Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing Conclusion, May 17, 2008
The first book was just good enough to make me read book two. Book two was just good enough to make me read book three. Good thing there is no book four, because I wouldn't have continued. This is a very disappointing conclusion to the trilogy. Kirkpatrick is a marvelous writer, to be sure, and his evocation of place is excellent, but in the end the characters just don't do enough to justify a book.
Without entering any spoilers in thie review, suffice it to say that the final showdown between the Falthans and their evil nemesis finally takes place in a fairly dry manner. In the end, this series would have worked better as a single book, with some tight editing and more attention to character development and plotting.
If you liked books one and two, you'll probably like book three. I found it disappointing and probably won't buy any more of Kirkpatrick's books until he stops trying to stretch one book into three.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
good conclusion, April 12, 2008
Enjoyable conclusion to the trilogy. At the end of this book, I felt as if I was saying goodbye to old friends, which for me is a sign that the author did a good job bringing his characters to life.
The battle scenes were well done , and the apparent defeat of the Falthan army at the end was an interesting twist.
As others have noted, the detailed descriptions of the different landscapes added to the realism, though the author/cartographer's abundance of place names was at times confusing.
In the tradition of Tolkien's work, if not quite as good, this trilogy held my interest right to the end.
|
|
|
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, but not unexepected., April 8, 2008
Sometimes I wonder how this stuff gets published. I mean, this trilogy started out OK. And I mean, just plain OK. A real LOTR ripoff, but lots of books are, so that's no big deal. The second book really improved upon the first and I was looking forward to the third. But, Kirkpatrick really let us down with a formulaic, poorly written and wholly unbelievable conclusion to his little epic. The book starts out bad and just gets worse. Even the evil wizard/Sauron guy, who was fairly interesting in limited appearances throughout the first two books, becomes nothing but a weenie in the end. It's one thing to kill the bad guy, it's quite another to turn him into a weenie. It just doesn't make sense.
There's lots and lots of "this doesn't make sense" bits in this book, too many to mention. The set up for the war is implausible (all of a sudden, tons of armies just APPEAR, ready to fight!!!) The battle scenes are not well-written. The lead character's emotional problems and refusal to deal with them don't seem true to form and again, don't make sense. The ending is just plain silly and wholly predictable. The main female character, who was supposed to have some important part to play in everything, doesn't really do much except suffer. Her appearance at the end of the book attempts some form of clever ending, but it really doesn't do much. The book still retains the travelogue aspect of the first two as yet more geography is traversed. Eventually, you get tired of this gigantic mass of characters going through yet another storm in yet another mountain pass. Can't these guys travel to San Diego or something to get out of the weather for a few days?
I guess if you're 15 years old and think "Eragon" and "Harry Potter" are good books, you MIGHT like this series. For anyone older, it probably won't do much for you. Too bad, really, as the second book showed some promise. I hear there's another book or something similar coming up. I have no idea if I'll get it. Maybe if I'm desperate or stuck in an airport or something.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|