From Publishers Weekly
Analyzing the "significant advance of arrogance, unruliness, greed, and cynicism in the legal profession," Harvard law professor Glendon (Rights Talk) ambitiously assays the burgeoning legal world. According to the author, big-firm lawyers are motivated less by professional ideals than by client loyalty, judges prefer judicial supremacy to more democratic processes and legal education has drifted from professional pedagogy to often-irrelevant ideology. However, she believes "legal hubris" may have begun to decline and suggests that the Anglo-American legal tradition can reinvigorate today's "pragmatic" students. Glendon's analysis has historical depth and ideological subtlety: she recognizes both the strengths and the weaknesses of the past and states that the number of lawyers matters less than what those lawyers do. While her overblown subtitle might be better inverted-society probably has more effect on lawyers-and her survey is necessarily incomplete, this readable, moderate book should stimulate debate.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
When "critical legal studies" deny standards of objectivity, billable hours replace lifelong lawyer-client relationships, and advertising substitutes for reputation, the crisis bemoaned by this Harvard law prof appears intractable indeed. Beyond her erudite description of these dismaying features, she offers little solace but Micawber-like patience until some improvements show up--but will they ever? In her view, the foxes are so far inside the chicken houses, especially the American Bar Association, the judiciary, and the academy, that cleaning out the coops will be an arduous task. Portions of this tract harken back to the early 1960s, when her J.D. was minted in the classical fashion by fussy, elbow-patched teachers for whom the law was a calling, not a business. Glendon supports this outlook with summaries of the bar's giants, like Holmes, Hand, Frankfurter, and Cardozo, whose counsel of restraint and realism she hopes the next generation of lawyers will heed. A bit technical, but timely for students plunging into law school.
Gilbert Taylor
See all Editorial Reviews