Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
More Hope for Horace, April 19, 2001
By A Customer
Ted Sizer's stories of what's happening in American high schools seem accurate and familiar. What's embarrassing is that a guy like him can go in, study the situation, identify what is happening and proceed to make changes, one school at a time, and have it grow into a nationwide movement. I say embarrassing because there are administrators (and teachers) in these schools year after year, who, either don't notice what Sizer sees or don't seem to be committed enough to affect change.It's almost an "Emperor has no clothes story". Nobody wants to sayanything to rock the boat-until it all collapses.Sizer stops short of saying there will be anything like a revolution- he knows schools change too slowly to do that-but he does make a strong case for the embarrassment of America's underperforming and the underprivileged. I understand exactly what he's talking about when he talks about how poorly even the good students can discuss what they've learned, or identify what are the main ideas of what they've read. AS a teacher, I know their ability to make connections in history or have a sense of geography is abominable. It would almost be excusable except for the fact that teachers have been going through their gyrations of lessons since the kindergarten year. For the most part- the teachers blame the students. I like the fact that Sizer does not. The power of America's media is well known, but I hadn't thought of it as the great American cultural unifier, supplanting the American school. This is an interesting notion. If this is true, it should free the schools of their self-imposed responsibility to teach American values, and therefore the schools can take a firmer position on scholarship, for example. The predominance of the media as culture gives us all the more reason to ask students (and ourselves)- `How do we make sense out of all of this?' The opposite path would be to bury our heads in a textbook reading- answering the questions at the end of the chapter. As Sizer (speaking of technology and the media) puts it, "The imagination has new equipment in its arsenal". However some (the poor) have no equipment. I don't know why it takes a man like Sizer to remind us of our responsibilities to citizens in the name of democracy.Politicians and administrators should be leading the way in this regard, instead of obstructing positive change. Politicians preach equality every day- but Sizer seems to accomplish more toward the goals of freedom and equality despite having far less influence to start with. It's not just the schools that are broken. "What about standards for a system that accelerates the inequity in which they (children) live?" (p28) or standards for educators and politicians? (p46). I concur with Sizer's view that there are two movements in America, top down and bottom up. This unspoken conflict is the reason for little or no change in our school system. Teachers want bottom up change, but instead, they are reluctantly implementing top down programs. The standards movement will be sabotaged everywhere- because there are no reasonable conditions to achieve them (Sizer's words). But what I like best about Sizer is that he proposes hope and sensibility. New schools will emerge from alliances of students, teachers, parents, or the government will create more charter schools, or teachers will create non-profits or do what has been done in New York City- Deborah Meier with her school (CPESS) as well as the Center for Collaborative Education. Wouldn't it be interesting to see what American education would be like if people like Meier or Sizer were on the Bush cabinet as Secretary of Education?
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Real good read, November 27, 2000
Theodore Sizer, the Chairman of the Coalition of Essential Schools has written his third book about the experiences and observations of Horace Smith, his fictional representation of an American high school English teacher. Theodore Sizer launched a successful but slow-paced revolution that requires more and elicits more from adolescent students. He participated in a study that revealed that today's schools teach useless fact memorization and have weak curriculums that do not challenge the students or the teachers. In this book, Horace's Hope, Sizer picks up where he left off in his previous two books. Sizer revisits the schools from his previous books, and sees that not much has changed at all. Sizer contends that the new school is no longer the academies but instead is the media. He says that schools must give students the tools to understand the media's message, and if necessary challenge their profit-driven ideas. He believes that the goal is "informed skepticism". This can be achieved through small classes and a multidisciplinary curriculum. Instead of the normal standardized exams, our students need to do project-orientated goals that are displayed much like a dissertation. Both the teachers and the parents must decide upon the curriculum. This opens up for Sizer's next opinion about the schools and communities. He makes a strong case for school choice. He proposes a solution to the problems of bad schools in both bad and good neighborhoods. Sizer suggests that geographic boundaries be obliterated, with public money following the student to the school of choice. This would allow parents the choice of sending their children to any school. If too many choose this particular school then a lottery would choose. This would encourage that all schools are helped. The fictional teacher, Horace, does not play a big role as in the previous two books. This book is mainly a celebration of Sizer's Coalition of Essential Schools, which supports the growing number of schools embracing the group's nine goals. Sizer contends that communities need to come together. He provides real-life examples from observation about the delinquencies of our schools and teachers. Sizer wants our children doing the "higher learning", which is sometimes associated with college studies (although most colleges do not even go this far). This creative learning is not possible from most teachers because they were educated in the same system they now inhabit. Thus, the cycle perpetuates. Sizer himself illustrates education at its best, setting up arguments, marshalling evidence, and reaching a convincing conclusion. He says there is a slow change. This change is what gives Horace, and the teachers like him, hope. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in education of our children.My personal favorites on education are (in order): To Know as WE are Known: Education as a Spiritual Journey by Parker Palmer & Beyond Discipline: From Conformity to Community by Alphie Kohn
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Education Reform: The Tortoise and The Hare, January 11, 2000
Horace's HopeTheodore Sizer, the Chairman of the Coalition of Essential Schools has written his third book about the experiences and observations of Horace Smith, his fictional representation of an American high school English teacher. In Horace's Hope, Sizer returns to many of the schools he studied and chronicled in his two previous books, Horace's Compromise and Horace's School. Though many of their problems still exist, the changes that have been implemented offer Horace and all of us hope for the American high school. Many of the schools in Horace's Hope are now members of CES and have adopted the nine essential principles. These general principles, Sizer contends are only as good as the positive changes they create and the perseverance of those who implement them. Sizer contends that communities need to come together. Teachers and principals alone cannot get the job of education done. The community needs to be highly involved but mostly the parents and the students themselves, the focus of education reform. Some of these principles call for a change of philosophy, a change in action, are rather expensive and, all together, take time. I recommend this book to those who might have anything to do with education whether they are teachers, parents, employers, or community leaders. We all have an investment in how our youth achieve in the 21st century and our involvement and productive community partnership is a major key to their success. Horace's hope has not been diminished but strengthened by the chaos, difficulties and torturously slow progress of positive change because progress is taking place even if a little at a time.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Nancy Faust Sizer
by Paul S. George
by Theodore R. Sizer
See all Editorial Reviews
