Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Series Taken as Whole!, February 27, 2001
The Saints of the Sword was a very entertaining book, though it does not measure up to its predecessor The Grand Design, which was an excellent book. The plot is exciting certainly, but characterization slips a bit. Biagio, Richius, Nicabar, etc. don't always maintain a consistency in character (particularly Biagio and Nicabar), though Mr. Marco tries to explain the radical shift in personalities from previous books. This shortcoming detracts from the solid characterization of previous books and also hampers the plot. Still, the book was exciting and the pages turned fast. If you read the first two books, I do recommend you read this one. Mr. Marco is one of the better writers out there and one waits with bated breath for his next book (which will not be about Nar - sadly). But he does leave the possiblility of other books taking place in Nar, though he has "other things on the burner right now." His words, not mine.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Conclusion cements Marco's status in Fantasy, August 20, 2001
John Marco should be very proud of himself. The concluding volume of his TYRANTS AND KINGS trilogy was a wonderful read and satisfying conclusion to one of the finest sequences in recent fantasy literature. THE SAINTS OF THE SWORD maintained the high quality of the previous two novels in the series. The action of the battles and interactions of the characters were superbly drawn. One of the themes that came up in this concluding volume was the notion that people can change; redeem themselves. The Emperor Biagio was cast as one of the main villains in the previous two novels, but throughout The Saints of the Sword, Biaigio constantly tried to prove that he was a changed man. He made apologies for his previous dastardly acts and was truthful in Saints, something he was not in previous volumes. Biaigo is a reformed drug user, something that touches upon one of the problems of society today. Herein, Mr. Marco has tied a notion in the fantastic setting with a real world issue, lending credence and believability to his characters and their story. The character or Richius Vantran, who was the primary character in the previous books takes a step back as a secondary, yet very important character. The series began with Richiuss tale, and while not as primary a character in this novel, the story ends with the resolution of his initial struggle. The perspective change of Richius as primary character from the earlier volumes and almost a living legend in this volume was enjoyable. The cast of characters was sizeable, but not overwhelming, there were new characters playing big parts such as Alazarian and returning characters such as Jelena. Mr. Marco balance everything expertly, the drama, the passion and the war. Occasional bits of humor helped to highlight Mr. Marcos deftness at showing the humanity in a fantastic story of magic, war and fantasy. John Marco has told a compelling, plausible tale with sparkles of magic and wonderful battle scenes. He is one of a new group of superb writers of Speculative Fiction that should be read and held up as the best of the genre.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
John Marco Continues To Hone And Refine His Skills, March 6, 2001
John Marco has continued to improve upon his tale, in "Saints of the Sword" building upon the strengths of the earlier two books, while stepping back from some of their weaknesses. In particular, the author has skillfully expanded upon his use of multiple point of view used to such good effect in "Grand Design," adding new and strong characters with the introduction of Alazrian, Kasrin and Elrad Leth, as well as further developing the strong roles played earlier by Biagio, Nicabar and the Queen of Liss. Richius Vantran, the dominating protagonist in "The Jackal of Nar," steps even further to the background, a choice that I applaud, as I had always found his characterization mildly problematic, with his vacillating, at times verging on overwrought resistance to his role in events. In many ways, compared to Simon in "Grand Design," or Biagio or Kasrin in this work, Richius' actions and motives appear weak and not as successfully realized, threatening his character with being overshadowed as new characters come to the forefront. This was particularly true in the case of Simon in book two, who in many ways reflected many of Richius' dilemmas, but with greater strength, clarity and sympathy of purpose. I missed his presence here.Marco has also refined his use of political intrigue, in many ways this series beginning more and more to mirror George R.R. Martin's ongoing "Song of Ice and Fire," without seeming a knock off, though lacking the latter's scope and depth of detail and characterization. Nonetheless, those of you that have enjoyed Martin's current series will likely find much to admire here, as long as you do not draw your comparisons too closely. After all, this would be unfair to Mr. Marco, who is a relative newcomer, whereas George R.R. Martin has been writing successfully for a couple decades. But as John Marco has been building more upon his strengths than his weaknesses, as evidenced here, one greatly anticipates his future. Marco continues to at times make his plot too tidy, certain characters, as another reviewer has noted, too readily changing their stripes or accepting changes in circumstance. It is difficult to entirely accept Biagio's change of heart, despite the author's efforts to convince us, and Nicabar's ready acceptance of Kasrin seems too easy to be wholly credible. Other incidents occur with similar ease or coincidence. Finally, Richius' pangs of guilt have by now worn more than thin, though, with his little stage time, we are not again forced too much into dragging his whining bones through the fire. It would appear that the author has already begun a new work, evidently not a direct outgrowth from this series. However, for those of you who will miss Lucel-Lor and Nar, there are a number of hints at the conclusion of this work that leave more than ample room for a return sometime later. In any event, as this series is one of the more impressive debuts I have read, I will eagerly look forward to Mr. Marco's next project. I can only promise great expectations for the future.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|