Los Angeles Times Sunday Book Review, Lynn Smith
Most readers probably won't get through all 484 pages (including notes), of
Common Purpose, and Schorr's arguments, which occasionally fall into wonk-like jargon, are unlikely to convince those who insist that poverty is the result of moral failing and are determined to dismantle rather than reform ineffective government. The book's biggest contribution may lie in Schorr's compilation of 22 pioneering reforms, already well underway but rarely reported because of their typically low drama and high complexity. Fellow reformers will find support in the scope of experiments--from home visiting to school-community collaborations and literacy programs--that embody many of her practical solutions.
From Kirkus Reviews
Tough, cerebral, informed--and sanguine but not quixotic about the possibilities of injecting flexibility and imagination into the policies that govern welfare, child protection, and education. In an earlier work (Within Our Reach, 1988), Schorr (director of the Harvard Project on Effective Intervention) examined small, experimental social programs that successfully made a dent in seemingly intractable problems like teen pregnancy, school dropouts, and unemployment. A decade later, she finds many of the innovations strangled by bureaucracy or still limited to the neighborhoods where they began. But all is not lost, says Schorr. Leading from crowded classrooms and the cubicles that house children's-services and public-assistance workers are threads of insight and ingenuity that can be woven into a tapestry of programs that will serve the poor, the undereducated, and the overwhelmed. With new techniques of measurement, these programs can be realistically evaluated and propagated. What works, she says, are programs that are close enough to their communities to be ``comprehensive, flexible, responsive, and persevering.'' But good intentions are not enough. Such programs must also have clearly defined goals, competent, well-trained staffs--and government money. A chapter titled ``Taming Bureaucracies . . .'' is one of the most effective in the book, partly because Schorr does not abandon government employees, or even politicians, to the usual charges of apathy and selfishness. Other chapters look closely at productive partnerships among schools, families, and community and government agencies that have effectively reduced child abuse and neglect, drug abuse, illiteracy and unemployment. ``I have tried to paint a picture of the possible,'' says Schorr--and she has. But the picture also demands hard work, an open mind, and, yes, faith from every citizen who views it. (Author tour) --
Copyright ©1997, Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.
See all Editorial Reviews