Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Worthy heir of the Saga-writers, December 18, 2007
When I read the description of "The Whale Road" on Amazon, I was skeptical. It seemed to me that the author was trying to bring too many elements together, and that the result was bound to be a jumble.
I could not have been more wrong. "The Whale Road" is a rare treat- a book that combines high adventure, meticulous historical research and the excitement of ancient mysteries. The premise, of a band of oath-sworn comrades (in Old Norse, a "felag") seeking an ancient treasures based on clues that they have to traverse the known world to find, is believable and innovative. The characters are well-developed, from the narrator's companions to the historical and fictional figures they come across in their quest. Those who are familiar with the tale of Sigurd from the Volsunga Saga (VOLSUNGA SAGA - The Story of the Volsungs and Niblungs) and other works of Old Norse literature (e.g., The Sagas of Icelanders: Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition (World of the Sagas) will delight in Low's inventive and fresh look at the legends and tales of this fascinating culture.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Epic Beginning, January 6, 2008
"The Whale Road" by Robert Low is a very ambitious novel. Try to picture an Indiana Jones type adventure 1100 years ago. Our story is centered around a young man, 15 years of age, Orm Ruriksson, aka The Bear Slyaer, who is plucked out from his home in Norway, and placed on the Fjord Elk. He is sworn into a group called the "oathsworn" These are the toughest, and well known, Vikings, who sell their services to the highest bidder, seeking out treasures along "The Whale Road." When the group comes to knowledge of Attila the Huns ancient and secret treasure, the race is on to whom can find it first.
Robert Low does an excellent job of truly making this an historical fiction novel by weaving in what the times were like. The ever changing lords, tribes, groups, and what it meant to take an "oath." Through the eyes of Orm, we travel from Norway, through England and through the Middle East and Russia, and finally ending in "The Great City."
This story is jammed packed with believable places, people, and scenarios. We feel what it was like to live on a ship day in and day out, and what true fear is on the battle field, and just why men do rush in when in war. From battles ranging from sea, land and sieges, you won't be disappointed in this saga.
My only gripe, if we shall call it even that, was I felt that Mr. Low was trying to convey too much history at one time. While it was rare for any many or woman of the time to read or write, our Orm can read in a multitude of languages, is uncanny with history and people, and has a real knack for trading and value. However, even if this does feel overly done, it gives the reader a real insight to what life was like 1100 years ago, when the old ways were dying, and making way for the new, the "White Christ."
Readers of historical fiction, fiction, thrillers, and books from authors such as Bernard Cornwell, will not be disappointed in this. "The Whale Road" is a sure hit.
|
|
|
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Bad choice, February 28, 2008
I can't be sure of why exactly, but after having read dozens of books by Bernard Cornwell, Steven Pressfield, David Ball, and others (as I am a huge fan of historical fiction), this book is the last thing I'd like to read. Cornwell brings history to life, this books put me to sleep. It seems that at times reading Cornwell or Pressfield will teach you more about the historical period they're writing about than taking a history class, this book on the other hand, will confuse, annoy, and make you wonder why so many words are used and yet in the end little to nothing is said. The characters have little emotion behind them. If they curse every now and then, it seems as if it's an after thought, as if this is something that's needed right now, rather than a part of their character and personality. The story moves along horribly slow yet within the first twenty pages you'll meet about a dozen characters none of whom are memorable in the least. The beginning of the story carries little weight in terms of interest and is so convoluted with names and events that you won't know up from down. I'm also sure that, at times, this book will seem like a language or history lesson, one that you don't want, more than a form of entertainment to take you away from your world and into that of the author's. I'd say give this one a pass.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|