Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
46 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sci-fi for grownups, February 1, 1999
By A Customer
This wonderful collection offers a wide variety of the very best science fiction, not of the "square-jawed-heroes-and-beautiful-princesses" kind, but the kind of fiction that leads you to ponder about deep philosophical matters. I only do not rate it with the full rating of 5 stars because of a few rather uninspired choices, for example H.G.Wells's "A Story of the Days to Come." I like Wells but it is no mystery that some of his stories are not up to scratch, and this is one of them: preachy and curiously unvisionary (sometimes comically so, like, why on Earth did Wells believe that the quaint institution of the chaperone would survive so many years into the future? But then, probably all of Wells' good stuff has already been overanthologized). Others have apparently been included just for the sake of representing a particular author, rather than because of their quality. However, the selection has been mostly made based on excellence, and the few not-so-goods are largely compensated by the sterling quality of the rest of the stories, some of which are true masterpieces, like Poul Anderson's "Goat Song," a beautiful and haunting recreation of the myth of Orpheus, the deeply disturbing "Mother" by Philip José Farmer and "Consider Her Ways" by John Wyndham, the original and fairy-taleish "The King and the Dollmaker" by Wolfgang Jeschke, the poetic "Riding the Tide of Mourning" by Richard Lupoff, and many others, in fact too numerous to mention. Of special merit are the inclusions of modern classics like Gibson's "Johnny Mnemonic" and Ellison's "Repent, Harlequin!" and others which are excellent but hard to find, like the exquisite but out of print "The Rose" by Charles Harness. A truly indespensable item for the sci-fi serious fan.
|
|
|
12 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Where are the aliens?, July 17, 2000
This book purports to survey the evolution of science fiction over the course of the twentieth century, and in this regard is a fairly educational tome. It's nice, for example, to know that E.M. Forster and Rudyard Kipling (!) wrote short stories that could fairly be called science fiction, and that there was a controversy among serious writers at the beginning of the century regarding whether inexorable technical progress would bring utopia or dystopia, and I feel richer for knowing that. However, this vast (>800 pages!) anthology baldly ignores stories which explore two favorite subjects of mine (and, I assume, many other readers): the implications of interstellar travel, and speculation on the nature of alien intelligence. There are a few stories here which investigate these topics, but only a few, and I was left with the suspicion that either (a) Hartwell simply doesn't like/"get" aliens and space opera, and likes time travel and noodlings on dystopia a whole lot more, or (b) there were serious copyright or reproduction problems with enough of the major short stories and novellas which classically treat these subjects that the entire subgenre was ignored...there's one particular example in which the introductory abstract for a story glows *about another story by the same author*, and then treats us to one of his lesser works. There are definitely some gems here which I haven't seen elsewhere (e.g. Farmer's "Mother"), and the works chosen are unquestionably among the best-written of the genre, but after plowing through the dozens of stories I found myself missing a treatment of the aspects of science fiction that I personally enjoy the most. It might be a good gift for that special someone whom you've never been able to turn on to SF -- these are good transition stories; some so good that you don't even know you're reading science fiction.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not Free SF Reader, March 2, 2008
Something of an introduction here by Hartwell to suggest that science fiction is the literature of the twentieth century, and stands in opposition to modernism. Sounds pretty dumb to see 'SF is anti-modern' of course, when he means it in the 'literature' sense.
He mentions the beginning of this as an argument between H. G. Wells and Henry James about that sort of thing. Something like 'Hey, H. G., how dare you write something good that isn't all depressing and deathly', in a nutshell. Apparently Forster agreed with James, which may explain the extremely tedious nature of The Machine Stops.
Apart from that and the junk C. S. Lewis story this is a high quality anthology. Pointing out that you used Clarke, Asimov etc. in a previous bigarse volume is one thing, but at least put something better in their place.
I think the point might be to skip the most famous, most well known stories though, perusing this lineup. How Johnny Mnemonic snuck in then, not sure.
A Century is correct though, from around 1890 to 1990, or Kipling to Kress if you prefer alpha to numeric.
Still, a very nice volume and absolutely a major anthology, with a 3.73 average, over such a broad timespan, with some gems you aren't too likely to come across in other places.
