|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Flawed, but still fun, weepy, July 19, 2004
By A Customer
The equivalent of a long-distance phone commercial, this book is a little overwrought and pretty manipulative, but if you want a decent tear-jerker, The Passions of Emma is worth your while. This is my first book by Williamson, whose writing style is overly dramatic and sentimental, but she tells a decent yarn if taken at face value. The story is from the point of view of Emma, a beyond believable beauty, who falls in love (reluctantly) with her best friend's husband. But the juice of the story is repression and longing, over which many characters torture themselves. There are a lot of elements that strain believability: the clairvoyant daughter, Emma's disregard of societal pressures, her sudden interest in poor people, a ghostly appearance, the sidebar into the loony bin. Really, it's got some serious melodramatic elements: falling for friend's husband, the dying consumptive, the several suicides, the handicapped sister, the evil mother, the big fire and on and on. Even the weather seems to cooperate: the weather sucks when people feel sad and the sun shines when they're happy. Storms conveniently arise at dramatic moments, rain beats down to illustrate despair. As the protagonist, Emma is a little too perfect (beautiful, rich, compassionate and artistic too!), and I thought the friend character Bria was a more compelling heroine, certainly braver and spunkier. As for Shay, the hero, he doesn't seem that extraordinary, what with the dirty hair and schlumpy clothes; it's difficult to see what Emma is so fired up about. I couldn't help thinking that from the point of view of some of the other characters, Emma and Shay don't seem so great. (Think about it, to those who've already read the book: Emma screws over her fiance pretty good, and she kinda ignores her sister a lot. And Shay gets over his wife pretty quickly, and he doesn't seem too tormented about the people he's killed.) But that's the thing: this book doesn't really hold up to examination, nor is it meant to be picked apart. If you can get over the (many) implausibilities, you will definitely cry by the end and feel rewarded by the love-conquers-all scenario. Read it quickly and without thinking too much.
|