Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Pretty, but Otherwise Average, June 7, 2004
I was quite excited upon learning that an update was in the works for one of my favorite Star Wars books of all time. The original Essential Guide to Vehicles and Vessels was (and still largely is) a one-of-a-kind work. Prior to that, most of the ships of the expanded universe appeared only in printed text- not illustrations. Doug Chiang and Troy Vigil really added life to the ships of the Star Wars universe. The New Essential Guide is something less than new. The full color illustrations are the best part of it- especially those that depict vessels not shown in the previous work. Additionally, there's some background on vehicle manufacturers, famous battles, and comparisons between vessel sublight and hyperspace speed. Other than this, however, the book falls short of its previous incarnation. The schematics largely tell you things you could have inferred just by looking at the picture (The ship has a hull?! No way!) and the text is watered down for a younger audience. There's not as many hard facts or numbers, including no comparison at all of shield or hull strength (something I, a long-time SW space sim player, was hoping for). There is a simple explanation of the basic technologies at the start, appropriately titled 'A Layperson's Guide to Technology.' It seems the author and publishers aren't aware that most kids nowadays are more familiar with technical jargon than adults. Aside from these minor complaints, there is one major issue I have with this book. That is, only a handful of new ships are shown, and most of these are from the prequels. Frankly, other books like the Incredible Cross Sections series have covered these vehicles better than the Essential Guide could hope to. There's also the issue of beating a dead horse. If you don't know what an X-wing looks like by now, you probably won't be buying this book. Why recap material that's been published a dozen times already? There's a whole load of new ships in the New Jedi Order series alone (i.e. the Bothan Assault Frigate, Star Defender, Ranger Gunship). Why not present those? The New Essential Guide to Vehicles and Vessels does have some cool features, but aside from the updated color illustrations, it is less than 'new' and hardly 'essential.' I would recommend the original Essential Guide over this one, and advise those that already own it to check out other guides first.
|
|
|
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My son and I both love this book!, January 26, 2004
This large and attractive book is an overview of vehicles from the Star Wars universe, containing everything from the AAT to the Z-95 Headhunter. Each vehicle is shown in a color, full-page picture, with a technical readout, and then is given a one page introduction with schematics. Lots and lots of vehicles are here, including many from the movies and the New Jedi Order, though obviously not from Episode III.My son is a major fan of Star Wars, and was really glad to get this book. The colorful and serious way that these vehicles are treated really brings them to life, making them seem as real to him as any real vehicles. Plus, he loved the one-page description of the vehicles, and pored over the book for many hours. He loves this book, and so do I! We both highly recommend this book.
|
|
|
16 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing..., October 29, 2003
By A Customer
Lately, the Essential Guides have all been very good and informative, The Essential Chronology and The New Essential Guide to Characters being probably the best. The older guides were also generally satisfying. But unfortunately this book is a real let-down.I've been eagerly waiting for a new vehicles guide for years, and the high quaility of each successive Guide only made the wait more tantalizing. The new look of the Essential Guides, starting with the new charcters guide by Daniel Wallace was excellent. The book was full of not only full color illustrations, but useful, new information. Dan Wallace seems the perfect writer for this job. And to the New Essential Guide to Vehicles and Vessels... Some good, some avarage quality pictures, and that's about all. Lots of very important vehicles and ships were omitted, while page after page was wasted with already well known things, such as the Sandcrawler, Luke's landspeeder, snowspeeder, Virago, etc. Where are the important vehicles newly introduced, such as the Bothan Assault Cruiser, all the New Class New Republic capital ships and various other new ships from the EU? Where is the Pulsar Skate? Why mention Hound's Tooth and IG-2000 again, rather than this time around including the Mist Hunter and Punishing One?(not that they are very important ships) The existing entries are also bland and empty. Apparently Haden Blackman got lazy and added almost no new information. The Naboo ships still lack names. Almost no history and background to the vehicles. There are some funny quotes from the peoples of the galaxy about those ships, but that's about all, and some of the quotes are pretty stupid. The Star Destroyer entry is terrible, all the SD types stashed into two pages. Likewise for the Mon Calamari cruisers. No details about all the new X-wing classes, such as the XJ and XJ3 models; they are only briefly mentioned. One wonders where the hell is their third proton torpedo launcher... It seems we'll never know. Haden Blackman's writing style is also pretty dry, it seems he copied most of his information from the old vehicles guide and Incredible Cross-Sections books. And I wonder who edited this book, or if any editors were involved at all. The book is full of typos and mistakes. In the small(and inadequate) schematics below each page, a lot of the numerics were wrong or didn't correspond to the said item. In the Interdictor entry, it says the New Republic ''confiscated the remainin Interdictors after Thrawn's defeat.'' What nonsense. A-wing's affiliation is Galactic Empire(!), and at the end of the BTL-S3 Y-wing entry, almost as an afterthought it's added that ''there is also a two-seater version''. Well, BTL-S3 is THE two seater version! And so on, so on... My advice; look at the pretty pictures in this book, and then put it back on the bookshelf. Not worth the money, get yourselves a copy of the old Essential Guide to Vehicles&Vessels if you don't already have it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|