Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
77 of 80 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Doctor recommended, a compelling read!, June 11, 2008
As a California physician, I have found myself diagnosing Lyme disease in an increasing number of patients who come to me with vague, multi-system complaints, but certain consistent patterns: living, working or playing in outdoor brush or field areas (gardening, golf, hiking, camping)is the first, but many have only a little outdoor exposure. Second, complaints of the slow onset of stiff, aching joints that get better and worse, sore muscles, that spasm, tingle and turn numb off and on, headaches and fatigue, problems with sleep, an up and down course that slowly gets worse. Pamela Weintraub, a professional writer and editor, tells her story of her family's move to a rural New York community as healthy active people, only to have all four family members contract Lyme disease in the early 90's, and face not only the disability of this infection but also the confusing double talk of a medical community in denial. She tells not only her story but those of others, and in the telling reveals the difficulties in getting an accurate diagnosis, in finding a doctor to believe and treat the patient, and in being able emotionally and financially to continue the treatment until the disease is resolved. If you are a patient with Lyme disease, perhaps you will learn some things you didn't know before. If you are someone who has believed that perhaps Lyme disease is a myth, or that the people who have it are exaggerating, this is the book for you. If you are a physician, and have quoted the Infectious Disease Society of America's treatment guidelines to a suffering patient to explain why you will not treat them, or will only treat them for three weeks- this is the book for you. Those of us who have Lyme disease, or treat Lyme disease, know it to be as devastating and disabling as a HIV infection, and in many cases, as difficult to cure. Give this book to doctors, to journalists, to scout leaders who take kids into the woods, to your friends who go camping, gardening, horseback riding; to your friends with furry pets, or those who enjoy the deer in their yards. We have a serious growing epidemic in this country, affecting young and old. Let's wake ourselves up to proper treatment and prevention. Dr. Tedde M. Rinker, Redwood City, California
|
|
|
45 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
PHYSICIAN ADDICTED TO AMAZING STORY AND WRITING, June 15, 2008
I have grown very bored with reading--including my own books. But this work is so well done I literally find myself getting up in the early morning, and grabbing the book as fast as my cherished morning coffee.
I have struggled for years to make sense of the Lyme instructional chaos, such as eccentric thinking and directions from health departments and the CDC. Some medical societies offer various Lyme "guidelines" and confusing Lyme treatment suggestions that make no sense. They simply have never appeared practical in the real world of clinical medicine. No patient is the same, and the extended lab testing I do, sometimes unveils other infections or a wide range of inflammation residues a year AFTER so called "curative" antobiotic treatment. I also never hear discussions about Lyme's BbTox 1 which is a patented Lyme surface biotoxin in a potent poison family.
In this context, the delicious writing of the master of the pen, Weintraub, is such a help, even for a full time researcher and author of infection textbooks. On this one, she is a lighthouse in the storm, who calms and clears the dark water and allows all of us to see the rocks and the insanity in a clear manner.
My only criticism is that I will be done reading this book in a few hours. Books of this powerful clarity and fascination only come along every few years. So buy and enjoy. Since I just read the veterinarians have declared Lyme is in all states, perhaps Weintraub's timing is perfect. This is not an infection you want to treat in yourself or your loved ones after many years--you want to get it now, before permanent injury occurs to the brain, the cartilage or other physical areas.
|
|
|
26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
HISTORIC, POWERFUL AND ENGROSSING , June 12, 2008
I have followed this famous author's long and respected career in science writing for some time. This is a writer's writer. And when I recently saw she was going to apply her keen mind, wit and brilliance to the issue of Lyme and the other infections routinely carried by the deer tick plague, I was delighted.
I had been to so many Ivy tower experts with the experience of children, and the blind mechanical reasoning of robots, who would look at obviously ill children or other relatives, and sadistically place some kind of Woody Allen joke psychiatric diagnosis on them. Once I even found myself sniffing their breath--no one is this idiotic, are your a drunk?
The infections before them were so far over thier skill and knowledge, they were fumbling like a toddlers in a pool, but they were causing us to drown. Many had fancy administrative positions which deluded them into arrogance and the deception they really knew what they were doing with Lyme (and Babesia, Bartonella and Ehrlichia).
After a few years of full time reading and almost having relatives and children die, and after all the sages and big name physicians sounded less and less informed, I fired them all and a relative fixed my family.
Weintraub gets it. She is not seduced by someone's position with the CDC or NIH. She is an ACTUAL reflective journalist of the old school who is a hard worker, who does not want an easy story, she wants the real deal. She wants the facts. This is Watergate medical style, and I feel it will be one of the most important medical books of the century. Because as IDSA and other dubious medical groups with simplistic clone-like treatment "guidelines," found to be profoundly questionable by the CT state attorney general, will lose the Lyme war, because reality always wins.... But often not until the last act.
This is a massive uncovering of the ugly side of medical politics and scams. And yet it is very engrossing and highly readable. If you have Lyme or have a relative with Lyme or you might have Lyme, you really want to be on a solid foundation before you get tricked into being given junk care. I have walked that road and believed in medical Popes. Yet now I know so many years later, there is no single expert Lyme medical group, and certianly NOT routine infection societies who are still stuck in the early 1990's.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|