Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Book - it's all about the characters, October 27, 2005
All good books are based on characters. No matter how good or bad the plot, if the characters aren't well developed and interesting, the book sucks. This book has great characters, fairly archetypal, but still well rounded and interesting.
As with all Brust books, this a mystery in the Arthur Conan Doyle/Sherlock Holmes style. Whether set in a fantasy or SciFi, the setting is just local color to flavor the meat of the book - solving the mystery.
This is one of those books I re-read about once a year. I always pick up something new each time I read it. The first time you read it, you might find it hard to keep up with all the characcters (four who work for the bar, four who live in the bar, and four ~bad guys.) With all mystery books, it's a fun read to see who dun it and why - it's not about defining the bad aspects of society who drove some charcters into the story line (although this IS explained...)
I'd recommend this or any Taltos book to anyone - regardless of if you read SciFi/Fantasy or not (I usually don't...) His local color is amazing - refined to the level of Twain or O Henry. The only downside is Brust clear obsession with hungarian cooking, as he pretty much lists each and every meal the charcters have in minute detail. This part gets on my nerves, but I'm not a foodie, so that's a big reason - but regardless, it's not annoying enough to spoil the yarn Brust spins.
This book would make a GREAT movie.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Jammin' Down the Space-Time Continuum, July 15, 2004
Brust is justly known for his Vlad Taltos fantasy series, and he has written several other books outside of that series that are well worth reading. This book is somewhat of a departure for him, being more science fiction oriented than fantasy. The main building block of this book is a rather unique restaurant that moves itself through space and time whenever a nuclear weapon is exploded in its near vicinity. Inside the restaurant is an Irish folk-song band that accidentally was caught up during the restaurant's first move. As the plot develops and the restaurant makes several moves through time and to other planets, the band begins to realize that they are part of an attempt to change future history by opposing a group that keeps going around starting nuclear wars. Not a bad concept, but it does lead to somewhat episodic patches, rather than being a linear whole. Much of the characterization comes through as individual flash-backs to defining events in their lives; present time dialogue and interaction with others is somewhat flimsy, but overall there is certainly enough `reality' to these characters to carry the story. Of course, as a band, their music intrudes in several places, which certainly provides some atmosphere, but I found Brust's description of some of this quite a bit over my head, not being a musician myself. I've run into this same problem with Emma Bull (who was a member of the same band as Brust) and Spider Robinson - it is simply very difficult to describe in written language what is almost totally an aural experience, but I'll give him good marks for a decent stab at trying. While the final resolution of the story made sense and was satisfying, I found that the basic motivation/rationale behind the war starting group just did not seem adequate justification for their actions. As this is central to the basic story, this is a fairly major flaw. Still, it's an enjoyable read, though not up to the standards he set in the Taltos set. --- Reviewed by Patrick Shepherd (hyperpat)
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brust at his best, January 31, 2001
I love this book! I can't believe it's out of print! I've taken to stockpiling Brust novels; they seem to come and go...The timeshifts--both literal and Faulknerian--keep this book fast and exciting. I love the casual descriptions of how the worlds change farther from Earth, the crack about how Star Trek still exists several centuries later, the really creepy ideas about irrational fear of AIDS, and, of course, the mystery of Who Is Cowboy Feng????? Brust nails the details (just like in the Vlad books, whose timeline is so well worked out that the first books refers to events that aren't explained for years), giving subtle hints about Sugar Bear and Cowboy Feng, so that when he does finally tell us, the resolution is incredibly satisfying, like being shown pieces of a jigsaw puzzle one at a time before finally seeing the whole.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|