Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
124 of 139 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Close minded judgemental SW fans stay away....., February 29, 2000
Let me just say I'm pretty shocked by all the "If I could give Zero stars I would" reviews here. I've read all the Star Wars novels also, and I liked most of them, didn't like some, and some I thought were fantastic. Tim Zahn, for instance has 5 brilliant novels. This novel is great too. I'm so disappointed in some of these Star Wars fans here to be so incredibly closed minded, and afraid of change. Aren't you tired of the Empire making ANOTHER comeback? Aren't you tired of the Jedi kids getting kidnapped again? Aren't you tired of another Superweapon? Then this is a fantastic step in the right direction. The writing is very fast paced and is gripping. Many readers complain of "no plot movement". I beg to differ. It moves along at a fine pace, and there is another thing to consider. This is the FIRST book in a continuous story arc of a TWENTY-FIVE book series. Do you want everything resolved in one book? Give me a break. I think the Yuuzhan Vong are a very interesting race, and will make for some great books. Also, you people that can't handle Chewie's death, get a life(By the way, I found his death was classy and well done. I was nearly brought to tears, and he went out a hero). For so long now, our SW characters were invincible. The books lose some intensity when you KNOW the main stars can't die. This move wasn't a publicity stunt. It was bringing something fresh and new to the Star Wars universe, and I welcome it. There was also a comment about this being a DARK novel. I agree. It is more dark and foreboding than others. But, I must say after "Phantom Menace" seemed to target the 10 and under audience, I'm very happy to see the SW universe take a more adult view, without losing the "feeling" of this great place. You want more cute stuff, go read Ewok adventures or something. One criticism I agree with was the portrayal of Mara Jade. Her character was rather flat, and I expected much more from the firey red-headed Jedi. Of course, she kind of has her reasons for being so subdued. Finally, I'm sending a challege to all Star Wars fans that bashed Vector Prime. Go to theforce.net and read the MASSIVE interview with R.A. Salvatore in the interview section. He addresses many of the criticisms of his novel, and really explained everything you could possibly want to know about the new direction of the novels. Including the Chewie issue and many others. I GUARANTEE upon reading this, some will change minds about this novel. Hopefully I haven't offended anyone too badly, for we all love Star Wars, and I just get upset when my SW brothers and sisters can't handle change. I think more highly of us as readers. I'm off my soapbox now.
|
|
|
30 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dark, Darker, Darkest, October 8, 1999
This is not the Star Wars we all grew up with. I have read all the books, all the collected comics etc, and this is something very different. The art on the cover gives you an idea of what's inside. Two things that are outstanding; 1. a Map of The Star Wars Galaxy, 2. and a Time Line of the books, that while not going all the way back, covers 99% of what should have been included years ago. THANK YOU! Mr. Salvatore adapted to this saga very well, and without the one-liners that have gotten so annoying from the original 3 movies. He didn't use any crutches, and created amazing new life forms, organic weapons etc. Excellent story, well-paced, never slumps, keeps the tension high, so plan on a late night or two. The "IT" that others refer to bothered me, as I feel it was unecessary. That type of written device usually props up a weak story, and this book is anything but weak. But be prepared, this is a grim New Republic, many of our favorite characters are angry, very angry.Teenagers kill, with justification, but it's one more reminder that this "New" series is very new and very dark. If it were a movie, they would have to work hard and cut alot to not get an R. Still it's outstanding. Don't give up on "IT", a crack in that door was left open, and fans will kick that door in. Enjoy!
|
|
|
22 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Skip Vector Prime, go directly to Onslaught, February 3, 2000
By A Customer
If you haven't bought Vector Prime yet: DON'T. Go directly to the listing for Michael Stackpole's new Star Wars novel "Dark Tide Book One: Onslaught" and purchase it instead. Vector Prime is a poorly constructed mish-mash of a book that bears little to no resemblance to the Star Wars universe as we know it through earlier books. Looking for your favorite characters? You won't find them here. Oh, their names are the same, but the personalities are one-dimensional. Looking for a tightly plotted story? It ain't here, either. Instead, characters fly off willy nilly solely as it suits the author, with little to no explanation given for the enormous coincidences that are the only engine driving this plot. In a word, this books -- well, it's the word used to describe how you are able to drink through a straw. It's incredibly disappointing. But if you ARE looking for a terrific Star Wars novel, go directly to "Onslaught." There you'll find the characters we know and love, with a story that is very well told indeed. You don't need Vector Prime at all -- Stackpole does a great job summing up everything you need to know, with a far greater emotional impact than Salvatore was capable of. Trust me. You'll be much happier -- and you'll save a few dollars!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|