Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hard Lessons for a Prom Queen, February 6, 2001
OK, I confess: I'm a 30 - year old mother with a career, and I'm still reading teenage fiction. How sad is that? Not at all, actually, when it's written as well as this book. Imagine: you are lovely Lara, Little Miss Popular, Homecoming Queen. Life is sweet. Mammy's rich and Daddy is good looking. Your boyfriend is deep and sensitive(even if not quite as popular as the one you dumped last year). You are friends with the cool crowd and wonder on occasions if your best friend Molly, who has a tendency to speak her mind and carries a few pounds too many, matches up. But you are a good girl, who offers Molly and other plump unfortunates condescending advice on how to improve themselves. And then you get fat. Not just a little overweight, but really, massively fat.Even without eating anything .Your positive attitude and discipline don't seem to help. Suddenly you are at the receiving end of pitying glances and "helpful" advice.You are no longer cool or cute. Your boyfriend still loves you but"just isn't in love anymore..." This excellent and inventive book deals with the inner turmoil of a Prom Queen's descent into fat hell. What I liked best was that the author resolutely refuses all easy cop outs. Lara now knows how fat people feel, but it makes her no wiser.The fat girl that she has patronised doesn't suddenly become her best friend. No, she visits Lara in hospital and gloats at her misfortune. Lara doesn't fall in love with the fat boy at her new school, they don't go on a diet and live happily ever after. But Lara does learn to live with her condition and learns a few hard lessons in the process. The quality of the writing is superb. All in all, a worthwhile book not only for adolescents.
|
|
|
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting idea, terrible execution, March 22, 2005
I was looking forward to reading this book because it dealt with a topic that's very personal to me: being thin for most of your life and then suddenly gaining a lot of weight due to having a metabolic disorder. This happened to me a few years ago, and I was recently put on medication for my problem. I've never let my change in appearance get me down, though, and I was anticipating reading a story which featured a plus-sized heroine who isn't defined by her looks.
Boy, was I disappointed. Though the book is well-written, I found the narrator, Lara, to be incredibly shallow and conceited. And it pained me that all she did was whine about being "huge" and no longer popular. Yes, it's understandable that she'd be concerned about gaining so much weight in such a short amount of time - who wouldn't be worried about their body going through a drastic change? - but I wish some of her and her parents' concerns had been about her health (potential heart problems, etc.) I also didn't think the story sent out a positive message to the age group that it's intended for. We only see Lara kinda-sorta come to terms with being plus-sized in the very last chapter. Until then, she's resigned to being an "unattractive" outcast .. and when she "accepts" herself, it's mainly because it's suggested that she's on her way to becoming "normal" again. So, did Lara even really learn anything? It's hard to say. As far as I could tell, she was still judgmental and shallow even at the end of the story.
I wish that we'd seen more of an evolution of her going from hating herself to finding ways to love the new her. Instead of shipping her off to a new town to start over, it would've been much more interesting if Lara had decided to stick it to her snobby friends by adapting to her changes rather than wallowing in how unlucky she was. What if she'd done something like run for class president? Or became a plus-size model? Or had done something throughout the course of the book to demonstrate how she was growing accustomed to her new self. One thing I've learned is that you really are treated in the way that your attitude reflects. Yes, it's a cliche, but it's a good one. And this book was just immersed in negativity.
|
|
|
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
offensive, September 18, 2004
This book is a piece of crap. Seriously.
This girl, who was a winner at beauty contests, suddenly starts getting fat. And the bad thing is, because she is such a shallow person, you sort of WANT bad things to happen to her!
SOme examples of the offensiveness:
"The new me headed for the fat ladies' store: Lane Bryant....never, ever in a million years did I think I would be caught dead in that store, shopping for myself."
"...I used to feel so superior because you had fat thighs and big hips..."
"Not that I was even remotely attracted to him, anyway. I mean, he was just so....so fat."
"If she hadn't been so fat, she would have been pretty...."
"How pathetic. We had nothing in common. She probably ate all the time like Perry Jameson and deserved her fatness..."
"What I meant was obvious. He was gorgeous. She was huge. I really didn't need to say it out loud."
"terrific. I was the pinup for fat guys and blind guys."
I forced myself to read the whole thing, but I'm tossing it in the garbage now, so that no one else has to read this tripe.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|