The other thing Hartwell has included is a smattering of non-English originally stories from Europe (although none from Asia, or South America or Africa) as other examples, and these are also pretty reasonable selections. He points out that the major centre of SF is America, something which is undeniable except maybe to some bizarre holdout extremely parochial poms perhaps.
If you get a chance to pick this over 1000 page monster up, do so.
Science Fiction Century : Beam Us Home - James Tiptree Jr.
Science Fiction Century : Ministering Angels - C. S. Lewis
Science Fiction Century : The Music Master of Babylon - Edgar Pangborn
Science Fiction Century : A Story of the Days to Come - H. G. Wells
Science Fiction Century : Hot Planet - Hal Clement
Science Fiction Century : A Work of Art [Art-Work] - James Blish
Science Fiction Century : The Machine Stops - E. M. Forster
Science Fiction Century : Brightness Falls from the Air - Margaret St. Clair
Science Fiction Century : 2066 Election Day - Michael Shaara
Science Fiction Century : The Rose - Charles Harness
Science Fiction Century : The Hounds of Tindalos - Frank Belknap Long
Science Fiction Century : The Angel of Violence - Adam Wisniewski-Snerg
Science Fiction Century : Nobody Bothers Gus - Algis Budrys
Science Fiction Century : The Time Machine - Dino Buzzati
Science Fiction Century : Mother - Philip Jose Farmer
Science Fiction Century : As Easy as A.B.C. - Rudyard Kipling
Science Fiction Century : Ginungagap - Michael Swanwick
Science Fiction Century : Minister Without Portfolio - Mildred Clingerman
Science Fiction Century : Time in Advance - William Tenn
Science Fiction Century : Good Night Sophie - Lino Aldani
Science Fiction Century : Veritas - James Morrow
Science Fiction Century : Enchanted Village - A. E. van Vogt
Science Fiction Century : The King and the Dollmaker - Wolfgang Jeschke
Science Fiction Century : Fire Watch - Connie Willis
Science Fiction Century : Goat Song - Poul Anderson
Science Fiction Century : The Scarlet Plague - Jack London
Science Fiction Century : Drunkboat - Cordwainer Smith
Science Fiction Century : Another World - J. H. Rosny-Aîné
Science Fiction Century : If the Stars Are Gods - Gregory Benford and Gordon Eklund
Science Fiction Century : I Still Call Australia Home - George Turner
Science Fiction Century : Liquid Sunshine - Alexander Kuprin; trans. by Leland Fetzer
Science Fiction Century : Great Work of Time - John Crowley
Science Fiction Century : Sundance - Robert Silverberg
Science Fiction Century : Greenslaves - Frank Herbert
Science Fiction Century : Rumfuddle - Jack Vance
Science Fiction Century : The Dimple in Draco - Philip Latham
Science Fiction Century : Consider Her Ways - John Wyndham
Science Fiction Century : Something Ending - Eddy C. Bertin
Science Fiction Century : He Who Shapes - Roger Zelazny
Science Fiction Century : Swarm - Bruce Sterling
Science Fiction Century : Beggars in Spain [SS] - Nancy Kress
Science Fiction Century : Johnny Mnemonic [SS] - William Gibson
Science Fiction Century : Repent Harlequin! Said the Ticktockman - Harlan Ellison
Science Fiction Century : Blood's a Rover - Chad Oliver
Science Fiction Century : Sail the Tide of Mourning - Richard A. Lupoff
Dogstar biowar ending.
4 out of 5
Space escort barrel scraping.
2.5 out of 5
An elderly survivor of some nuking lives in a museum, and one day comes across a couple of primitive kids, nascent musicians.
4 out of 5
Giving the past lifestyle a try.
3 out of 5
Vulcan solution.
3.5 out of 5
Composer impression.
4 out of 5
Can't do anything ourselves.
3 out of 5
Bird people buried.
3 out of 5
This is a job for eight of us man, Uncle Sam?
4 out of 5
This is a book about science and art, and how people view such things might have an impact on human evolution and the development of a new species, homo superior. Also sarcastic commentary on authorities that want to hamper or censor such things.
3 out of 5
Author's drug doom by dimension dogs.
4 out of 5
4.5 out of 5
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|