From Publishers Weekly
In this folksy revision of "I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly," an auburn-haired woman in a calico dress looks out her window at a yellow, five-pointed star while her son sleeps under a patterned quilt. The lady fetches some running shoes and roller skates ("She bought the skates to replace the shoes./ She bought the shoes to catch the star./ I don't know why she wanted a star-/ it seemed too far"). She next acquires a car, a plane and a "big rocket,/ then zoomed up and caught the star in her pocket." Using all her modes of transportation in reverse order, she returns to the farmhouse and affectionately presents her son with the star "in a jar. (So it wasn't too far!)" Harper (Imaginative Inventions) populates whimsical land- and cityscapes with fanciful bugs, birds and animals. The bold lady buys a bike from a small pink squirrel, then cycles through a flowery forest; she gets a car from a speckled snake and cruises past quirky shops. For each reiteration of the sequence, Harper provides a rebus alongside her key words. Delicate stippled dots and understated spirals decorate every available surface. These attentive folk-art touches complement the spry singalong verse, while suggesting the heights that love might reach. Ages 4-8.
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
reSchool-Grade 2-Yet another variation on the familiar English folk song. This time the protagonist is a feisty, "bold" lady who wanted a star. "I don't know why she wanted a star-it seemed too far." She buys running shoes from a funny-looking caterpillar salesman and runs for miles before stopping for a snooze. Then she buys skates to replace the shoes, a bike to replace the skates, a car to replace the bikes, and on and on until she acquires a rocket to zoom off to catch the star. The imaginative and inventive retelling maintains the rhyme of the original except for a slight change at the end. Acrylic cartoons in bright colors lend a zany feel to this bold lady who lets nothing get in the way of reaching her star, which she puts in a jar ("So it wasn't so far!"). An action-packed read-aloud.
Leslie Barban, Richland County Public Library, Columbia, SCCopyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.