Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ben Kincaid is back with another seriocomic thriller., April 22, 2001
"Murder One" is the latest entry in William Bernhardt's series of legal thrillers featuring the nebbishy lawyer from Oklahoma, Ben Kincaid. Although Ben is far from macho, he is a true idealist, and he is an aggressive and smart courtroom attorney. Christina McCall, Ben's former legal assistant, has recently graduated from law school and she is now Ben's partner. The case in this book deals with the horrible murder and mutilation of a policeman, Joe McNaughton, who was a popular man on the Tulsa police force. McNaughton's cop buddies and his widow are sure that the killer is a nineteen-year-old stripper named Keri Dalcanton. Keri was Joe's lover until he ended their torrid affair. Ben faces formidable obstacles in his efforts to acquit Kerry. First of all, there is strong circumstantial evidence linking Keri to Joe's murder. In addition, several policemen have a vendetta against Ben and Keri in the form of "the blue squeeze," which consists of physical and verbal harassment by the police. As usual, Ben's case seems hopeless and dangerous. However, he and his loyal staff battle the D. A. and the police with some clever tactics of their own. As always, Ben and his cohorts are amusing and charming, and the case is complicated and involving. There are plenty of red herrings to keep the reader guessing. However, Bernhardt goes overboard in several areas. There are graphic depictions of sadomasochistic and kinky sex that do not mix well with the gentle humor that pervades much of the book. The ending is way over the top and the plot becomes extremely contrived in an effort to "surprise" the reader. I enjoy a good surprise, but not at the expense of believability. All in all, "Murder One" is a serviceable legal thriller, but Bernhardt should have toned down the sensationalism and made the plot play out a little more realistically.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Blue Squeeze, the Cop's Way of Getting Even, November 27, 2003
Veteran police detective Joe McNaughton was a cop everybody liked, so when he was found murdered, his nude body hanging from a fountain with his privates severed and stuffed in his mouth in downtown Tulsa, his pals are understandably upset. Though married. McNaughton had nineteen-year-old stripper Keri Dalcanton as a main squeeze and the police quickly arrest her. The cops, along without everyone else in town it seems, want her blood and the assistant DA is seeking the death penalty.
The book opens in court and good guy attorney Ben Kincaid is looking at a loser. He believes Keri is innocent, but the police just have too much evidence, then he notices a problem with the search warrents used to obtain said evidence and through an intuitive stroke of good luck he gets Keri off on a technicality.
The cops, especially McNaughton's partner Arlen Matthews, go nuts. They decide to apply the Blue Squeeze, a term that means something like, damn the law and get even, cop style. They raid Kincaid's office and find the murder weapon, then they arrest the attorney and brutalize him in jail.
From this point on the battle lines are drawn, it's the cops verses Kincaid and the police will stop at nothing. Kincaid bails out of jail, but the cops re-arrest Keri and this time the slick DA himself is prosecuting the case. He wants to ride to re-election on the back of the conviction.
There is enough tense courtroom drama alone in this legal thriller to keep you tuning the pages at a steady clip, but the struggle leading up to the second trial and the long lead up to a climax straight out of left field will speed your reading like you wouldn't believe.
|
|
|
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
William Bernhardt's Back but Not at His Best..., May 28, 2001
Tulsa, Oklahoma criminal defense attorney, Ben Kincaid, is fighting an uphill battle to keep his client, Keri Dalcanton, a nineteen year old kinky stripper, out of prison. She's charged with the grisly murder and mutilation of her married lover, police detective Joe McNaughton, and even though Ben believes her to be innocent, all the circumstantial evidence points in her direction and he doesn't see much chance of winning this case. That is until a technicality sets her free. The police and D.A.'s office is outraged at what they consider this miscarriage of justice and promise they'll avenge McNaughton's death by other means, if necessary. Ben is just thankful for the lucky legal break and that this media circus of a case is finally over. Unfortunately, he couldn't be more wrong. Within days, incrimminating evidence of the murder is found in Ben's office, Keri's technicality is thrown out and Ben, himself is facing charges for obstruction and murder one..... William Bernhardt has written a fast paced, legal thriller with an interesting premise, but he doesn't always deliver. His plot needs to be tightened up and is more complicated at times, than intricate and compelling. His characters could be better developed and fleshed out and there are so many, you need a scorecard to keep track of who's who and what's what. But it's the implausible and contrived "surprise" ending I found most disappointing. After 288 pages, you shouldn't have to suspend belief to finish the last 29 pages of the book. Murder One is adequate beach reading with decent courtroom scenes, but Mr Bernhardt has written better books.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|