Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
33 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
DM Cookbook CD ROM, April 16, 2002
By A Customer
Book is OK, but DON'T BUY THE CD-ROM! I dropped [a large amount] for what I thought would be a worth-while "self-learning" course on Data Mining programming in SAS. To my great disappointment, I found that while Olivia had included the code (which you can type in yourself), there was NO DATA PROVIDED, making the code all but useless (can't run the models with no data!). I e-mailed her asking for some kind of a sample data set. She agreed, but after months of begging she provided nothing whatsoever. Don't make the same mistake I did - STAY AWAY FROM THE CD-ROM!!!
|
|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wholesome - no frills - data mining cooking !!, December 19, 2001
By reading this book you should learn how to cook data mining applications...but if you have very little or no appreciation of data mining and customer relationship management (CRM), and you have never used SAS software, you'll probably end up burning your first few cakes or even worst your fingers !! As the author gives a very brief introduction to data mining, make sure before you even start reading this book that you have a grasp of statistical modelling and data mining in a CRM context, otherwise you will find the material presented in this book too much to take in at once, and worst, you may probably end up being put off building your own data mining applications. The author clearly has a solid statistical (read SAS) background, making this book a strong contender as one of the best books on data mining around, providing the reader with a number of useful recipes, practical examples and pragmatic data mining approaches which should be studied and understood in detail. Being a cookbook, the author's (or should I say the chef's) particular style may not suite your palate. In other words, you may not like the author's bias towards using logistic regression as the main data mining technique. As a result, you will not learn how to cook exotic dishes using ingredients such as neural networks. However, the choice to use logistic regression as the main statistical techniques pays off, as this allows the reader to start learning to cook robust/reliable meals (models), before cooking with the more exotic ingredients (techniques). The topics and interventions provided by the well-experienced contributors are in context with the author's material, strengthening the practical context in which data mining applications are presented. On a few occasions, I found that the author does not discuss figures and tabulated outputs in a straightforward way, inevitably affecting the readability of the book. Notwithstanding, the methodology and material presented has a considerable amount of depth and rigour, and the general themes are well structured and maintained throughout. Many figures and tabulated results are presented in the graphical output provided by the SAS system, which may be less appealing to you if you are not going to be using SAS. Also, many data mining software tools now available have significantly better graphical data presentation capabilities than those presented in this book, inevitably giving it a slightly dated look. Unsurprisingly, being the first version of the cookbook, there are a few typos (and one incorrect figure at the beginning of the first chapter). In summary, this book is not for the novice, but will be a book that you will want read more than once.
|
|
|
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A foundation book for middle-advanced analysts, March 26, 2002
Yes, its not for beginners or executives. That's great, because so many other books are aimed at glossing over the details for novices. This book gets down and dirty with exactly how one goes about analyzing and modeling data in applied marketing. It assumes some knowledge of data and basic analysis, but it also reviews assumptions along the way and points out "gotchas" for the less experienced. Yes, there is an overemphasis on Logistic Regression and a paucity of info on other techniques, but the Logistic Regression work is well done. Yes, it is very SAS based, but the code is not hard to translate to other systems. She doesn't spend as much time as I would prefer on explaining all the output that she presents, though its an excellent start. But she does provide specific details on ALL the steps, from getting and transforming data to how to present your results and use your model, things that are ignored in many other books. Sure, there are easy quibbles and minor errors throughout, but what tech book today is error free? So, if you are looking for the basic guidebook on just how one goes about "modeling", then this is the one. Its got a permanent place on my bookshelf, and is one of the standards I recommend along with Kimball, Pyle, and other "ya gotta have" books.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|