveal exactly what made Harrison tick, the two requirements for a good biography. Isn't it a pity. To be fair, Shapiro's book is very readable. Although Harrison's fans will undoubtedly find this biography interesting, they won't find anything new here. My real criticism of Shapiro's biography, however, involves his inadequate research. He acknowledges that "no Beatle was . . . interviewed in the writing of this book." Nor did Shapiro interview either of Harrison's wives, his siblings, or friends in writing his book. In fact, the only person Shapiro interviewed was musician, Delaney Bramlett. "The real story," Harrison once said, "is the one that only we can tell from our point of view, and we know all the little intimate details" (pp. 179-80). Much to my disappointment, the "real story" of George Harrison isn't told here. G. Merritt
|