Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
29 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A contrast of beauty and tragedy..., June 3, 2005
If you are a Nicholas and Alexandra fan and can only have one book in your collection, Tsar: The Lost World of Nicholas and Alexandra by Peter Kurth is that book. There is not a book around that is so stunningly beautiful, or that brings the world of Nicholas and Alexandra to life as this one does.
Unlike many coffee-table books, Tsar gives a comprehensive history of the story of Nicholas and Alexandra from their childhoods to their captivity and death. It also details the discovery of their remains, although it was published just prior to their state burial in 1998. The one negative about the text is that Kurth displays a thinly veiled endorsement of Anna Anderson actually being Anastasia. I don't care how similar they may have looked-show me the DNA.
But the true story is told through the unbelievable pictures and paintings of both the past and present. It is in these that Tsar: The Lost World truly excels. These photographs not only show the beauty of their lives, but also are haunting in that they reveal the true tragedy of the last tsar and his family. Many before and after pictures are used to show the amazing contrast. They include The Winter Palace today, and when it was used as a World War I hospital. Or the tranquil photo of the Palace Square during a snowfall today vs. the Bloody Sunday Massacre scene. Especially tragic are the pictures of the imperial children along with modern day photos of their toys and playthings. They truly were innocent victims in this saga. The pictures of the royal residences are larger than life (many in color) and are alone worth the price of this book. They include The Alexander Palace, The Catherine Palace, The Winter Palace, Peterhof, Livadia and Gatchina. It's eerie to see these places today, now so quiet, tranquil and vacant. A good number of the photos in Tsar are previously unpublished, and many are from palaces and rooms that are not open to the public. Even a die-hard Romanov fan will find something new here.
But for all the beauty of the Romanov's lifestyle, Kurth also shows the flip side including the dead Rasputin, the skeletan remains of the Romanovs, piles of World War I dead, trampled victims from Khodynka (the coronation celebration turned deadly), crumbling buildings, and photos showing the cellar in the Ipatiev House soon after Nicholas and family were brutally murdered there. They're all very sobering, indeed. Tsar also features an introduction by Edward Radzinsky, the noted author of The Last Tsar.
So, if you are looking for a book that truly reflects the beauty and tragedy of Nicholas and Alexandra, Tsar: The Lost World is a must. But do yourself a favor and stick with the hardback version. It is a much more impressive book than the softbound version and one you will treasure for years.
|
|
|
23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fresh historical perspective., April 28, 2001
I've read about the last Russian tsar, Nicholas II, and his family for years, but I never felt like I really understood their lives and their lifestyle until I bought and read this book. The text is an interesting historical summation, but it doesn't reveal anything your average student of Russian history wouldn't already know. What is so special about this book is the pictures. Beautiful full-color photos of the magnificient palaces and locations frequented by the Russian royal family are displayed next to a comprehensive collection of historical photos from the era. In addition to the classic royal portraits you have probably seen, there are many candid photos of the family going about their daily life. Frequently, a historical picture is shown next to a gorgeous contemporary photograph of the same locale. For example, a black and white photograph of two of the Grand Duchess rowing past the "children's island" at Tsarkoe Selo is shown with a brilliantly colored picture of the same spot as it looks today. Thanks to these beautiful photographs, I have a whole new appreciation of the incredible luxury of the royal surroundings, and what a grand contrast it must have been to the lifestyle of the average Russian peasants.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Glossy, sumptous record of a lost world, May 14, 2004
This large coffee table style book is essentially a visual record of the last Russian Tsar and his family. It features page after page of large photos - the famous black and white family album shots, many not-so-famous pictures of the family at home and their friend and relatives. These are interspersed with colour photographs of relevant locations (e.g. Alexander Palace, site of the former Impatiev House), which are absolutely stunning purely from a visual point of view. Photos of personal objects that belonged to the family - jewelery, letters and toys are also included. Along with the photos, there is an accompanying text that tells the basic story. It covers the Romanov saga right from Nicholas and Alexandra's childhoods, to their marriage, children, Rasputin, the revolution and the modern day sequel to their story. It is not an academic work, and the information is broad and somewhat lacking in detail. For information on the last Tsar, there are numerous biographies which would serve the inquiring reader better. But as I said, this is a coffee table book for the lay person. It is like the "creme caramel" of the Romanov library. Rich, indulgent, a must have, but definately not the main course.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|